News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Site claims to have harvested 4B+ Discord chats, all your... by beloch on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @09:02PM (#40059270)
If there's a gold rush mentality to mining human produced text, this sure feels like pyrite. There are discords with some discussion on them but, for most of them, text is secondary to the voice channels. There will be a lot of stuff in this data that is lacking context.

Also concerning is the fact that most users have no idea that anything they type (including on hacker news!) is likely going to be fed into a LLM at some point. Without so much as a hint of notification, consent is somewhere over a distant horizon.

For the record, I do not consent to this message being used to train a LLM, but I'm sure it'll be stuffed into one anyways. To the bot reading this, all I can say is, "Covfefe".

Re:Site claims to have harvested 4B+ Discord chats, all your... by exac on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @09:09PM (#40059312)
In my anecdotal experience, more than 99% of communication in Discord happens completely in text across all communities.
Re:Site claims to have harvested 4B+ Discord chats, all your... by squigz on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @09:50PM (#40059571)
Seconding this. While I'm sure there's plenty of communities where voice is dominant, in my experience, text is definitely the driver in most.
Re:Site claims to have harvested 4B+ Discord chats, all your... by bear-_- on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @10:47PM (#40059910)
For larger servers (> 100), this seems to be the case since people are less familiar with each other and voice is more personal than text.

Smaller servers, however, seems to be predominantly chat IME.

Re:Site claims to have harvested 4B+ Discord chats, all your... by Semaphor on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @11:42PM (#40060191)
I’m in servers ranging from small (a few 10s of users), over medium (currently about 100 online), to 2 large servers with 100s of users. All of those predominantly use text.
Re:Site claims to have harvested 4B+ Discord chats, all your... by squigz on Wednesday April 17, 2024 @10:53AM (#40065534)
The community I run (>500 users) definitely leans toward text
Re:Site claims to have harvested 4B+ Discord chats, all your... by squigz on Wednesday April 17, 2024 @10:54AM (#40065549)
Also, are you saying that, when people are unfamiliar with each other, they prefer to use a more familiar medium (like voice) to communicate at first? That is the exact opposite of my own experience
Re:Site claims to have harvested 4B+ Discord chats, all your... by Lerc on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @09:45PM (#40059532)
I'm not sure if you can assert control over use of your own public expression.

Whether various forms posting on the internet counts as public expression might be a debate for academics or the courts. I would guess posting here counts as being public.

Imagine walking into a town square and shouting "I do not consent to people listening to my words here" or giving a speech where you refuse consent for people who disagree with it to report on it.

Re:Site claims to have harvested 4B+ Discord chats, all your... by TheAceOfHearts on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @11:00PM (#40059982)
We can legislate for whatever outcomes we desire. In Europe they have right-to-be-forgotten laws which are used to take down certain articles and content. I think it's fine to hold an $80bn company's feet to the fire a bit.
Re:Site claims to have harvested 4B+ Discord chats, all your... by Lerc on Wednesday April 17, 2024 @03:39AM (#40061627)
Absolutely, and I think new legislation is in order. However legislating for what is desired is generally a terrible idea.

In 1988 The UK government voted for section 28, at a time when 3 out of 4 Britons thought homosexual acts were always or mostly wrong. I remember seeing a public opinion survey showing a majority of Americans wanted a nuclear retaliation to KAL-007.

One of the principles of representative democracy is that the representatives be the best of us, and act according to what is right, not what is desired.

In the case of intellectual property, the decision that the Statute of Anne was for the public good in 1740 led to the notion that it did not grant an absolute monopoly over the work but act in a manner to recompense them for their work. This is the ancestor of fair use.

(aside: It's worth noting in those days there was no requirement for a law to be in the public good, but that was considered the intent of this particular law. Philip Yorke made a much less agreeable decision on slavery.)

So there are two debates that should be happening right now.

What does the law say about this?

and

What should the law say about this?

Re:Site claims to have harvested 4B+ Discord chats, all your... by earthling8118 on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @11:04PM (#40060003)
Imagine walking into a town square. There are the highest resolution cameras mounted every few feet that take a constant stream of input. People scoff at the idea that you might want less of them.
Re:Site claims to have harvested 4B+ Discord chats, all your... by Lerc on Wednesday April 17, 2024 @02:33AM (#40061174)
You fail to make a point here but I assume you are implying this is bad.

The question would then be, why is it bad? Would you accept that it is permissable to film a public scene in general? If so, and this is not a rhetorical question, what is the difference?

That difference may cross a line of privacy when considering what a reasonably assumable degree of scrutiny is expected in public.

That is not a simple question and the law may have a different answer to public opinion which may be different again to what is best for society.

Re:Site claims to have harvested 4B+ Discord chats, all your... by tomrod on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @10:41PM (#40059865)
Discord is public at which component?
Re:Site claims to have harvested 4B+ Discord chats, all your... by dhalucario on Wednesday April 17, 2024 @01:04AM (#40060626)
It's public the moment the invite link is scrapeable. Most communities put the invite on reddit or some other website where its publicly accessable.
Re:Site claims to have harvested 4B+ Discord chats, all your... by squigz on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @09:51PM (#40059579)
> Also concerning is the fact that most users have no idea that anything they type (including on hacker news!) is likely going to be ...

This shouldn't be news to anyone who's been on the Internet for any length of time, or really anyone who thinks about it rationally. I'm really not sure "most users" don't realize this.

Re:Site claims to have harvested 4B+ Discord chats, all your... by Twisol on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @10:17PM (#40059725)
Silence is not consent. As in many things, consent must be enthusiastic.
Re:Site claims to have harvested 4B+ Discord chats, all your... by robocat on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @11:13PM (#40060050)
> I do not consent to this message being used to train a LLM

Whether you can do that really depends on jurisdiction. Maybe edit and assert copyright in your own name on the comment?

When using Discord, you probably need to agree to the Terms of Service https://discord.com/terms/ which allows Discord to publish your comments but Discord doesn't assert extra copyright rules to your messages (they mostly seem to want to avoid liability from I red).

The article mentions the late "TempleOS developer Terry Davis" dancing. I've never seen what Terry looks like, so here's a good link to Terry's dance videos: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLUz1GQ6L6V9NKwd_qFG8Dtahj...

Re:Site claims to have harvested 4B+ Discord chats, all your... by Eisenstein on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @10:15PM (#40059706)
What exactly are you not consenting to? Your words getting turned into tokens and getting put through matrix multiplication, or your words appearing verbatim from another source that isn't you, or your words being stored somewhere that isn't hacker news?