News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google workers fired for protesting Israeli contract file... by weatherlite on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @08:51AM (#40222454)
What's the deal with the ethnostate ? I mean, why is a Palestinian ethnostate a good thing but a Jewish ethnostate is horrible?
Re:Google workers fired for protesting Israeli contract file... by someotherperson on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @02:24PM (#40227170)
Nobody advocates for a Palestinian ethnostate, it's a concession that was made to resolve the issues after the Jewish refusal of a bi-national solution that would have Jews as the minority.
Re:Google workers fired for protesting Israeli contract file... by weatherlite on Thursday May 02, 2024 @12:22AM (#40232670)
Most Palestinians want a Palestinian ethnostate from the river to the sea.
Re:Google workers fired for protesting Israeli contract file... by someotherperson on Thursday May 02, 2024 @12:46AM (#40232783)
Complete nonsense. The Palestinian National Charter doesn't restrict citizenship to only Arabs, it explicitly keeps citizenship for pre-Israeli Jews and you can bet a million dollars that it wouldn't restrict the Afro-Palestinians, Turkmen or any other groups. The only restriction in the charter for citizenship is for Jews that moved there after the formation of Israel.
Re:Google workers fired for protesting Israeli contract file... by weatherlite on Thursday May 02, 2024 @03:41AM (#40233693)
Israel doesn't restrict citizenship to only Jews, it is probably more heterogenous than Palestine. Israel is 20% Arab.
Re:Google workers fired for protesting Israeli contract file... by racional on Thursday May 02, 2024 @02:24PM (#40239723)
Israel doesn't restrict citizenship to only Jews,

But its laws extend greatly preferential treatment to (certain kinds of) Jews, of course.

"Jews" (or those deemed as such by certain disputed criteria) may naturalize, but with onerous requirements: demonstrating proficiency in Hebrew being one of them (that "other" indigenous language, Arabic, or other common languages of pre-1947 inhabitants such as Armenian just won't cut it). Also, if you're a citizen and you marry a non-national, citizenship is automatically granted -- unless that person that person has the misfortune of being an inhabitant of the West Bank or Gaza (which includes many descendants of people expelled from what is now Israel in 1947-1949 and afterwards of course).

Israel probably more heterogeneous than Palestine.

Given the 517k or so non-indigenous squatters (nearly all of them fit in this category, anyway) in Area C, and the 240k or so non-Arab residents of illegally occupied (that is to say, "still Palestine" per international law) East Jerusalem -- this is a highly untenable statement to make.

I don't see how [the Right of Return] isn't the will to create an ethnostate, it's a mirror image of Zionism.

In human terms, one could also look it as an attempt to restore basic dignity and liberty to these folks, more or less on par to what is provided to prospective citizens of Jewish ancestry via the Law of Return.

Re:Google workers fired for protesting Israeli contract file... by weatherlite on Friday May 03, 2024 @09:27AM (#40247431)
> In human terms, one could also look it as an attempt to restore basic dignity and liberty to these folks, more or less on par to what is provided to prospective citizens of Jewish ancestry via the Law of Return.

I agree. So then I don't get the demonization against Zionism. Sometimes ethnostates make sense due to special circumstances in history and in the present.

Re:Google workers fired for protesting Israeli contract file... by racional on Friday May 03, 2024 @02:25PM (#40250701)
I don't see most critiques of Zionism as "demonization", though I would agree they are sometimes misinformed and involve lousy choices of wording and phrasing.

Many of most serious (and highly informed) of these critiques come from Jewish and Israeli sources, BTW.

Re:Google workers fired for protesting Israeli contract file... by weatherlite on Sunday May 05, 2024 @06:58AM (#40263872)
I don't know if just because someone is Israeli or Jewish it makes his opinion that much more valid - especially when people cherry pick the views that already conform to their opinion and ignore all the rest (e.g if the person is an Israeli anti zionist they will listen to him, if he's an Israeli Zionist they will cancel him). As for the criticism itself, too much of the time (imo) it focuses on Israel as a uniquely colonizing and evil entity in the world and is completely one sided. One side is totally evil (the Israeli side), has no business existing and should self dismantle or get help from the world in dismantling. The other side (the Palestinian side) can pretty much do no wrong.
Re:Google workers fired for protesting Israeli contract file... by racional on Monday May 06, 2024 @01:29PM (#40277094)
If I may simplify what you're saying to what seems to be the gist:

[The criticism] focuses on Israel as a uniquely colonizing entity

In essence the criticism seems to boil down to this:

Israel indisputably maintains the longest-running military occupation in the world, at present. Which it is aggressively expanding in both the West Bank and Gaza, as we speak.

Its attitude towards the Arab population has been ineluctably colonial from the very start of the movement. As expressed in most every piece of Zionist writing you will find, and the recorded statements from basically everyone involved. And then the large-scale massacres and violent displacements starting in 1947.

In a supposedly post-colonial world, there are very few countries with an analogous situation or history.

Is this the criticism you're referring to?

Re:Google workers fired for protesting Israeli contract file... by racional on Friday May 03, 2024 @06:14PM (#40252979)
Sometimes ethnostates make sense due to special circumstances in history and in the present.

Hypothetically. But when established by force on top of other people's land, not so much.

Re:Google workers fired for protesting Israeli contract file... by someotherperson on Thursday May 02, 2024 @02:46PM (#40239979)
I personally never said Israel is an ethnostate, but a Palestinian state is definitely not a mirror image of Zionism. It was never historically monoethnic and issues with Jews is a post-Israeli thing. Not to discount pre-Israel antisemitism or the Arab nationalism movement, but national identity was always tied to a pan-ethnicity rather than religion or bloodline.

Maybe a simple example of this is Armenians (Christian, non-Arab) who would receive full citizenship in Palestine but are still stateless today in Israel[0].

[0] https://apnews.com/article/jerusalem-armenian-community-land...

Re:Google workers fired for protesting Israeli contract file... by weatherlite on Friday May 03, 2024 @09:28AM (#40247444)
Palestinians aren't an ethnicity then? But Jews are?
Re:Google workers fired for protesting Israeli contract file... by someotherperson on Saturday May 04, 2024 @02:32AM (#40255421)
I'm a bit confused by the response, but 'Palestinian' is not an ethnicity, no. 'Jews' are an ethnoreligious group.
Re:Google workers fired for protesting Israeli contract file... by weatherlite on Saturday May 04, 2024 @02:45AM (#40255484)
I'm a bit confused by your response as well, Palestinians are an ethnic group.
Re:Google workers fired for protesting Israeli contract file... by racional on Thursday May 02, 2024 @02:42PM (#40239925)
Some do, but reliable percentage data on this topic seems to be hard to come by.

And many Israelis (and the current extremist regime) want the exact reverse of course. And make no apologies for this fact.

Re:Google workers fired for protesting Israeli contract file... by tptacek on Thursday May 02, 2024 @08:43PM (#40242866)
That's true, regarding the fringe neo-Kahanist "Greater Israel" coalition Netanyahu assembled. But as you know, it's also true of Hamas; that's the "some" you're referring to. Issue polling is tricky, but it's likely that a majority of Israelis oppose the positions of Netayahu's coalition.

(It's probably true that a majority of Gazans at this point oppose the Hamas program; it's very difficult to know, because both Israel and Hamas have done their best to make sure that the opinions of ordinary Gazans are suppressed).

Re:Google workers fired for protesting Israeli contract file... by racional on Friday May 03, 2024 @05:21PM (#40252526)
Not to quibble, but because you like to nerd out on these things:

Maximalist land claims from the Israeli side go back much further than the Kahanist movement - specifically to the Revisionist Zionism movement founded circa 1925. Which arguably became the de-facto position of Israel after the 1967 war up to the current day (basically: "We weren't really planning to grab all this territory, but being as things somehow ended up that way we might as well keep it, because after all it's ours anyway.") And in any case was explicitly the ideology of the Herut Party, which eventually morphed into Likud.

Hamas's own position in regard to inverse claims is less clear, given the (somewhat) conflicting language in the key passage everyone cites (Paragraph 20) from the 2017 Charter. By my own reading, that paragraph is actually quite straightforward, and tilts decisively towards the "formula of national consensus" re: 1967 borders.

Then again, that was the Hamas of 7 years ago. Given their penchant for piling up civilian corpses the minute their fighters assemble on enemy territory in sufficient numbers to do so; and that "explanations" for their actions have been terse and sparse since then -- I'm not sure what they currently believe.

Re:Google workers fired for protesting Israeli contract file... by tptacek on Friday May 03, 2024 @05:43PM (#40252727)
Hamas is an overtly genocidal organization; their charter says it in plain language, and their deliberate massacre of civilians on October 7 ratifies it. There's no argument to have here. Say that Gazans aren't Hamas, and cannot be collectively punished for the actions of a psychotic millenarian military cult, and I'll agree wholeheartedly with you.
Re:Google workers fired for protesting Israeli contract file... by racional on Saturday May 04, 2024 @12:51AM (#40254945)
Hamas is an overtly genocidal organization; their charter says it in plain language

The 2017 Charter absolutely does not, and if you think it does you'll have to cite specific paragraphs to back up this view. In fact it specifically rejects antisemitism and goes on further to say:

Hamas rejects the persecution of any human being or the undermining of his or her rights on nationalist, religious or sectarian grounds.

Re:Google workers fired for protesting Israeli contract file... by tptacek on Saturday May 04, 2024 @12:44PM (#40258784)
They just launched a genocidal attack on Israeli women, children, and grandparents. I don't have to parse the distinctions between their overtly genocidal charter, which they didn't disavow, and their new document. They re-avowed the original charter on October 7. Only on Twitter is this a live debate.

You know what else happened with Hamas in 2017? A huge internal conflict and series of purges that left Yehya Sinwar, who is a literal Bond villain, in charge of the organization. It's wild to see anybody try to rehabilitate Hamas with "2017".

(We're still just nerding out on this, I assume).

Re:Google workers fired for protesting Israeli contract file... by weatherlite on Sunday May 05, 2024 @07:19AM (#40263994)
Zionists accepted the 1947 partition plan (and as far as I know Peel's 1937 plan to a much smaller territory). The Palestinian leadership rejected both outright. In addition Zionists proposed the 2 state solution twice (Camp David 2001, Olmert's plan in 2008) to be rejected twice. To this day there hasn't been a clear consent by a Palestinian leader to let go of the Palestinian right of return, nor has there been a prominent Palestinian leader that accepted any kind of border resolution before the Palestinian Nakba. I've never seen it, would be glad to be shown otherwise. So it's pretty much a long trend of Palestinian rejectionism for any kind of solution.

You are cherry picking the facts that agree with your world view and ignoring the rest.

Re:Google workers fired for protesting Israeli contract file... by racional on Monday May 06, 2024 @11:05PM (#40281935)
Aside from this being an unrealistic description of events -- it's also quite a change of subject. We weren't talking about the failure of the Oslo process (which had multiple factors apart from the cartoonish depiction above), or the various failures by both sides at any other stage in this slow-motion human catastrophe. And certainly not about some alternate fandom history of what could have happened in 1947 or 1937.

You can cherry pick all you want, as long as you stick to the subject.