News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by Chris2048 on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @06:13AM (#40209204)
The other person isn't necessarily waiting for the response. At the least, its a communication that you are about to ask them something, i.e. check back here in the next minute or so while I type out my question.

Also, "Hi" is a good way of finding out if a person is present, sometimes you might ask to call them instead of typing your question.

It also might be the case there are multiple people who can answer the question, so you want send out "hi" to a few of them to see who will respond right now.

Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by smeej on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @06:24AM (#40209302)
If you might ask to call, just ask to call. "Hi! I have a question about X that would be easier to explain on a call. Do you have time to hop on a call for 5 mins?" is a better way to start the conversation by a factor of about 10,000.

You can even send this to 3 or 4 people and let anyone who doesn't respond first say you caught so-and-so first and are good to go now. Or just delete the message.

Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by Chris2048 on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @06:30AM (#40209360)
I would not send out multiple "Do you have time to hop on a call for 5 mins?" b/c then they might call me before I delete the message.
Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by reg_dunlop on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @06:36AM (#40209407)
You don't have to answer every call you receive.

Then, you could send another completely Async communique detailing why you did not answer, which would then teach the other person to respond with a yes/no/silence/emoji, etc

Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by smeej on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @06:38AM (#40209437)
Who on earth calls without confirming you meant right now?

But even if it happens, take the call, decline any others that come in, and explain in 5 minutes. You've still saved everybody time.

Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by vundercind on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @07:08AM (#40209651)
Who doesn’t let the person who requested the call initiate the call?
Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by wepple on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @06:21AM (#40209267)
Not a single one of these is a valid reason; they all add a distraction round-trip and getting straight to the point achieves the same outcome without the RTT
Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by CipherThrowaway on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @06:46AM (#40209496)
> At the least, its a communication that you are about to ask them something, i.e. check back here in the next minute or so while I type out my question.

This is part of what makes it such poor etiquette. You've created this ambiguous, open-ended distraction for the other person. You expect them to divert focus away from what they're doing so they can poll the chat channel waiting for you to get your thoughts in order.

At least include some context so they have a better idea of what you're about to ask.

Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by Chris2048 on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @01:55PM (#40213925)
> You expect them to divert focus away from what they're doing so they can poll the chat channel

They don't need to poll a channel, most chat applications will pop up a notification when a message appears.

What they can poll is the chat app icon, and to not be AFK in the next few minutes.

What would be the purpose of providing more context before actually asking a question?

Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by gregoriol on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @06:19AM (#40209258)
Chat is natively async: you don't need to know if people are there to ask a question, they might answer at any point in the next few minutes or hours.

If you do post just "hi" in a message, your question should come within seconds after.

Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by Chris2048 on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @06:33AM (#40209384)
true, but the same is true for email.

I use IM as more informal, (AND/)OR conversations with likely back-and-forth, that may require the other person to be present to be of use.

Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by gregoriol on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @08:08AM (#40210122)
The risk is that by the time they get back to the chat and answer your "Hi", you might be gone and so their "Hello" answer might be useless to sync you both. Examples others provide to request a timeframe to discuss the subject would be much more efficient
Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by smeej on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @06:40AM (#40209449)
So ask them for a time they're available to do that. Don't just ping them and hope to get lucky. Even if they have time to send you a "Hi" back, that doesn't mean they have time to talk to you, so you're going to have to ask that anyway.
Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by vundercind on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @07:13AM (#40209694)
“Hey—have you got some time to chat about Fizz today? [Optional second sentence indicating level of urgency in your part]”

If they don’t get back immediately, you can safely assume “right now” is not a time they have. If they actually don’t know shit about Fizz and you need to bug someone else, they can communicate that when convenient without needing you at your keyboard when they do it, because at least they know WTF you want to chat about.

There is no benefit to just “hello.”

Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by nkrisc on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @06:25AM (#40209306)
Or you can achieve exactly the same thing by just sending whatever message you were going to send anyway.
Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by Chris2048 on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @06:31AM (#40209365)
But I might not send it anyway, that's the issue.
Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by smeej on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @06:42AM (#40209466)
You might be gathering this by everyone's responses to every single one of your comments, but you're using this tool fundamentally differently than everyone else and than it's meant to be used, and you're doing it in a way that inconveniences everyone who has to use it to interact with you.

Since it's a communication tool, you'll get better results if you use it like it was designed and like everyone else does.

Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by Chris2048 on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @09:41AM (#40210875)
I gather by the responses that there are a lot of HNers that feel strongly a certain way, but I do not confuse HN, or the participants of a pile-on, with "everyone"; nor am I fond of promoting this reddit style group-think.

I'm not asking for a poll, but reasoning (which is the explicitly stated purpose for this forum). If a thousand (apparently annoyed) HNers agreed on something but could not reason why, I wouldn't care for it. In fact, I've seen exactly this kind of cultish thinking among developers specifically, hence the existence of flamewars over notation preference.

The tone of some of these replies also suggest to me there's some projection going on, that also makes me defer to the explicit reasoning provided rather than the sentiment.

> you're using this tool fundamentally differently than everyone else and than it's meant to be used, and you're doing it in a way that inconveniences everyone who has to use it to interact with you

I disagree, but if you've already made up your mind, there's no opportunity for discourse here.

Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by smeej on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @11:45AM (#40212346)
People are replying to you explaining why your reasons don't support your arguments, and explaining what the real reasons for using it differently are.

There's no opportunity for discourse, but it's apparently because your idea of "reason" is also different from everybody else's.

Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by Chris2048 on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @12:02PM (#40212562)
> explaining why your reasons don't support your arguments, and explaining what the real reasons

Their opinion differs to mine, and I also disagree with some of the counter-arguments.

Describing their responses as "real" versus mine is evidence that you've made up your mind, and are no longer objective about the topic.

> your idea of "reason" is also different from everybody else's

reasoning can be flawed or incorrect, but you are implying mine isn't reasoning at all. Care to back that claim up?

Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by smeej on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @12:30PM (#40212869)
First, let's define "reason": a statement offered in explanation or justification [0]

> sometimes you might ask to call them instead of typing your question.

Does not explain or justify. Is not a reason. The possibility that you might ask to call has no bearing on whether or not you should start with "Hello," because if you are going to ask to call, you would be better served by just asking to call in the initial message, and if you are not going to ask to call, you would be better served by just asking your question in the initial message.

> It also might be the case there are multiple people who can answer the question, so you want [to] send out "hi" to a few of them to see who will respond right now.

Does not explain or justify. Is not a reason. Whether you are going to send the message to multiple people or only one has no bearing on whether or not you should start with "Hello," because if you are going to send the message to multiple people, you would be better served by sending your actual question. Even if you get more than one answer, you can just thank the people for their responses, if you don't manage to delete the extra messages from other people. If you are only going to send the question to one person, you would be better served by asking your actual question, so they can move the conversation forward when they reply.

> I would not send out multiple "Do you have time to hop on a call for 5 mins?" b/c then they might call me before I delete the message.

Does not explain or justify. Is not a reason. Whether more than one person might call you has no bearing on whether you should start with "Hello," because if more than one person does try to call you before you have a chance to delete the message, you are still better served by having them know why you wanted to talk, since they can better appreciate why you would have sent multiple messages and taken the soonest call, and if no more than one person tries to call you, you are still better served by having that person know why you want to talk to them before they call.

> I use IM as more informal, (AND/)OR conversations with likely back-and-forth, that may require the other person to be present to be of use.

Does not explain or justify. Is not a reason. Whether you need someone to be present to have a back-and-forth conversation has no bearing on whether you should start with "Hello," because if you do need someone to be present, you would be better served by having them already know what you might need them to be present to discuss, and if you do not need someone to be present, you would be better served by having them know as soon as possible what information you need from them.

None of your "reasons" explain or justify. None of them actually have any bearing on whether you should or should not start a conversation with "Hello." The answer is the same regardless of your "reasons." They're not even germane to the discussion, much less are they "reasons."

[0] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/reason

Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by Chris2048 on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @02:26PM (#40214396)
So, something is (or isn't) "reason" based on your judgement on what is reasonable or justified? What if you are wrong?

> The possibility that you might ask to call has no bearing on whether or not you should start with "Hello," because if you are going to ask to call, you would be better served by just asking to call

If they respond (within a minute, say), you might ask for a call. If they don't, you instead type out the question, and check back later. Hence the response (asking for call, vs question) depends on the answer to "Hi".

> if you are going to send the message to multiple people, you would be better served by sending your actual question

Why? If someone else is answering, I explicitly don't want another person to start working on the question. If anyone one responds while I've already asked the question, I can just tell them I no longer need help - they waste little to no time or focus working on finding an answer.

> Even if you get more than one answer, you can just thank the people for their responses

This seems like a much bigger waste of other peoples time.

> you are still better served by having them know why you wanted to talk, since they can better appreciate why you would have sent multiple messages

why am I "better served" by this? They don't need to know what I might have asked, it's a distraction for them.

> if you do need someone to be present, you would be better served by having them already know what you might need them to be present to discuss

If they aren't present, the discussion may not happen.

Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by smeej on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @07:45PM (#40217849)
No, according to the dictionary, something is a reason if it explains or justifies your previous statement. If its answer has no bearing whatsoever on the previous statement, it's not a reason. It's just a statement.

If you can give a single example of a situation where saying "Hello" instead of actually including your question, by all means make it, but you are the only one who can't see how poorly you communicate.

Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by Chris2048 on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @07:56PM (#40217933)
Great, you disagree. Now kindly stop commenting.
Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by CipherThrowaway on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @06:48AM (#40209512)
That's even worse. You're sending out rounds of "Hi's" to multiple people, distracting them to prepare them for a question you might not even ask?

Candidly, you sound like an incredibly selfish communicator.

Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by Chris2048 on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @09:32AM (#40210810)
let's say you go up to a group of people working on desks.

You ask "Is anyone free to help me with <X>?".

Is this a "selfish communication"?

What about messages posted in a group chat?

Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by smeej on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @12:37PM (#40212977)
No, that is a reasonable way to ask for help.

What would be "selfish communication" would be to walk up to a group of people working at desks and just say, "Hello," and stand there awkwardly waiting for them to acknowledge you.

Same thing with a group chat. Asking, "Is anyone free to help me with X?" is a reasonable way to ask for help. Sending a whole group of people, "Hello," is a waste of everyone's time.

Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by Chris2048 on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @01:59PM (#40214013)
This was a question for CipherThrowaway specifically.
Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by CipherThrowaway on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @01:55AM (#40219981)
It definitely can be. The presence of uncontrolled interruptions is a common complaint in open offices. Individual employees tend to manage this issue with noise cancelling headphones. I've also seen eng managers create dedicated periods of focus time or designate a focus room for this reason.

But it doesn't matter either way, because in-person is a different medium to text with a different dynamic. If you'd read the article, you'd see this is directly called out:

> You're trying to be polite by not jumping right into the request, like you would do in person or on the phone. But Chat is neither of those things.

A group message is still chat, but it is a different dynamic to sending out individual messages. Can you honestly say - in good faith - that you don't see the differences between directly and personally addressing someone, versus addressing a group? Try to put yourself in other people's place and imagine how these things might be different.

I also agree with the sibling comment that walking up to a bunch of people working and saying "Hello" with no context then waiting around for a response would be poor etiquette. If you can see that people aren't working - that they are taking a break or already idly chatting - then I would say it's fine. But these are the types of rich context clues that you get from in-person communication that you usually don't get from chat.

Your reply from elsewhere:

> They don't need to poll a channel, most chat applications will pop up a notification when a message appears.

It was you that said the purpose of "hi" was to have them check back. If the notification were sufficient on its own, then you wouldn't need to say "hi" at all. They'll receive a notification once you ask your question either way. The selfishness is in the asymmetry of the interaction. The standalone "hi" is the lowest effort and highest ambiguity way of interrupting someone and asking for their attention.

> What would be the purpose of providing more context before actually asking a question?

So that people have some idea of how important your question is going to be, how long it might take to answer, whether it is relevant to the work they're currently doing and so on. Maybe you see a "hi" in chat and it doesn't matter to you either way. If that's the case, you are probably a minority among technical workers.

Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by nkrisc on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @07:05AM (#40209631)
Why would you message everyone “hello” if you’re not going to send the message?

“Hello”

“Yes?”

“Nevermind.”

What?

Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by Chris2048 on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @09:32AM (#40210812)
What is the implied delay between "Hello" and "Yes?"?
Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by smeej on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @12:36PM (#40212949)
Does it matter? Whether it's instantaneous or happens over the course of hours, that type of communication contributes nothing to anything.
Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by Chris2048 on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @05:19PM (#40216486)
Yes, but there is already a thread between you and me specifically on that topic so there's no need to answer other comments.
Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by reg_dunlop on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @06:32AM (#40209374)
As others have said, don't ask to ask. And don't make me have to divide my attention, checking to see or waiting for something you may or may not eventually ask.

Oh by the way, I have a follow up question....

Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by addicted on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @06:27AM (#40209321)
That is such a ridiculously inconsiderate approach.

Why can’t you just say “hey, are you available for a call now?” Instead?

Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by Chris2048 on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @12:06PM (#40212592)
"Hi, are you free?" seems just as good to me, and mostly equivalent (without reference to a call).
Re:Don't Just Say "Hello" in Chat by smeej on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @12:34PM (#40212920)
Maybe we need to approach this a different way to get through to you.

What is the advantage of asking, "Hi, are you free?" over asking, "Hi, are you free to talk for X number of minutes about Y?" Can you think of a single advantage?