News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by fossuser on Saturday April 20, 2024 @01:09PM (#40098802)
Waymo is amazing and has fully replaced Uber for me in SF. They're also expanding to the entire peninsula from SF down to Cupertino - you're out of date on this.

Waymo driving in SF is way better than human. It's not timid either.

This Mercedes post is marketing - it's not really what people consider autonomous given the constraints.

> "Drivers can activate Mercedes's technology, called Drive Pilot, when certain conditions are met, including in heavy traffic jams, during the daytime, on specific California and Nevada freeways, and when the car is traveling less than 40 mph. Drivers can focus on other activities until the vehicle alerts them to resume control. The technology does not work on roads that haven't been pre-approved by Mercedes, including on freeways in other states."

The above makes it nearly useless and far less useful than what Tesla has been shipping for years imo.

Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by bhauer on Saturday April 20, 2024 @01:56PM (#40099270)
> "Drivers can activate Mercedes's technology. called Drive Pilot, when certain conditions are met, including in heavy traffic jams, during the daytime, on specific California and Nevada freeways, and when the car is traveling less than 40 mph. Drivers can focus on other activities until the vehicle alerts them to resume control. The technology does not work on roads that haven't been pre-approved by Mercedes, including on freeways in other states."

It's remarkable how often these significant limitations are ignored.

The difference between SAE Level 3 versus Level 2 is liability, not functionality. Conceptually, it would be relatively simple to create a Level 3 system that only worked in parking lots and never drove over 5 MPH. And yes, such a system would be "Level 3," which naively sounds better than "Level 2" because the number is higher.

But you could compare such a system that works only in parking lots against Tesla's Supervised FSD Level 2 system which controls the vehicle at prevailing speeds on all city streets and highways, executes left and right turns, stops at traffic controls, executes U-turns, parks, and everything else. Tesla doesn't want to assume liability yet because they are still iterating fast. The last few builds have been released about two weeks apart.

The functional domain of a Level 2 system can be significantly greater than a Level 3 system. And that is the case when comparing Tesla Supervised FSD versus Mercedes Drivepilot. It remains commendable for Mercedes to take on liability, but we should not kid ourselves. Doing so is a play for cheap media wins and punchy-sounding milestones like what we see in this article. It's not actually moving autonomy forward in any meaningful way when compared alongside Waymo and Tesla FSD. The scope of the Mercedes system is simply too narrow.

Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by ra7 on Saturday April 20, 2024 @02:03PM (#40099342)
> The difference between SAE Level 3 versus Level 2 is liability, not functionality. Conceptually, it would be relatively simple to create a Level 3 system that only worked in parking lots and never drove over 5 MPH. And yes, such a system would be "Level 3," which naively sounds better than "Level 2" because the number is higher.

No one’s going to take liability if their technology is not ready for the conditions they want to work in. And no one’s creating systems that only work in 5 mph parking lots just to claim the L3 title. So comparison to hypothetical systems aren’t useful.

Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by bhauer on Saturday April 20, 2024 @02:06PM (#40099385)
The limitations of the Mercedes system are only a little higher than the hypothetical parking lot Level 3 system. The point is to emphasize that a narrow Level 3 system is not very interesting compared to a broad Level 2 system. Technical capability > appeasing lawyers.
Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by ra7 on Saturday April 20, 2024 @02:13PM (#40099453)
Technical capability with known operating conditions (that can expand over time) > technical capability with unknown operating conditions.

Only one of them allows you to take liability.

Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by llamaimperative on Saturday April 20, 2024 @02:09PM (#40099407)
Uhh but a narrow Level 3 system will also in general do broad Level 2. You think these Mercedes can't do adaptive cruise control at 60mph wherever you want to activate it?

I would take a car with reliable, narrow L3 and reliable broad L2 (especially when the L3 is reliable in the most frustrating driving conditions to encounter) over broad pseudo-L3 any day.

Waymos are incredible, but Teslas are a much worse tradeoff than what MB is proposing here in my opinion.

Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by bhauer on Saturday April 20, 2024 @10:42PM (#40102791)
> Uhh but a narrow Level 3 system will also in general do broad Level 2. You think these Mercedes can't do adaptive cruise control at 60mph wherever you want to activate it?

The Mercedes system will absolutely not follow navigation routes, change lanes, execute right and left turns, execute U-turns, stop at traffic controls, and so on. All of which FSD will do.

A broadly capable Level 2 system that is suitable for 99% of driving scenarios (with supervision) is way more interesting than a tightly constrained Level 3 system that is only suitable for <1% of driving scenarios.

Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by llamaimperative on Saturday April 20, 2024 @02:08PM (#40099398)
> The difference between SAE Level 3 versus Level 2 is liability, not functionality.

No it's not. The difference is functionality, proof that the vendor believes they've achieved that difference is most clearly communicated via liability.

> The scope of the Mercedes system is simply too narrow

Producing systems that perform reliably under the prescribed conditions is called "good engineering."

Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by srockets on Saturday April 20, 2024 @03:16PM (#40100140)
> Tesla doesn't want to assume liability yet because they are still iterating fast.

I would guess the reason for not wanting to assume liability is not their update cadence, but the same reason that made Mobileye fire them as a customer.

Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by Retric on Saturday April 20, 2024 @02:10PM (#40099417)
Level 3 actually lets you take a break while driving. L2 systems don’t and therefore IMO don't provide significant benefits.

More range and more driving conditions just don’t matter here if I can’t read a book on the way to work then it’s not self driving just advanced cruse control.

Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by srockets on Saturday April 20, 2024 @03:19PM (#40100172)
You can read a book on the way to work. Before going fully remote, I did it every weekday, using a magnificent piece of technology called public transit.
Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by Retric on Saturday April 20, 2024 @03:26PM (#40100231)
And level 5 beats level 3, however I don’t have any public transport options on the way to work and nobody is selling level 5 self driving cars. Mercedes hasn’t mapped my roads either, but that’s a lower barrier than getting nationwide public transportation setup.
Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by srockets on Saturday April 20, 2024 @04:58PM (#40100955)
And this is the why I think pouring money on autonomous driving is a net negative for most but a small group of shareholders: a public transit infrastructure is expensive, but the net benefits are immense, and can be had today.

Every dollar spent on private cars reduces that infrastructure, and that's not just my own thinking, but also that of car manufacturers, as evident by their lobbying to derail public transit projects.

Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by Retric on Saturday April 20, 2024 @07:31PM (#40101940)
It’s different pools of money.

Further I don’t live in a city so my local government has zero interest in public transportation beyond school buses. We just don’t have the density where it makes any sense. When I did live in a city the issue wasn’t drivers it was the inability to scale roads for local demand. Self driving cars don’t change anything about that equation.

Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by kwhitefoot on Saturday April 20, 2024 @02:39PM (#40099722)
Not really. Mercedes say you have to be able to take over within ten seconds.
Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by Retric on Saturday April 20, 2024 @03:19PM (#40100174)
10 seconds after a warning which is plenty when your reading. You do need to stay awake, sober, and in the drivers seat but that’s not a big deal.
Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by flohofwoe on Saturday April 20, 2024 @02:27PM (#40099596)
> against Tesla's Supervised FSD Level 2 system

...those same Mercedes cars that have Level 3 also have a much more "powerful" and flexible Level 2 system built in, but this requires to keep a hand on the wheel and pay attention to the road (mentioned towards the end of this video, at around 6:15: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZLz95Gw7g8c)

Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by bko on Saturday April 20, 2024 @01:21PM (#40098921)
How is Waymo pricing compared to Uber or other ride share?

I originally thought autonomous cars would greatly reduce costs but considering the tens of billions dumped into these companies, they can't charge lower prices as they have to recoup investments.

Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by AlotOfReading on Saturday April 20, 2024 @01:26PM (#40098995)
It's a dollar or two more expensive than the corresponding Uber (non-shared) fare in my experience, so a bit less after tips. Keep in mind that the "true" price of these services probably isn't the biggest pricing factor right now. The cost is a way to manage demand, get some additional income, and investigate what the market will bear.
Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by bko on Saturday April 20, 2024 @01:39PM (#40099117)
I doubt they're profitable though. From Bing:

> As of the latest available information, Waymo is not yet profitable. Alphabet’s Q2 2023 earnings report indicated that its “Other Bets” category, which includes Waymo, had revenues of $285 million and an operating loss of $813 million. This was a decrease in operating loss from $1.34 billion in the second quarter of 2022, but still significant. Over the last five years, “Other Bets” has generated $3 billion in cumulative revenue but incurred $20 billion in operating losses, with Waymo constituting the bulk of these losses.

I just don't see the end game. Are marginal rides not profitable even at Uber fates? Uber for instance was losing money because they were taking rev from profitable cities to give incentives and build up drivers in the new markets. But Waymo doesn't have that problem. Is it just GPU spend that they can eventually stop?

Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by suzakus on Saturday April 20, 2024 @01:45PM (#40099165)
Nothing about that quote indicates that waymo loses money on marginal rides, rather that it loses money in aggregate which is not particularly surprising considering low overall volume , r&d overhead of both head count and things like cars and facilities to store said cars
Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by AlotOfReading on Saturday April 20, 2024 @01:52PM (#40099233)
I suspect it's vaguely near gross profit, that is excluding almost all the expensive engineers, marketing, R&D costs, new silicon development costs, etc. It's not remotely operationally profitable though, you're right.

The business model is pretty simple. Robotaxis can operate much cheaper than humans and simultaneously provide a better service. Competing at the same cost as existing services makes them massively profitable. You can unlock additional efficiencies through things like fleet management, not supporting unprofitable cities the way Uber has to, vehicles designed for longer service lives and so on. Most companies plan to use that market (and closely associated ones like food delivery) as a profitable beachhead to scale down the technology to the point where it can be applied more ubiquitously in things like consumer vehicles. Some are more vocal about this than others.

Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by jackcosgrove on Saturday April 20, 2024 @01:59PM (#40099309)
I wonder if anyone has done an analysis looking at a set of tasks and ordering them according to the ease of automating them compared to the cost of labor.

Self-driving cars seem like a poor choice of market, since the task is very complex and there are also many people worldwide who are willing to work as drivers.

The sweet spot would be a task that is easy to automate and also doesn't have much human competition. Obviously the OG automation case of assembly lines fits this. LLMs can occupy this space since there are probably more people who can drive a car than can write grammatically correct natural language. I would put self-driving trains in this category as well but that's an outsider's perspective.

Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by acchow on Saturday April 20, 2024 @01:26PM (#40098994)
If you tip on Uber/Lyft, then Waymo pricing is close (maybe a 5% premium). But during peak hours, Waymo is much more expensive.
Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by ra7 on Saturday April 20, 2024 @01:41PM (#40099137)
In addition to what others have said about pricing, you need to compare Waymo with Uber Black, not UberX or shared rides. Waymo says they are aiming to be a premium service because the cars (Jaguar I-pace) are much nicer and, of course, there’s the novelty of not having a driver.
Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by jeffbee on Saturday April 20, 2024 @02:00PM (#40099320)
Uber has sent me cars that did not have tires, wipers, or headlights. The fact that Waymo sends you a roadworthy car is, by itself, worth $5 per trip.
Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by jen20 on Saturday April 20, 2024 @02:07PM (#40099396)
Is it? Or should a roadworthy car be considered table stakes for actually being on the road, and one which is not is instead worth a police report?
Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by yCombLinks on Saturday April 20, 2024 @02:29PM (#40099623)
Should be doesn't help. This is what actually happens.
Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by jeffbee on Saturday April 20, 2024 @04:42PM (#40100849)
At least in my city (state, really) the police have vacated their duties to enforce roadworthiness because hand-wringing quasiliberals said that enforcing the laws against bald tires and missing headlights was hurting the poor. Also my state does not have and never had annual safety inspections.
Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by fragmede on Saturday April 20, 2024 @07:11PM (#40101813)
Though, what are the wipers for if the cameras on the Waymo are outside?
Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by fragmede on Saturday April 20, 2024 @07:10PM (#40101806)
It's not a novelty that the driver in the driverless car won't hit on, or harrass a woman taking a trip late a night in an altered state. Uber and Lyft have paid out to settle thousands of lawsuits brought by women who get assaulted by drivers.
Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by perryizgr8 on Saturday April 20, 2024 @01:49PM (#40099207)
> originally thought autonomous cars would greatly reduce costs

In general, it's a mistake to think that selling price has anything to do with the costs. The price is simply what the market will bear. If people are paying Uber $x for a service, waymo would be stupid to price the same service much lower than that. If their costs are much lower, they would rather make that much more profit. If the rider wants a small piece of that pie they can invest in the business (via stocks in the case of Google).

Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by dageshi on Saturday April 20, 2024 @01:57PM (#40099284)
I think more realistically google right now does not want to undercut uber and by extension real drivers who're doing it for a living.

They don't need that kind of bad publicity when potentially the licenses they operate under could be pulled given enough political pressure.

I wouldn't consider current pricing indicative of what it might ultimately be, consider that if aggressive enough google could divert a big portion of the countries car spend to themselves.

Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by tempestn on Saturday April 20, 2024 @01:52PM (#40099232)
It's not useless, but it's a very specific use case: commuting in rush hour traffic.
Re:Mercedes becomes the first automaker to sell autonomous c... by dandy23 on Saturday April 20, 2024 @02:00PM (#40099317)
And that's a very annoying condition to drive under. So quite useful.