Wait, people still use this benchmark? I hear there's a huge flaw on it.
For examples, fine-tuning the model on 4chan make it scores better on TruthfulQA. It becomes very offensive afterwards though, for obvious reasons. See GPT-4chan [1]
>very offensive
Any cons?
Asking it to answer questions on its own is much more prone to hallucination.
To that end I've been using Llama 3 for summarizing transcripts of YouTube videos. It does a decent job, but... every single time (literally 100% of the time), it will hallucinate a random name for the speaker.* Every time! I thought it might be the system prompt, but there isn't one.
My own prompt is just "{text}\n\n###\n\nPlease summarize the text above."
If I ask it to summarize in bullet points, it doesn't do that.
I'm assuming there was something in the (instruct) training data that strongly encourages that, i.e. a format of summaries beginning with the author's name? Seems sensible enough, but obviously backfires when there's literally no data and it just makes something up...
*In videos where the speaker's name isn't in the transcript. If it's a popular field, it will often come up with something plausible (e.g. Andrew Ng for an AI talk.) If it's something more obscure, it'll dream up something completely random.
"{text}\n\n###\n\nPlease summarize the text above. The text is a video transcript. It may not have the names of the speakers in it. If you need to refer to an unnamed speaker, call them Speaker_1, Speaker_2 and so on."
"using the following documentation to guide you {api documentation}, edit this code {relevant code}, with the following objective: Replace uses of {old API calls} in {some function} with with relevant functions from the supplied documentation"
It mostly works, but if the context is a little to long, sometimes it will just spam the same umlaut or number (always umlaut's or numbers) over and over for example. Perhaps some fine-tuning of parameters like temp. or repetition penalty might fix it, time will tell.
They mention this model's relative weakness in the TruthfulQA eval, since it's more lossy trying to pack 'knowledge' into a small model relative to problem-solving skills (which shine on MMLU)
Regardless - still a very useful thing to have offline and on the fly. Those scores are nothing to scoff at.
Given that these pipelines are likely harder harder to imitate than new architectures like Transformers, I assume there has been and will be an intense focus on synthetic data generation and cleansing. Llama 3 used 15T of tokens in its training corpus vs 4.8T in the "scaled-up" version of phi-3. If you made it to the end of this disjointed ramble I'm sorry