News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Beautiful Dissociation of the Japanese Language by canjobear on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @01:32PM (#40134639)
> Since the sounds per character are 1-1 and the semantics are very clean you can get a lot out of a text by looking characters up in the Unihan database.

You probably got a lot of wrong meanings this way. The characters aren't 1-1 mapped to sounds and their semantics are profoundly context-dependent.

Re:The Beautiful Dissociation of the Japanese Language by RyEgswuCsn on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @04:35PM (#40136939)
I think they meant there is only one syllable per character.
Re:The Beautiful Dissociation of the Japanese Language by kfk34k on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @01:43PM (#40134777)
The characters are mostly 1-1. There are a few exceptions, but usually one is a lot more typical than the other, so reading it with the typical reading won't usually get you in trouble
Re:The Beautiful Dissociation of the Japanese Language by canjobear on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @04:40PM (#40136996)
The multi-sound characters are common in usage. For example 长 can be cháng meaning "long" or zhǎng meaning "to grow". 行 is xíng "to walk" or háng with no real single coherent meaning, appearing in compounds like 银行 yínháng "bank" and 行业 hángyè "profession". All of these are very common usages. In context they are essentially never ambiguous, but if you are going through character-by-character it's not going to make sense.
Re:The Beautiful Dissociation of the Japanese Language by gtranger on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @01:58PM (#40134967)
While not as egregious as Japanese where characters can have 15+ readings, the number of exceptions certainly are not few. Below is a link to the official table of words with multiple pronunciations in standard Mandarin.

https://zh.m.wikisource.org/wiki/%E6%99%AE%E9%80%9A%E8%AF%9D...

Re:The Beautiful Dissociation of the Japanese Language by housel on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @03:14PM (#40135981)
While I couldn't find any characters with more than three or four readings in this list, the Taiwan list (https://language.moe.gov.tw/files/people_files/%e5%88%9d%e7%...) has one character with five readings (著) and one with six (和). Still a long way from 15, though.
Re:The Beautiful Dissociation of the Japanese Language by Asraelite on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @02:40PM (#40135567)
872 in that list. It would be interesting to see how many of those exceptions are actually common and relevant to everyday speech.

But yeah, even taking that into account, Japanese is a trainwreck compared to Chinese.

Re:The Beautiful Dissociation of the Japanese Language by gtranger on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @03:08PM (#40135900)
It's worth noting that the aforementioned list is the unified pronunciation list that was published in 1985 by the Ministry of Education. The reason why you see some words only having a single (unified) reading in that list is due to the necessity of having to unify them in the first place, although there are still quite a few words with multiple readings. Keep in mind that there was no official language of China until 1932. Without going into detail about how pronunciations evolved with the change of dynasties and how China actually has 300+ spoken languages, the need for a unified pronunciation stems from the fact that many people in China, historically and even today, do not speak standard Mandarin as their first language. In other words, prior to 1985 it was much more chaotic. If you want a more up-to-date comprehensive list of words with multiple readings (多音字) you can find it below (although this is not an official government list). I've linked directly to the common words of which there are 106 (although the page does not define what is considered "common").

https://baike.baidu.com/item/%E5%A4%9A%E9%9F%B3%E5%AD%97/108...

Re:The Beautiful Dissociation of the Japanese Language by numpad0 on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @01:58PM (#40134965)
I think GP's assessment that Chinese is semantically clean and regular might not be completely correct, rather it's quite close to his primary that friction is much reduced compared to Japanese, or many others for that matter. It's very well known that Chinese grammar is super close to English for whatever reasons.
Re:The Beautiful Dissociation of the Japanese Language by thaumasiotes on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @02:28PM (#40135384)
> It's very well known that Chinese grammar is super close to English for whatever reasons.

They are both felt to have gone through a lot of simplification. It isn't well known that they have similar grammars, for the fairly straightforward reason that they don't have similar grammars.

Re:The Beautiful Dissociation of the Japanese Language by BalinKing on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @02:33PM (#40135465)
I imagine the parent is referring to both languages being analytic (although, IIRC, Mandarin is a fair deal more so than English).

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Analytic_language

Re:The Beautiful Dissociation of the Japanese Language by PaulHoule on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @10:51PM (#40139943)
As an English speaker I find it frustrating that languages like German and French have so many irregular verbs and that you also need to keep track of grammatical gender which seems pretty arbitrary.

In Chinese though you find structures which are pretty regular such as "measure words" where you might write

  yi zhang zhi
which means

  one (piece) of paper
where the word "zhang" is used because paper is thin, but you might use "ke" for something round like a pebble or "tiao" for something long and flexible like a snake. This and a lot of of what I read in the grammar book comes across as rational to me.
Re:The Beautiful Dissociation of the Japanese Language by glandium on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @01:51AM (#40141068)
English is not that much better, actually:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_irregular_verbs

The English language has many irregular verbs, approaching 200 in normal use—and significantly more if prefixed forms are counted.

https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Appendix:French_irregular_ver...

There are approximately 350 irregular verbs that do not conjugate in either the first or second conjugation

I don't think French has examples as crazy as go -> went. I mean, there aren't even letters in common!

Re:The Beautiful Dissociation of the Japanese Language by thaumasiotes on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @04:13AM (#40141874)
> English is not that much better, actually

Note that Latin is generally considered to have about four irregular verbs, possibly a few more than that depending on how you're counting.

A verb in Ancient Greek has six principal parts, which means that to correctly inflect it you need to memorize six more-or-less independent forms. (They're often "less" independent, but sometimes they'll surprise you!)

By contrast, an English verb, except for the single verb be, has a maximum of five forms. (Not five principal parts - five fully-inflected forms!) So by the Greek standard, English has just the one irregular verb. That's not a correct application of the concept, but it is worth observing.

> I don't think French has examples as crazy as go -> went. I mean, there aren't even letters in common!

This is a suppletive verb. (That is, a verb in which some forms descend from one ancestral verb and other forms descend from a different ancestral verb.†) Went was originally the past tense of the still-existent verb wend, in the same way that bent is still today the past tense of bend; wend has had to shift over to wended.

Not only does French have suppletive verbs, it has the same suppletive verb, aller [to go]:

    1sg pres.    je vais    [< Lat. vadere]
    1sg impf.    j'allais   [< Lat. alare]
    1sg fut.     j'irai     [< Lat. ire]
The Latin verb is ire; it is minorly irregular but not suppletive in Latin.

† Suppletion as a linguistic phenomenon is not restricted to verbs; compare person -> people.