News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jane Street is big. Like, big by znpy on Thursday May 02, 2024 @07:55AM (#40235089)
> Setting criteria such as having an Ivy League degree or a CS degrees with GPA over 3.8 was a logical way to achieve this goal.

It wasn't a "logical way", it was an "easy way". That's classist at the very least.

Re:Jane Street is big. Like, big by SkipperCat on Thursday May 02, 2024 @08:10AM (#40235218)
To a certain extent, you are correct. However, companies like Jane Street need to filter and doing so based on colleges is the most efficient when other factors are all equal. Top tier colleges strive to base their admittance on performance and strive to be racially and culturally diverse. This gives Jane Street the ability to say they filter on the same criteria.

I'm all ears if you have a better system that is more efficient. I'd also add that I went to a State college and my resume would have been tossed if I applied as a starting engineer too.

Re:Jane Street is big. Like, big by gadders on Thursday May 02, 2024 @08:20AM (#40235317)
>>and strive to be racially and culturally diverse

But not socio-economically.

Re:Jane Street is big. Like, big by iknownthing on Thursday May 02, 2024 @09:02AM (#40235703)
I'd say just go with GPA.
Re:Jane Street is big. Like, big by tombert on Thursday May 02, 2024 @09:25AM (#40235973)
I kind of agree, but I do wonder if that’s largely confirmation bias though; they hire the best engineers they can find from an Ivy League, don’t bother even looking at decent state school people, then the Ivy League engineers they hire do well and they assume it must because they went to an Ivy League school.

I know that fancy colleges like to say that they strive to base admittance on performance, and I believe that’s true to an extent, but it certainly seems like they make an exception for students who come from a lot of money. I’ve mentioned this before but think about any politician that you think is un utter moron, and there’s still a reasonably good chance that they went to an Ivy League because they come from a rich family.

And it annoys me that people act like Ivy League schools are the only ones that accept based on performance. I applied to a bunch of state schools as a teenager and I got declined by a bunch of them. We can wax philosophical about why I was declined but I doubt it was personal, just that they probably didn’t think I would perform well based on some metric.

Re:Jane Street is big. Like, big by lupire on Thursday May 02, 2024 @08:47AM (#40235561)
You seem to be conflating "logical" with "moral".
Re:Jane Street is big. Like, big by eddieroger on Thursday May 02, 2024 @09:01AM (#40235691)
It makes logical sense - if they look over their staff and search for commonalities amongst successful employees, and trends like school or CS degree and GPA stand out, then it's logical to assume that will predict further success and thin the pool. It's a jerk move, sure, but it can be both.