News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scaling will never get us to AGI by jqpabc123 on Thursday April 11, 2024 @12:46PM (#40004187)
To me, all the arguments against AGI appear unconvincing, motivated by religion/faith, or based on definitional sophistry.

Religion is belief in the unknown without reason or logic.

Do you know of any inanimate object that is truly "intelligent"?

Without ever knowing or seeing a single, real working example, you "believe" and have "faith" that it is possible. By so doing, you are practicing religion --- not science.

Re:Scaling will never get us to AGI by the8472 on Thursday April 11, 2024 @03:38PM (#40005971)
That's like complaining about artificial, non-organic flight being a fantasy before the wright brothers. Which would not have been entirely wrong, but hardly a knockout argument as we now know with certainty.

There is a vast difference between "engineering challenges have not yet been proven moot by a working prototype" and "precluded by physics or mathematics".

The (in)animate distinction is more akin to net-positive fusion in a man-made vessel vs. in a gravity well rather than obeys the 2nd law of thermodynamics vs. perpetuum mobile.

Re:Scaling will never get us to AGI by jqpabc123 on Thursday April 11, 2024 @04:09PM (#40006295)
That's like complaining about artificial, non-organic flight being a fantasy before the wright brothers.

Nope.

Before the Wright brothers, we knew it was scientifically possible to suspend objects heaver than air is an air current. For example, kites and balloons.

The only examples we have of "intelligence" are organic in nature.

Since we have no examples to the contrary; for all we know, "life" and "intelligence" could be somehow inter-related.

And we don't currently fully understand or know how to engineer either one. Yet people have "faith" --- just like the alchemists.

Re:Scaling will never get us to AGI by the8472 on Friday April 12, 2024 @07:36AM (#40011400)
> The only examples we have of "intelligence" are organic in nature.

High-abstraction category-words such as "intelligence" are not fundamental properties of nature. They're made by man. Which means we currently happen to define intelligence in a way that we primarily observe in organic objects. So there's some circular reasoning in your argument. If we look at all the more fundamental building blocks such as information-processing, memory, adaptive algorithms, manipulating environments then we know all of them already are implementable in non-organic systems.

It is not a blind belief decoupled from reality. It is an argument based on the observation that the building-blocks we know about are there and they have not been put together yet due to complexity. There also is the observation that the "putting together" process has been following a trajectory that results in more and more capabilities (chess, go, partial information games, simulated environments, vision, language, art, programming, ...), i.e. there's extrapolation based on things that are already observable. Unless you can point at some lower-level piece that is only available in organic systems. Or why only organic systems should be capable of composing the pieces into a larger whole. I am not aware of any such limiting factor.

Just like "suspending" objects in air was possible and self-propelled machines were possible, even if not self-propelled flight had not yet been done at that time.

Re:Scaling will never get us to AGI by myrmidon on Thursday April 11, 2024 @07:22PM (#40007863)
This is very nonconvincing to me, because you dance around the core of your own argument, refusing to state it plainly: Why would it be necessary for everything intelligent to consist of animated matter? You don't even offer a plausible hypothesis.

To me the null hypothesis is that non-organic intelligence is possible --at worst (!!)-- simply by emulating exactly what an intelligent organic entity does (but it seems obvious to me that this approach is likely to be wasteful and inefficient).

Re:Scaling will never get us to AGI by jqpabc123 on Thursday April 11, 2024 @07:36PM (#40007955)
Why would it be necessary for everything intelligent to consist of animated matter?

It may not be necessary --- but at this point in time, we really don't know enough to state this as a fact.

What we do know is that our only working examples of "intelligence" are all organic and mostly analog --- not digital. Suggesting that real "intelligence" is possible without "life" --- is unsupported by any evidence and is a pure leap of faith at this time.

Re:Scaling will never get us to AGI by myrmidon on Thursday April 11, 2024 @08:06PM (#40008103)
First, "It doesn't exist already" is an extremely poor argument against the technical feasibility of really anything :P

> Suggesting that real "intelligence" is possible without "life" --- is unsupported by any evidence and is a pure leap of faith at this time.

Strongly disagree on this; If you accept that brains effect intelligence by selfinteraction accoring to physical laws, then "computability" directly and inevitably follows. And that implies artificial brains are feasible...

Re:Scaling will never get us to AGI by jqpabc123 on Friday April 12, 2024 @11:15AM (#40013881)
And that implies artificial brains are feasible...

Given enough time, money, effort and energy, anything is *feasible* --- even converting lead into gold.

Expecting it to just *emerge* somehow on it's own without any real design or plan or understanding of the scope involved --- that goes way beyond *feasible* or *practical* and heads straight for *magical thinking*.

Re:Scaling will never get us to AGI by Windchaser on Friday April 12, 2024 @12:17PM (#40014577)
Is anyone expecting it to "just emerge somehow"?

This seems strawmanny. There has been an absolute ton of research into figuring out what kind of design/scope is necessary. More planning and research is happening all the time, and architecture is specifically being changed with a mind towards specific new functionalities. It's not haphazard; it's planned. Yes, there is some room for 'emergence' or learning, but that doesn't mean there isn't also a lot of structure and planning.

The picture you present of NN research is so far off from what I see actually being done in this field that I'm a little boggled. Are you sure you're in touch with what's actually happening in the field?

Re:Scaling will never get us to AGI by dragonwriter on Thursday April 11, 2024 @08:09PM (#40008116)
> Do you know of any inanimate object that is truly "intelligent"?

So, your argument is that by making something intelligent we would necessarily also make it animate?

That's reasonable, but doesn't impact the plausibility of AGI. “Artificial” is not “inanimate”.