Re:Charge Robotics (YC S21) announces Sunrise autonomous sol...
by ericd on Friday April 19, 2024 @05:25PM
(#40092074)
Thanks for going through that! We used aerocompact, with 18” ground screws/anchors (a lot of them), and their engineering plans for our anticipated wind load didn’t even require all possible ground screw spots to be filled, so it seems like piles might not be strictly necessary?
With panels getting so much cheaper, is tracking necessary still? Maybe if land is at a premium, but I know the aerocompact commercial deployments don’t support tracking.
Re:Charge Robotics (YC S21) announces Sunrise autonomous sol...
by justicz on Friday April 19, 2024 @05:51PM
(#40092316)
Fascinating! My initial thought is that this is going to be very soil dependent. Is this the system you were using? Was it ballasted? https://www.aerocompact.com/en-us/products/ground-mount
Re:Charge Robotics (YC S21) announces Sunrise autonomous sol...
by ericd on Friday April 19, 2024 @05:57PM
(#40092364)
Yeah, we used the g20 south-facing ground mount, no ballast, about 40 18” ground screws for a 48 panel array (relatively small 108 cell panels). Soil is clay, for reference, not very rocky, so might be unusually well suited for the screws. Easy to drive with a socket wrench or impact wrench, 1” heads.
Re:Charge Robotics (YC S21) announces Sunrise autonomous sol...
by mxfh on Friday April 19, 2024 @05:35PM
(#40092179)
30+ years sounds excessive for managed installations (anything thats not just sitting inaccessibly on a roof with prohibitively expensive access costs), would think max 10-20 years, if you have the option to upgrade some higher efficiency panels for maintaining best ROI given current trends continue and land being a cost factor in most regions.
A couple of ways this shows up: 1. making your system rugged to handle extreme weather. These sites need to last 30-40 years without breaking, which pushes you to use pretty heavy + large components. Piles get driven several feet into the ground, so even with unfolding systems you're still probably pile driving. 2. tracking -- adding the complexity to enable rows to rotate to face the sun makes it harder to make the system portable. Basically all large-scale solar getting built is single-axis tracked. 3. module cleaning -- it's important that vehicles can traverse rows to clean dirt off of modules on a regular basis. Having structure that connects the rows together may make this more difficult.
None of these are intractable on their own but together they make the approach you describe very difficult.