News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Denying Russia's Only Strategy for Success by libertine on Sunday May 05, 2024 @11:01AM (#40265378)
So, a world where people forgot about History and the outcomes of appeasing dictators, and all that was achieved with the UN was pointless, so let's go back to a time of military expansionism.
Re:Denying Russia's Only Strategy for Success by hollerith on Sunday May 05, 2024 @11:43AM (#40265674)
I don't think the verdict of "History" is as clear as you seem to think it is. Finland and Austria for example definitely appeased the dictator Stalin and his successor dictators for decades. They were careful not to join NATO or the EU. They consulted the dictator (or an authorized underling) on all defense decisions. These decades of appeasement did not result in an attack or a loss of territory.

If I had been a citizen of Finland or Austria during the relevant decades, I think I would've been angry if my government had decided against appeasing the Soviet Union.

The strategic situation has changed and now Finland's joining NATO carries very little risk of an attack from the dictator from the east.

Re:Denying Russia's Only Strategy for Success by libertine on Sunday May 05, 2024 @01:11PM (#40266415)
> I don't think the verdict of "History" is as clear as you seem to think it is.

Well, I think it is - because the verdict was documents signed by Russia that stated clearly that each country is entitled to its own sovereignty, territorial integrity, foreign policy, alliances, and strategic decisions.

The documents are:

- UN Charter

- Helsinki Accords

- Charter of Paris for a New Europe

- Russia–NATO Founding Act

If Finland made their strategic decisions to appease Putin, including not joining NATO, I don't know. And it would be great if you could share some sources on this information because it made me curious. I'm finding it hard to believe Finland was on a tight leash from Russia (especially because they rebuilt and maintained their military without restrictions).

Re:Denying Russia's Only Strategy for Success by hollerith on Sunday May 05, 2024 @01:46PM (#40266693)
>If Finland made their strategic decisions to appease Putin . . .

That is not what I said: I said Finland and Austria appeased the Soviets in the ways I described from 1945 to at least 1990.

Re:Denying Russia's Only Strategy for Success by libertine on Sunday May 05, 2024 @02:16PM (#40266957)
I see what you're saying. But as I stated, the world changed, and Russia (and even the USSR) changed during that period and signed the documents to marked such change.

Going back in time just because "Russia has nukes" doesn't seem like a very viable option - not to mention that others also have nukes.

Re:Denying Russia's Only Strategy for Success by johng on Sunday May 05, 2024 @11:38AM (#40265640)
Nukes. People are afraid of provoking him too much to where he uses nukes. It's that simple.
Re:Denying Russia's Only Strategy for Success by libertine on Sunday May 05, 2024 @01:01PM (#40266336)
So everyone will be bound to a psychopath because he has the world hostage under the threat of nuclear destruction.

That ain't much of a world worth living in, now is it?

Re:Denying Russia's Only Strategy for Success by saikia81 on Sunday May 05, 2024 @04:13PM (#40267832)
The suffering of the few keeps the many safe. This is not a solution, but a reality as old as the existence of mayor destructive power.

Mass weapons of destruction have just changed the scale of the game. We have never been closer to the great filter.