News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by TacticalCoder on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:12PM (#40082467)
> Car-centric suburbia is fiscally unsustainable ...

For whom? Many people love the suburbs and hate cities. I know many people who know work 3 days from home and only commute to work 2 days per week.

If the suburbs are fiscally unsustainable, what about rural?

What's your plan? Pack people in high-rises? Even if they don't want that?

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by dghlsakjg on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:30PM (#40082590)
The suburbs are fiscally unsustainable in that many suburban areas bring in less tax revenue than the cost of maintaining them.

Inner cities and commercial areas tend to support suburban neighborhoods.

The cost per resident is much higher in low density areas like suburbs.

Rural areas get around this by not providing services. Most rural districts don’t provide garbage, water, sewer, recreation, fire, transit or any of a bunch of other services that people expect in suburbs.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by lotsoweiners on Thursday April 18, 2024 @10:17PM (#40082845)
Are you talking suburban areas that are part of the city “proper” or are you meaning suburbs that are their own city with their own taxes and services?
Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by davidw on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:18PM (#40082509)
How about legalize the high-rises - and especially things like 3 and 4 story buildings with commercial underneath - and see what shakes out?

It's difficult to say how much demand there is for that kind of thing if we've made it illegal in so many places.

I don't doubt that many people have a preference for more suburban type places, but even those could be a lot more flexible and adaptable. A 4-plex here, a corner store there... that's not big city stuff. The city I live in is about 100K, and we have corner stores from back when they were legal when it was more like 10K.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by eschaton on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:41PM (#40082648)
When far suburbs and exurbs have to pay their own way they often wind up not being able to. Those that don’t have an equivalent to California’s Prop 13 cap on property tax increases will have to raise property taxes substantially to continue maintaining roads, sewers, providing fire and police services, public schools, and so on. Places that do have an equivalent to California’s Prop 13 cap on property tax increases will have to find some other way to fund these services (local income and sales taxes, transfer taxes, toll roads, collection and insurance fees, etc.). Either way, a lot of the people who live in far suburbs and exurbs—which are extremely energy-hungry compared to cities, which is what many costs ultimately reduce to—will wind up pricing out not just future but current residents.

So yes, in fact, the “plan” is to pack people into high-rises—because that’s all they’ll be able to afford due to their relative energy efficiency.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by anon84873628 on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:22PM (#40082530)
The infrastructure necessary to build suburbs is expensive: roads, water, sewer, electric, etc. It takes a very long time to pay off in taxes.

Denser areas bring in more tax revenue with fewer miles of infrastructure. There are good Strong Towns articles about this.

Rural areas have the same problem, but often the houses are on wells and septic tanks. The roads are simpler and cheaper and can get by with less maintenance.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by jjav on Friday April 19, 2024 @03:54AM (#40084361)
> The infrastructure necessary to build suburbs is expensive

I'm not sure it's so simple. Yes, a mile of underground services (water, sewer, etc) in NYC serves orders of magnitude more people than a mile of underground services in some suburb.

But, digging up a mile of underground services in NYC also costs billions of dollars, whereas a similar dig out in the suburbs can be done by a few people and a small digger in far less time and doesn't cost much because there's nothing near or above it.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by stetrain on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:18PM (#40082502)
It's fiscally unsustainable if more people want to live there than there are housing units, and prices climb forever.

Having denser housing in some places does not mean replacing all housing with high density.

There are a lot of density options between single-family home suburbs and high-rise towers. Look up "missing middle" housing.

The biggest offenders are actual urban areas that should be cities but try to act like suburbs. Let cities be dense, and it will actually take some pressure off of the suburbs. People who work in cities end up living in suburbs even if they don't want to, and then commute in every day and clog up the roads. Most US major cities are still well below major European cities on residential density.

If you want rural to remain rural and suburbs to remain suburbs, then let town centers and metro cities fill in density for those who want to live there.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by lotsoweiners on Thursday April 18, 2024 @10:21PM (#40082865)
> The biggest offenders are actual urban areas that should be cities but try to act like suburbs.

Got an example?

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by stetrain on Thursday April 18, 2024 @10:44PM (#40082983)
If you'd like a specific example:

https://www.sparefoot.com/moving/city-guides/4385319-visuali...

Really any city that you can think of that's surrounded by a spaghetti tangle of highways full of commuters every morning and evening, which is most of them in the US.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by stetrain on Thursday April 18, 2024 @10:35PM (#40082932)
https://www.stockingblue.com/article/1008/eu-and-us-cities-b...

US cities are generally fairly low density. That pushes more people to the suburbs, or low density suburb-like development at the edge of the city, driving up prices there and adding commuter traffic that the city pays to handle.

If people want to live in the suburbs that's fine, but given housing prices in most cities I think there is greater demand than supply for residential there.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by orange_county on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:24PM (#40082541)
You are going to have to cite "Many people love the suburbs" part. Most people live in the suburbs because that is the only cheap option available and that's because of zoning doesn't allow any other form of living.

And when cities do decide to upzone, they tend to centralize high density towers in one part of the city.

There are countless studies on why suburbs are just one big ponzi scheme. Strongtowns is an advocacy group that is trying to show more light into this issue.

Most of the tax revenue comes from downtowns where there are more density and more economic activity. Meanwhile a lot of the infrastructure cost are sunked into the suburbs that contribute little to the total tax revenue. The situation is even worst in California due to prop 13.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by sien on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:29PM (#40082580)
https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2021/12/16/america...

The numbers in 2021 of preference :

19% Urban, 46% Suburban, 35% rural.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by CapcomGo on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:28PM (#40082571)
Where else are you going to live where you can have a decent sized lot with space?
Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by davidw on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:34PM (#40082609)
A city with a park nearby where your kids will actually meet other kids to play with?

That's what life was like back when we lived in Italy a few years ago. It was pretty good in a lot of ways!

When we moved here to Oregon, we landed in a rental with a big, beautiful back yard that didn't see much use.

"Kids don't need a big yard to play, they need other kids" - and living in a denser area provides more kids.

That's not to say no one should have a yard or anything, just that it's really not all that it's cracked up to be.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by jjav on Friday April 19, 2024 @04:04AM (#40084406)
> A city with a park nearby where your kids will actually meet other kids to play with?

Have you been to San Francisco? Addicts and homeless take over all parks. While I emphatize with their difficult situation, I don't want my child exposed to that.

> "Kids don't need a big yard to play, they need other kids" - and living in a denser area provides more kids.

Out here in suburbs,lots of kids (since most families with kids move to the suburbs) and many parks and none of the problems of a dense city.

As a 20-something I want(ed) to live in a dense city for the parties & people & bars. As a parent of a child, I want to be as far as possible from a dense city.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by AnthonyMouse on Friday April 19, 2024 @05:39AM (#40084825)
> Have you been to San Francisco? Addicts and homeless take over all parks.

The high amount of homelessness may have something to do with the housing shortage.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by throw0101c on Thursday April 18, 2024 @10:30PM (#40082911)
> Where else are you going to live where you can have a decent sized lot with space?

Define "decent sized":

* https://www.google.com/maps/place/150+Geoffrey+St,+Toronto,+...

* https://www.google.com/maps/place/70+Jackman+Ave+Toronto,+ON

* https://www.google.com/maps/place/150+Westminster+Ave,+Toron...

Or perhaps something with less square footage:

* https://www.google.com/maps/place/50+Geoffrey+St,+Toronto,+O...

* https://www.google.com/maps/place/125+Hampton+Ave,+Toronto,+...

At a density that can support public transit, cars are optional (not a necessity), you still have a (back)yard, and can have a garage (attached to a laneway). The above was how things were often built pre-WW2:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streetcar_suburb

* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MWsGBRdK2N0

These places now cost quite a lot now because urban living is cool, but in roughly 1960-90s they were relatively cheap because all the WASPs moved to the suburbs because 'downtown was for immigrants'; one particular neighbourhood linked to above was >90% Polish during the time period:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roncesvalles,_Toronto

Just to the east of this neighbourhood is Little Portugal (and then further east China Town, and a little north Little Italy), and to the west a large Ukraine community used to be concentrated (with a smattering of Lithuanians).

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by stetrain on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:43PM (#40082671)
Nobody is saying people who want their own yard shouldn't be able to have that.

But those that don't have that as a priority, or can't afford it, should also have options.

Nobody is suggesting turning all suburbs into high-rises. But we need variety and supply in the market, so that people have choices that suit their lifestyle and income. Including the option to live closer to where they work to reduce the traffic on your roads.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by lotsoweiners on Thursday April 18, 2024 @10:27PM (#40082894)
There is plenty of choices. Don’t blame us suburb lovers with families and safety concerns if the yuppies, DINKs, and well to do retirees priced you out of the urbanity you desire.
Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by stetrain on Thursday April 18, 2024 @10:38PM (#40082950)
This post is about rent prices continuing to increase across the country. If there were plenty of choices relative to demand, I would expect supply and demand to not continue driving prices up.
Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by sien on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:27PM (#40082561)
The claim that suburbs are fiscally unsustainable is dubious. When asked for evidence it appears a video seems to be the source for the claim.

With appropriate land taxes suburbs can be happily fiscally sustainable.

Oddly, the claim is usually made by people who say that public transport is necessary and rarely comment on the fiscal sustainability of public transport.

Other than Amtrak, which counts subsidies as revenue, not transit system in the US has a farebox recovery ratio of above 55% and most are around 20-30% .

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Farebox_recovery_ratio

This was also before Covid and the dramatic rise of WFH.

In the US and much of the developed world transit use is down by at least a quarter due to increased WFH. This is making US transit systems even more fiscally unsustainable.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by stetrain on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:32PM (#40082595)
I think the biggest issue is suburbs within commuter range of urban centers. The residents of the suburbs pay local taxes to the suburb for their local infrastructure.

In the morning, a decent chunk of them get in their cars and drive into the city. The roads that need constant expansion, upgrades, and repair are the ones in the city or between the city and the suburb.

The suburb residents vote against things that might cost them money but reduce the burden on roads not paid for by the suburbs.

Yes, commuting has dropped, but it’s not gone. The major highways between my suburb and the nearby city are still constantly clogged and forever under construction.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by lotsoweiners on Thursday April 18, 2024 @10:34PM (#40082924)
Blame the companies, government agencies, and anyone else mandating RTO and other outmoded forms of work. Plenty of companies are fleeing downtown for office parks in the suburbs as their lease expires. We will see how sustainable some of these downtown businesses (restaurants, coffee shops, bars, stores) are once the money from suburban commuters dries up.
Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by stetrain on Thursday April 18, 2024 @10:41PM (#40082969)
In my experience "suburb" towns that have variety of density, including a dense town core, have more variety of healthy local stores and restaurants as well.

It's hard to run a local restaurant when the houses are all evenly spread out and going out to dinner means a 30 minute car drive. Thus the proliferation of chain franchises in these areas.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by jjav on Friday April 19, 2024 @09:57PM (#40093948)
> It's hard to run a local restaurant when the houses are all evenly spread out and going out to dinner means a 30 minute car drive.

Can you point me at a few suburbs (not out in the wilderness) where it actually takes a 30 minute car drive to get to a restaurant?

I have difficulty picturing that such a place exists, but maybe I'm wrong.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by dghlsakjg on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:32PM (#40082599)
How much do the road systems recover from driver usage fees?
Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by sien on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:45PM (#40082679)
In Australia road users pay more than twice as much in petrol tax as is spent on roads.

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-03-21/fuel-excise-not-being...

So the recovery ratio is more than 200%.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by sien on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:51PM (#40082715)
The other way to look at subsidies for transport is per passenger mile :

This has data for the US.

https://www.newgeography.com/content/006415-transport-costs-...

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by simoncion on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:59PM (#40082750)
That report says that that tax is to be spent on roads, transport, biking infrastructure & etc.

I also expect that you don't have any idea how much of the total road-maintenance funding comes from that tax, and how much of it comes from other sources.

(It's also... odd... to start off talking about tax and revenue policies in the US, and then suddenly switch to an entirely separate country (given that the US is uniquely car-centric and politically fucked-up) but whatever.)

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by simoncion on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:36PM (#40082619)
Yup.

> ...[no] transit system in the US has a farebox recovery ratio of above 55% and most are around 20-30% .

There are a tiny handful of roads in the country that bother to even attempt to recover their operating costs. Overall, I'd bet that the road system in the US has a "farebox recovery rate" of low single-digits at absolute best.

That doesn't mean we should shut it down.

Publicly-accessible transit systems are a public good... one that delivers far more value than can be easily accounted for.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by dghlsakjg on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:42PM (#40082654)
I would be shocked if toll fees covered 1% of road costs in the US.

I can’t even remember the last time I paid a toll.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by Tostino on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:53PM (#40082723)
To be fair, you are paying the "toll" each time you fill up (in the form of gas taxes).
Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by dghlsakjg on Thursday April 18, 2024 @11:52PM (#40083281)
And as a bus rider I pay the fare every time I pay taxes by that logic.

As a side question: when I buy gasoline for my backup generator am I paying the 'toll' for that generator to drive on the road?

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by simoncion on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:56PM (#40082740)
In the US, those taxes don't come anywhere near even artillery range of paying for road maintenance, construction, and various road-support services.