The only for DevDiv to regain its honour is by reminding Windows Divisino that the oxygen Windows lives on is in DevDiv creating new developers. Given that VS11 Express is only a toy, and requires a presumed $99 annual subscription to deploy, it is going to be difficult for any students to justify.
This civil war is going to maim the Windows ecosystem at a time when it is especially weak.
Regarding students, though, Microsoft has DreamSpark, which looks like BizSpark for students (all the way down to high school students, apparently). They can get free access to VS and at least some subset of operating systems.
Its rarely because they knowingly like it.
That's the opinion I've managed to deduce after working with over 200 heavy vs users over 10 years.
Visual Studio is a fine IDE that has a lot of things going for it. Hell, now that I write Obj-C for a living I wish Xcode was more like VS (especially when it comes to stability).
In contrast, I'd rather marathon American Idol than use Eclipse for a single day.
I am not really a GUI person.
I ... loved Visual Studio + VB6 for UI heavy apps. The programming language was kinda lame but it was just about good enough, and the form designer tools were excellent.
I debugged using whatever the (now lost from my memory) appropriate colloqualism for printing to stderr was, because yeah, sorry, I'm like that. But I loved it for everything else even so.
Do not underestimate the awesomeness that is Visual Studio once you've had time to develop enough Stockholm to ignor the crazy quirks.
Eclipse is fine when you get used to it. It has a fairly hefty learning curve but when you get there, it's awesome.
Recent additions include integrated Git, code intelligence so good that it understands C++ templates, in-IDE static analysis, one-keystroke to fix typos in identifiers, etc.
No scripting. Cretinous window layout facilities. No search and replace in selection. No mixed source/disassembly view. Registers view disappears when as you debug. No keyboard shortcut for rectangular selections. Code browsing menu 'thing' doesn't show structs. That stupid log navigator is too damn narrow, and has a proportional font. Pasting of rectangular selections doesn't work. No column/line number display. Lacks numerous basic simple text manipulation commands.
As a Mac dev for about two decades, I find that Xcode has taken a massive downhill slide latel. It went from merely mediocre to nearly unusable in a remarkably short amount of time.
But for doing lower-level native Win32 code, the kind of thing Microsoft seems to be wishing would just go away, I prefer a command line compiler. Linux and Mac are generally much better for that kind of development.
I deal with large (1Mloc+) 10 year+ old codebases in C#/ASP.Net and it is in no way capable of handling a large project without chopping it into miniscule assemblies and having solutions for each.
The IDE is monolithic enough to have severe usability and performance problems. It doesn't scale well and therefore is a risk if you want to continue using the platform for many years.
One could guess that insufficient of their customers have codebases like that for them to care over whichever feature requests got priority instead.
But, um, ow. I feel for you.
We got rid of visual svn and resharper as they made it less reliable.
Disclaimer: I work for Microsoft.
Your assertions about why developers like Visual Studio are nonsense... I like it over Sublime Text, RubyMine, WebStorm, gedit, XCode, and a slew of other tools / editors I've used. Why?
Because it has a great extension ecosystem (ReSharper, dotCover, TestDriven.NET, Git Extensions, VisualSVN), has by far and above the best live debugging tools on the planet, the best code completion, IntelliSense, and a slew of other features that make my development faster and easier.
And I say this as someone who's done plenty of C# in MonoDevelop too, without the aid of many of those VS features.
So no, Visual Studio hasn't jedi-mind-tricked me into liking it - I like it because it gives me the best experience and makes me more productive.
VS 2008 and 2010 are worlds better than 2005 -- so if we count the last 10 years nearly half of that will be people using 2005, and yes that was awful. Two version later, is it worth asking for a good price for a full featured version? Probably.
However, I tend to rarely use the debugger on my own code in any language since I started doing incremental TDD and using assertions galore all over the place to check inputs, outputs and assumptions. Prevention is better than cure (or debugging).
We don't have any problems at all. In fact it's really easy.
We use nservicebus and share by communicating rather than communicate by sharing. We use concurrentqueue class in the framework and all is solved.
You can't assert a list of hard coded values are all correctly spelled via an assert. You can't determine if a library that has it's own asserts is failing or your code is failing. You can't always add asserts to legacy code, etc.
I fail to see your point.
Assertions check assumptions and tests test code.
And yea you can use a dictfile from Unix to test spelling quite easily (we do it for document construction)
Nothing is ever 100% certain.
Are you suggesting that I magically write perfect software?
I don't, but it works first time in 99% of cases with the right tests and assertions.
The 1% left goes to debugging.
Our bug rate is approx 1 per 2000 lines of code that hit production.
Mingw may work, but it's still not a first-party tool, and it's still not fully compatible to microsoft's compilers.
Is there anything new that Windows 8 is doing that will cause Cygwin to regress?
Proposition A: Developers who write windows apps love
Visual Studio.
Proposition B: Developers who NEED Visual Studio can
afford a $500 piece of software.
Proposition C: Other OSes still provide free tools
Proposition D: MSFT spends money on developing this, so
they can choose to charge money for
supplying this
Proposition E: MSFT wants people to make metro apps in a
big way, and not to work on win32 stuff
Conclusion: Charging money for Visual Studio is sensible
Propositions A, B, and D form a coherent argument in support of your conclusion, and Proposition C may be nice to include, but isn't helping here. Proposition E appears to run entirely counter to your point.edit: as my responder points out, I'm incorrect in this assessment -- proposition E fits into the argument just fine. This is the folly of reading comments before having read the article!
"Visual Studio is sufficiently awesome that full-time developers--the ones who need Win32 support--can easily afford $500. For those who can't, Microsoft is making a deal: they'll give you a free copy of Visual Studio, but it's only good for targeting the new Windows 8 Metro environment. In other words, if you're willing to take the risk of developing for the new hotness that currently has basically zero apps for it, Microsoft will foot the bill. If you want to target the massive installed base that is Windows 7 and younger, you foot the bill."
I'm not saying I agree, but the argument is coherent.
After having read it, the article's title really doesn't fit the reality. If you want to develop traditional win32 apps, you can keep using VS2010. VS2011 has all the latest and greatest tech for them, but that's similar to the present divide between Express and Ultimate. This article appears to be trying very hard to frame the debate or sensationalize things.
It's fair to point out that if this trend continues into the next generation so that VS2010 becomes a sort of ghetto-compiler it's very bad, but we have no reason to believe right now that it will. Microsoft probably isn't stupid enough to shoot themselves that hard.
so does the rest of the world, unfortunately.
As a rule of thumb, Windows devs are mentally locked into Visual Studio and GUIs. They do not want to touch the command line. Open source scares them because it's libre & free. It's like some freaky movie where the Alien Software got downloaded into human brains and started issuing commands.
It's like some of these guys don't do computer programming any more. They program Visual Studio using C#. Of course, Visual Studio ain't bad, but the Visual Studio users are pretty rabid.
They would fork over thousands for their addiction.
I know many programmers (myself included) who have programmed and are reasonably competent in different languages using different text editors and IDE's on different operating systems and have made a conscious decision to use Visual Studio because, well, it is the tool that allows them to be the most productive. Companies choose Visual Studio because it allows their teams to be most productive.
I find myself using VS more and more for personal projects, as I haven't found anything that can beat the combination of F# and C# when used from VS. The .NET framework and languages have seen the introduction of some really exciting stuff such as LINQ, Reactive Extensions etc. etc. which are all supported by VS and offer more than enough for developers to keep interested in the platform.
Here's a rule of thumb for you: Good developers use the best tool for the job without getting religious about platforms.
If they decide that they don't want any apps on Windows other than Office it's their business. But it's a bit of a change from developers-developers-developers!
You're being sarcastic, but it would a possible move too. And yes, if you're writing apps you can afford it. It's not like Windows has too few apps, anyway, the could use the price as a quality control to throw one-man software companies out (there goes 99% of shareware).
That would be like going into McDonalds and shooting everyone but the cleaners.
They might not get many desktop upgrades from Win7 though !
Honestly, for a tool you would use all day long at work, $500 is cheap. If you NEED Visual Studio for C++, then it's worth the money.
Sure, on Linux and OS X you get free dev tools like XCode and GCC, but MSFT spends a lot of money building these tools, so if they decide they no longer want to subsidize them by offering them free, it's their business.
They want devs making Metro apps, not old Win32 C++ apps. If they don't get Metro apps to be built in a big way, Windows 8 tablet edition for human beings 2012 is never going to take off.
It makes sense for Microsoft.