I can see arguing to omit it entirely from a language, and to never introduce it, but clearly the Zig authors intend to include it.
Zig's initial async/await solution looked like it would avoid a lot of that mess, but IMHO it's better to not have a feature at all instead of a half-assed feature. So I actually appreciate Zig to focus on other things first if they don't currently have a good plan on how to provide a good async/await implementation that fits the "Zig vision". Personally, it's definitely not anywhere close to the top of my "must have" list for a low level language like Zig.
For example, an http server is using nonblocking calls and dispatches to its own threadpool. The lack of cohesiveness means that the blocking call made by the PostgreSQL library can't feedback into the http server's concurrency model. The http server could expose or pass some control mechanism into the application, but for that to work, all the libraries would need to support it.
A lot of people don't seem to think this is necessary, and I've generally assumed that they're right and there's stuff I just don't understand.
IMO, we haven't really seen a natively compiled and manually memory-managed language "get it right" yet. There are pretty good third-party abstractions for it though.
Async/await is a nice-to-have syntax sugar, but not required to write asynchronous code, and considering the substantial under-the-hood complexity I'm not sure if async/await is a good thing overall, especially in a low level systems programming language like Zig (or FWIW, also Rust and C++).
Arguably, promises are an important concept in JS because it's a convenient and composable method to let code complete "in the background" without proper multithreading, but promises work just fine without the async/await code transformation magic (which even in JS is just the cherry on the top, but not a must-have feature).
> sanitary minimal API for a stack object + state machine + set/longjmp builtin primitives
Traditional async/await doesn't use most of that but instead relies on the compiler to transform sequential 'async code' into a switch-case state machine. What you want sounds more like green threads / fibers with stack switching. This isn't portable to some platforms where the call stack isn't accessible (like WASM). But as I wrote above, I think that lowest layer should simply be 'stdlib functions with completion callbacks'. Those low level functions can then be wrapped into all sorts of asynchronous/multithreading runtimes.
FWIW, I think a stack-switching fiber runtime should be possible in Zig without special language primitives, because Zig has inline assembly: https://ziglang.org/documentation/master/#Assembly