News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Sonauto – a more controllable AI music creator by rlp on Wednesday April 10, 2024 @04:44PM (#39995518)
Wow. I just had it write a song about being sad about losing my keys in r&b/soul style, I'm totally blown away:

https://www.udio.com/songs/bDY5CYdJZP93AdpgpfBJNX

Re:Show HN: Sonauto – a more controllable AI music creator by swalsh on Wednesday April 10, 2024 @03:04PM (#39994525)
None of these "songs" have any emotion.. AI music just doesn't make me "feel" anything yet.
Re:Show HN: Sonauto – a more controllable AI music creator by postalrat on Wednesday April 10, 2024 @04:04PM (#39995150)
Probably because you haven't heard them before.
Re:Show HN: Sonauto – a more controllable AI music creator by Kiro on Wednesday April 10, 2024 @03:21PM (#39994715)
Would you pass a blind test?
Re:Show HN: Sonauto – a more controllable AI music creator by suyash on Wednesday April 10, 2024 @05:07PM (#39995740)
I bet that's only becuase you know it's created by AI. If no one told you that and you hear someone sing that song and play along bet you will feel. AI is only getting better, it will be just as good as any human and only way we will be able to tell is when it's disclosed if it's AI-generated or not.
Re:Show HN: Sonauto – a more controllable AI music creator by relaxing on Wednesday April 10, 2024 @07:38PM (#39996828)
If no one told me they were AI, I’d probably assume it was a parody group or a house band messing around in the studio. It doesn’t sound like an artist writing with intention.

And I’d wonder why they encoded at 32kbps with a RealMedia codec from 1998.

Re:Show HN: Sonauto – a more controllable AI music creator by developer1000 on Sunday April 14, 2024 @02:07PM (#40033044)
So true! I tried at least 4 songs they are all lame in the same way it hurts my ears couldnt get past 10 seconds. Still its quite an achievement well done developer! I mean we cant expect real creativity out of a lifeless machine can we.
Re:Show HN: Sonauto – a more controllable AI music creator by huac on Wednesday April 10, 2024 @03:29PM (#39994811)
it's difficult to gauge from outside / as a consumer, but what's interesting is rarely where models are at a given point in time, but rather where the model/team will be with similar amounts resources. it may very well still be Udio (who presumably have significantly more resources than Sonauto), but I would hesitate to say that a compute advantage counts as being 'far ahead.'
Re:Show HN: Sonauto – a more controllable AI music creator by froyolobro on Wednesday April 10, 2024 @03:04PM (#39994520)
These are pretty incredible. More compressed, but way better 'songwriting' and 'performance'
Re:Show HN: Sonauto – a more controllable AI music creator by klohto on Wednesday April 10, 2024 @02:23PM (#39994062)
meh, Suno v3 still has better quality for me personally
Re:Show HN: Sonauto – a more controllable AI music creator by throwup238 on Wednesday April 10, 2024 @02:33PM (#39994144)
In my experience with Suno ($40 spent so far) sound quality is worse than the cherry picked examples from Udio - especially the vocals - but everything I've heard from Udio could best be described as the elevator music equivalent of their respective genres so that's probably why it sounds so good. There seems to be a real quality vs originality trade off in the state of the art.

That said, I've only had the chance to generate a few songs with Udio and they have all sounded like they were recorded by a prison band in an overcrowded cell (I create mainly instrumental/orchestra/sound track music).

Re:Show HN: Sonauto – a more controllable AI music creator by bufferoverflow on Wednesday April 10, 2024 @02:34PM (#39994150)
Not for me. Suno voices sound distinctly robotic/metallic.
Re:Show HN: Sonauto – a more controllable AI music creator by jmacd on Wednesday April 10, 2024 @02:56PM (#39994422)
Something about a discussions of the nuance/taste of different LLMs for different purposes is really interesting to see when it is related to something like music.