News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by joshuamerrill on Thursday May 24, 2012 @02:47PM (#4019882)
While I applaud Eric's inexhaustible dedication to his company and mission, taking advantage of AOL in order to accomplish it is disgustingly unethical. It just makes it harder for other entrepreneurs who share that dedication but have chosen to build their businesses above-board.

I'm glad AOL has a sense of humor about this. But you can be sure that this incident will create additional requirements and restrictions for the [honest] entrepreneurs who still remain in the building.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by jaylevitt on Thursday May 24, 2012 @08:26PM (#4021298)
As the self-appointed permanent apologist for all things AOL, I declare that what Eric did is totally cool. Any work resources he used can be offset by our collective 24-hour work days from 1995-2000 - and we were denied Starbucks, wi-fi and telecommuting on account of they didn't exist yet.

I spent plenty of nights at the terminal and afternoons asleep on those couches; Eric's nighttime efforts will ensure that they wear evenly.

Eric: Welcome!

(AOL 1989-2001)

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by sandieman on Thursday May 24, 2012 @03:11PM (#4020032)
"Disgustingly unethical" is a little much.

AOL is going to get press out of this that am sure they will find worth the few months of squatting.

Also, entrepreneurs break rules in order to get stuff done. I applaud Eric and look forward to seeing him do well in the future.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by nupark2 on Thursday May 24, 2012 @04:05PM (#4020288)
> AOL is going to get press out of this that am sure they will find worth the few months of squatting.

That's AOL's decision to make. Not yours, not his.

> Also, entrepreneurs break rules in order to get stuff done.

Unethical people engage in unethical behavior (which is sometimes "breaking rules") in order to get stuff done.

Plenty of entrepreneurs do business honestly, and I'd rather read about them. I don't need a news story to tell me that behaving unethically can provide gains at a cost to others.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by sandieman on Thursday May 24, 2012 @05:24PM (#4020646)
If Steve Jobs had followed all the rules (many more unethical then sleeping on AOLs couch) I wouldn't be responding to this on my iPhone.
Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by nupark2 on Thursday May 24, 2012 @05:40PM (#4020716)
That's an unsupported assertion.

What unethical behavior are you referring to, and how have you demonstrated that Apple's success not only stemmed from such behavior, but could have only occurred through unethical means?

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by sandieman on Thursday May 24, 2012 @08:02PM (#4021231)
Steve sold blue boxes with Wozniak that allowed you to make unlimited phone calls. They profited 6k from this and is often told as the story that set the bond and precedent on how the two worked together.

This cost the phone companies and was an illegal item that they sold on the "underground market"

If Steve didn't partner with Wozniak would Apple be around today? Doubt it.

Was this more immoral then sleeping on AOLs couches for a few months after your incubator ended? I would say so.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by nupark2 on Thursday May 24, 2012 @09:03PM (#4021388)
That neither proves that unethical behavior was required for Apple's success, nor that said bond could only be created through unethical behavior. If you want a recrimination of that behavior, I'd be happy to give it. It was immature and wrong.
Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by vecter on Thursday May 24, 2012 @08:11PM (#4021255)
That's the most egregious straw man I've seen in a while. Even so, are you saying the ends justify the means?
Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by halter73 on Friday May 25, 2012 @04:29AM (#4022550)
What, if not the ends, justifies the means? I understand that, from a deontological perspective, you might believe that certain means can never be justified no matter what the ends, but surely squatting in an office building isn't a means so immoral that no end could ever justify it.

Now, you might think that building an education startup is not an end that requires or warrants trespassing, and you're probably right. However, I hope that you would feel differently about trespassing as a means to protect oneself from a dangerous oncoming storm.

I'm not sure if this is what you meant, but too often I hear people argue that if a certain means is immoral in one circumstance then it must be immoral in every circumstance. These people have the notion stuck in their heads that "the ends never justify the means." IMHO this viewpoint is far too reductionist to be universally valid.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by CamperBob2 on Thursday May 24, 2012 @10:49PM (#4021647)
Yes. Nothing great was ever done by people who slavishly followed the rules.
Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by laughinghan on Thursday May 24, 2012 @11:37PM (#4021771)
1. False. Define "great" and "rules" and I or others will happily provide no shortage of examples.

2. I want to give you the benefit of the doubt and assume you're a reasonable person, and you were merely exaggerating, but I don't even know what you're trying to say. Are you trying to say that in order to do great things, rules generally have to get broken...and therefore it's ok for entrepreneurs to do unethical things?

3. Consider reducing your consumption of entrepreneurship porn.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by CamperBob2 on Friday May 25, 2012 @12:20AM (#4021900)
1) Meh, that sounds like a lot of work.

2) The world is rendered in shades of grey, and not all ethical issues carry equal weight. Some are worth sweating, some aren't. This one isn't, according to a representative of the victimized party itself.

3) Consider having a beer or two and giving the high horse a good night's sleep.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by joshuamerrill on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:08AM (#4022154)
As I said in the topmost parent thread, "you can be sure that this incident will create additional requirements and restrictions for the [honest] entrepreneurs who still remain in the building."

Many successful entrepreneurs engage in social hacking in some way. What the entrepreneur in this case did was both unethical and illegal.

Just because you have a key to someone's house doesn't mean you get to open their front door and sleep on their couch.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by CamperBob2 on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:23AM (#4022188)
The world is rendered in shades of grey, and not all ethical issues carry equal weight. Some are worth sweating, some aren't. This one isn't, according to a representative of the victimized party itself.

(since you apparently missed it the first time)

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by nupark2 on Friday May 25, 2012 @10:20AM (#4023577)
The victimized party can choose to spin this any way they want, but it had no bearing on whether it actually did them harm or how they actually feel about it. That's not your decision to make, and 'shades of gray' is a lousy justification for theft of service.
Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by CamperBob2 on Friday May 25, 2012 @03:13PM (#4025016)
Sigh. I'm sorry, I thought I was on a forum for hackers, not commercial property managers.

I see this fellow as no worse than, say, a telemarketer. In fact, that's probably a good analogy to draw... except that I typically get more annoyed at telemarketers who hijack my time and attention, than AOL management seems to be at the person who overstayed his welcome in their building.

It's possible that I'm only as sympathetic to him as I am because he committed his offense in the course of trying to create something. Telemarketers don't offend me because they're annoying and presumptuous, but because they're lazy and unnecessary. If every telemarketer dropped off the face of the earth tomorrow, life would go on for the rest of us. If every kid with a bit of hustle and debatable judgment dropped off the face of the earth, things would go downhill in a hurry.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by nupark2 on Friday May 25, 2012 @10:31PM (#4026212)
Being a hacker has nothing to do with poor ethics. In fact, I'd say many of the best hackers I've had the privilege to work with have a strong sense of morals and ethics.
Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by jmtame on Thursday May 24, 2012 @11:29PM (#4021746)
Agreed. Even YC explicitly says they look for the "naughty" factor in entrepreneurs, and this is exactly the type of quality I saw in Eric from reading this article.

"Though the most successful founders are usually good people, they tend to have a piratical gleam in their eye. They're not Goody Two-Shoes type good. Morally, they care about getting the big questions right, but not about observing proprieties. That's why I'd use the word naughty rather than evil. They delight in breaking rules, but not rules that matter. This quality may be redundant though; it may be implied by imagination." http://paulgraham.com/founders.html

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by mbreese on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:12AM (#4022166)
I'd say trespassing would qualify as one of the rules that matters. Or really, any law. You can't build a company like that.

It's fine to break unwritten rules of decorum, or question conventional wisdom. This is another thing all together.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by joshuamerrill on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:12AM (#4022165)
There's a reason why PG used the word "naughty" and not "criminal." In this case, we're talking about the latter.
Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by Drbble on Saturday May 26, 2012 @11:47PM (#4029144)
I think AOL decided.
Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by carbocation on Thursday May 24, 2012 @04:03PM (#4020274)
It's probably too little. I would imagine this is tortious behavior, but IANAL.
Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by webXL on Thursday May 24, 2012 @10:44PM (#4021631)
Yeah, I thought AOL folded years ago. Good to see they're still around and that at least one kid is actually being productive there! zing!
Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by west1737 on Thursday May 24, 2012 @02:58PM (#4019942)
Do what you have to do. AOL is no worse for having someone sleeping on their couch.
Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by nupark2 on Thursday May 24, 2012 @03:04PM (#4019980)
AOL out the funds they spent on his theft of service and resources, and they're out the time they spent having security figure out why someone was sleeping there. They've been embarrassed in the press, and they're that much less likely to trust people that are part of their entrepreneur programs in the future.

The security staff in question was probably reprimanded for their failure to detect the interloper -- he abused the trust he had gained by previously becoming a "known" face.

You do what you have to do, ethically, to succeed.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by djloche on Thursday May 24, 2012 @03:36PM (#4020153)
"They've been embarrassed in the press"

They've actually been profiled as a reasonable company that invests in the future. How many people reading this article know AOL as "that company that first sent me discs in the mail" and previously thought AOL as a dead company?

AOL gets free, positive press showing that they're not dead, they're investing in the future, and that they're reasonable. The positive spin this article gives them is worth every penny of resources spent.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by nupark2 on Thursday May 24, 2012 @04:11PM (#4020319)
> They've actually been profiled as a reasonable company that invests in the future.

The best thing they can do at this point is put a positive spin on it, but ...

> The positive spin this article gives them is worth every penny of resources spent.

Not your decision to make for AOL. AOL will spin this, but post-facto justification ("see, it's not that bad -- they made good on my theft!") does not an ethical decision make.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by djloche on Thursday May 24, 2012 @05:15PM (#4020600)
Nowhere do I lay claim to making decisions for AOL. While I doubt they are interested, if AOL wishes to hire me for such purposes, I am available.

I pointed out that it was my opinion that the cost of the resources that Eric used was less than the cost of genuine, positive press.

I also did not declare his actions ethical. I responded to your claim that AOL has been embarrassed.

AOL responded appropriately (not pressing charges, just kindly requiring him to not sleep/live there anymore), and was able to respond to the press inquiry with a lighthearted statement that fits the narrative of the article. The article presents AOL not only as having reasonable management, but also as a place to work with great benefits (food, showers, gym, startup incubators, friendly environment).

AOL is where Yahoo will be in 5 years: they have nowhere to go but up in terms of public reputation and mindshare.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by nupark2 on Thursday May 24, 2012 @05:54PM (#4020778)
I see AOL as doing their best to avoid a bigger snafu over a smaller, unattractive snafu. Opinions on the value of this PR will vary, but the fact is that there's no substance here.

Somebody abused their fairly standard SV corporate perks, they responded without bringing in the police.

At the end of the day, my subjective impression is that their startup interests brought in an immature, ethically-challenged entrepreneur who is stuck in the money-raising cycle, and accordingly AOL has been dragged into the press because of something stupid he did.

That isn't a particularly positive narrative, but I can see how people that are more comfortable with Eric's failure of ethics can see it as a cool story of "hustling" entrepreneurship.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by Scramblejams on Thursday May 24, 2012 @03:56PM (#4020234)
Yeah, this was the first time I can remember thinking of "AOL" and "cool" in the same sentence. On the whole I think it reflects well on them.
Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by chc on Thursday May 24, 2012 @05:15PM (#4020607)
Meh. On AOL's scale, this sounds kind of like somebody noticing that I dropped a nickel and pocketing it instead of chasing after me. I suppose it's kind of unethical — I wouldn't do it, personally — but to put it in the same bucket with what we usually consider breaches of ethics seems incorrect. Even the AOL exec quoted in the article seemed more amused than anything else.
Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by joshuamerrill on Thursday May 24, 2012 @05:53PM (#4020774)
I'm sure the value of the theft is immaterial to AOL. The security breach is more serious, and the bigger issue, to me, is that other startups in the same building that are behaving ethically could suffer because of one person's behavior.
Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by koide on Friday May 25, 2012 @07:27AM (#4023015)
Or not... stop worrying that much until you actually see a consequence.

By the way, all AOL has to do now is to chastise a bit the security people and to make sure the security rounds do cover the whole floor plan. Nothing more, nothing less. I hardly see that as suffering for the other startups in the building.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by 3pt14159 on Thursday May 24, 2012 @03:05PM (#4019986)
Sorta... It's still stealing gym time, electricity, showers, laundry, and work space. The ends don't justify the means.

Though, companies like AOL or Google could totally make this a legit practice by asking for 2% or something of any startup that comes out of it.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by joshuamerrill on Thursday May 24, 2012 @03:08PM (#4020004)
AOL is a public company that has a responsibility for ensuring the safety and security of its employees and IP. That includes logging in or badging visitors, requiring contracts like NDAs, and requiring background checks. This entrepreneur skirted all those requirements.

So while AOL may not be worse off for having someone sleeping on their couch IN THIS CASE, you can bet that the hammer will come down on the rest of us in the building. From AOL's perspective, it could just as easily have been a homeless person with psychological issues. Honest entrepreneurs will suffer because of this.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by Arelius on Thursday May 24, 2012 @03:52PM (#4020217)
Did he? He had a badge, and to get that badge, he likely had an NDA and background checks, if they are actually requirements.

It really couldn't have been a homeless person with psychological issues, he would have been noticed and likely wouldn't have made it into the initial incubator.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by phodo on Thursday May 24, 2012 @03:04PM (#4019982)
I applaud him (a former employee did this at one of the incubators in the valley and I always thought: mad respect), but want to to comment on the "no worse" statement. This is a typical tragedy of the commons mentality:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons

Sure, if one person does this, AOL is no worse off, but if everyone adopts this attitude, it will have an adverse effect.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by joshuamerrill on Thursday May 24, 2012 @05:10PM (#4020580)
This isn't a tragedy of the commons. The food, office space, couches, etc., that the entrepreneur used were not "common" property—they were paid for by directly by AOL.

I'm flabbergasted that you can applaud him for this. It's like a former bank employee stealing money from the vault, because someone forgot to take away his badge.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by koide on Friday May 25, 2012 @07:34AM (#4023040)
I'm flabbergasted that you take his offense as if he drowned two babies and an old lady with her cat. It certainly was unethical, but his action was immature, not evil. I really fail to see an intent to cause harm. Now, he shouldn't get a prize out of it either, but that's VC for you.

Maybe you are this upset because you fear it will affect you personally?

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by webwright on Thursday May 24, 2012 @03:35PM (#4020147)
Stealing from someone just because they can afford it doesn't make it ethical.
Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by cellularmitosis on Thursday May 24, 2012 @07:44PM (#4021177)
Statements like this fall apart in anything other than a well-behaved society. If you were a serf with a starving family in fuedal Europe, living in crushing poverty under a corrupt king, would you wouldn't steal from him to survive, had the opportunity presented itself?
Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by FJim on Thursday May 24, 2012 @11:14PM (#4021719)
The first sentence is not an argument nor is it true. The next sentence follows it up with a non sequitur hypothetical.

Let's say his aging mother died and he continued to cash her Social Security checks for a year, to continue to pursue his dream, would you consider it unethical? The federal government certainly has the money, and he is tenaciously pursuing his dream.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by jroseattle on Thursday May 24, 2012 @08:52PM (#4021365)
Probably want to avoid comparing startups in Silicon Valley will starving serfs in feudal Europe. One is a choice, the other not so much.
Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by laughinghan on Friday May 25, 2012 @12:10AM (#4021877)
I think you're replying to the straw man "Stealing from someone just because they can afford it is always unethical.", which is not what parent said.

I agree with you that there are situations in which it's ethical to steal from someone who can afford it, but what parent said was that the latter condition doesn't guarantee it to be automatically ethical, implying that grandparent's assertion that the theft was ethical because AOL could afford it was fallacious.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by biot on Thursday May 24, 2012 @10:08PM (#4021550)
On the one hand, the starving serf living in crushing poverty doesn't have much opportunity to get out of serfdom.

On the other hand, an obviously talented young developer who is starving in Silicon Valley may need to take an internship that pays $80K+ per year.

I'm not seeing the parallels.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by Mz on Thursday May 24, 2012 @07:51PM (#4021199)
I am running a fever, so not really in a good state to make my point clearly/effectively, but inevitably we are all in this together, like it or not, and who benefits is largely a matter of what rules we put in place. Poor people are frequently legally disempowered and rich people are frequently the ones engineering the rules in their favor. The assumption that what the king has "belongs" to him rightfully often turns a blind eye to where it really came from.

Anyway, it is more complicated than the arguments I have been witnessing here today and I just regret that I am not in good shape to give adequate voice to the idea that society needs to come up with a more enlightened means to address ..the whole kit and kaboodle.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by larrys on Thursday May 24, 2012 @05:12PM (#4020590)
"AOL is no worse for having someone sleeping on their couch."

The assumption the companies has is that the building is clear each night. Having a person there could be an issue simply if there is a fire or other event and emergency personnel involved. In no way can any responsible company tolerate this type of stowaway.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by mindcrime on Thursday May 24, 2012 @05:51PM (#4020770)
The assumption the companies has is that the building is clear each night. Having a person there could be an issue simply if there is a fire or other event and emergency personnel involved.

FWIW, from a firefighter's perspective, I can assure you that - in the event of a fire - the fire department does not assume a building is clear just because it's the middle of the night or whatever. There are any number of reasons why people could be inside at 2:00am, 3:00am, etc. Maintenance work being done, facilities people cleaning, cheating executives banging their mistresses on their desk, etc., etc. In the case of a working fire, a primary search is going to be done (conditions permitting) anyway.

In no way can any responsible company tolerate this type of stowaway.

You're probably right, but I don't really think the reasons this is true have much to do with emergency scenarios. If anything, I'd lean more towards "what if the elevator was being repaired late at night, and the stowaway fell into an elevator shaft and plunged to his death?" and any potential liability that might come out of that.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by larrys on Thursday May 24, 2012 @07:15PM (#4021075)
"the fire department does not assume a building is clear just because it's the middle of the night or whatever."

Thank's for pointing that out. In retrospect I can see how assumptions similar to the one that I made can cause plenty of errors in emergency situations.

"a primary search is going to be done (conditions permitting) anyway."

I watched a docudrama on the Reagan assassination attempt last night. One of the mistakes they made I believe was assuming Reagan wasn't hit by a bullet because a) he seemed fine and said he hadn't been hit and b) the secret service said he wasn't hit.

While "a" would seem to be pretty valid info "b" was based on "a". After all you can't really see whether a bullet hits someone generally. So in keeping with your "primary search" with fires, they shouldn't have "assumed" the info they were getting was correct and fully checked him out much earlier. (And in fact I'm sure that is probably they way they would operate in the future learning from that mistake.)

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by jrockway on Thursday May 24, 2012 @08:10PM (#4021254)
Indeed. Some buildings are used normally at 2am. When we have games night at Google, it's rare that it's over before 2. This is an expected use for the building -- it's considered open 24/7/365.

I imagine there are AOL employees that work late, too, or fall asleep on the company couch.

Re:Meet the tireless entrepreneur who squatted at AOL by mcav on Friday May 25, 2012 @03:57AM (#4022460)
As someone who worked in the building at a startup a few months ago, the answer is no: most are gone by 5pm, all by 8pm.