News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scaling will never get us to AGI by myrmidon on Thursday April 11, 2024 @08:06PM (#40008103)
First, "It doesn't exist already" is an extremely poor argument against the technical feasibility of really anything :P

> Suggesting that real "intelligence" is possible without "life" --- is unsupported by any evidence and is a pure leap of faith at this time.

Strongly disagree on this; If you accept that brains effect intelligence by selfinteraction accoring to physical laws, then "computability" directly and inevitably follows. And that implies artificial brains are feasible...

Re:Scaling will never get us to AGI by jqpabc123 on Friday April 12, 2024 @11:15AM (#40013881)
And that implies artificial brains are feasible...

Given enough time, money, effort and energy, anything is *feasible* --- even converting lead into gold.

Expecting it to just *emerge* somehow on it's own without any real design or plan or understanding of the scope involved --- that goes way beyond *feasible* or *practical* and heads straight for *magical thinking*.

Re:Scaling will never get us to AGI by Windchaser on Friday April 12, 2024 @12:17PM (#40014577)
Is anyone expecting it to "just emerge somehow"?

This seems strawmanny. There has been an absolute ton of research into figuring out what kind of design/scope is necessary. More planning and research is happening all the time, and architecture is specifically being changed with a mind towards specific new functionalities. It's not haphazard; it's planned. Yes, there is some room for 'emergence' or learning, but that doesn't mean there isn't also a lot of structure and planning.

The picture you present of NN research is so far off from what I see actually being done in this field that I'm a little boggled. Are you sure you're in touch with what's actually happening in the field?