I did it manually the first time around and it was a pain in the ass.
With the hindsight I have now it would have been much cheaper for us than it turned out to be, but that’s still extra money I’m paying simply because complying with the law is as complex as it is, and I’m not running a business, just hiring a part-time caretaker.
Not knowing what was required for sure? Figuring out how to fill out the 1099-MISC? Knowing how to file it with the IRS/state?
I remember it being a bit tricky at first but once I knew the right form it only took a few minutes. The hard part for me is keeping track of rule changes.
Payroll service works though =)
A babysitter one of the examples specifically called out as a household employee in the IRS guidance[1], so if you’re doing it right you should be running payroll. That’s pretty tricky to DIY properly.
Which tells you volumes about the practicality of said law.
For all intents and purposes, a babysitter is looked at just like a nanny in that if they must adhere to the schedule you set and come to your home to take care of your kids based on the rules you set, the IRS will most likely view this as an employment relationship. And taxes can sneak up on you quickly. If the babysitter earns just $15 per hour and works even 10 hours per week, you’ll cross the $2,700 tax withholding threshold in a little over four months.
[1] https://www.care.com/hp/do-you-need-to-pay-taxes-for-your-pa...
And at some point you just pay cash.
What made it difficult was: finding out we needed to do anything at all, finding out what that “anything” even was, finding instructions for doing it, parsing the instructions and figuring out if we were reading the correct instructions, figuring out if the various exceptions and other special clauses applied, researching those, then figuring out how to actually do any of this, and so on, and then again a second time for state taxes.
Nevermind going down the rabbit whole of trying to figure out if we need an EIN and then repeating the same discovery and learning process for just that small part of the whole entire thing.
Honestly it would have been a full time job for me to successfully navigate it all. I don’t see how it’s possible to do without already being a CPA or accountant of some sort. It’s an entire domain of knowledge and I had almost none of that knowledge. There’s too much else going on in my life to begin to delve into all that.
All this for a baby sitter 16 hours a week.
this is such a privileged position and you think you should’ve just been able to pay cash and potentially screw someone over?
I went through all the trouble because I thought it was the right thing to do and I wanted to do right by the babysitter. It’s why I ended up paying an accountant a larger lump of money than I would have liked to in order to get it all sorted out.
Im complaining how difficult it is to do the right thing.
I did not read anything in your post that suggested you resented the babysitter or having to pay money to do it properly.
I read the exact opposite, that more people would if the process were not so burdensom of people who obviously have a child and so presumably not a ton of time for paperwork.
After all, you did it properly... what's to get angry about other than the topic of the original article, that tax paperwork is overboard?
You're only benefitting the babysitter by paying them cash, big win for them. And benefitting yourself to avoid all that payroll hassle that nobody understands. Win-win.
Maybe Congress can work on this next.
[1] https://www.irs.gov/publications/p926#en_US_2024_publink1000...
It's likely 90% of the population don't follow this tax law.
I eventually got everything sorted with the help of an accountant and they confirmed this.
I understand why it’s important to do it properly (for the employee’s benefit) but when I tried to look into what we had to do, as technically her employer, and it was nearly impossible for me to figure out what we had to do and then how to even do it (federal and state). I understand why many people just want to pay cash under the table. It really made me feel like a complete moron.
If we ever do it again we’ll have to just hire a payroll service and factor that cost into what wages we can offer, or structure it so that total payments remain under the threshold required for filing.