News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by mindcrime on Sunday May 20, 2012 @11:48AM (#3999071)
"Open Plan" offices are more evil than Satan, The Beach Boys, Pop-under Ads, Politicians, and Slashdot Trolls all rolled up into one. I would never knowingly subject anybody to that crap.

Which is why, if/when the day comes that Fogbeam Labs can acquire office space and hire employees, I intend to make sure that everyone gets a private office, with a door. Knowledge workers need the opportunity for privacy and way to avoid countless, unnecessary context switches. Open Plan is practically designed to generate the maximum possible number of interruptions and distractions during the course of a day. It's disrespectful to people to put them in a situation like that, and it's less productive. That's just the wrong way to do things, as far as I'm concerned.

Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by opminion on Sunday May 20, 2012 @12:25PM (#3999179)
The interesting question for us who agree with you is why do other people think otherwise. Two reasons come to mind: some co-workers don't mind the disruptions themselves (e.g. if they do a different kind of work), and some managers simply just like the view.
Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by mindcrime on Sunday May 20, 2012 @12:48PM (#3999243)
The interesting question for us who agree with you is why do other people think otherwise. Two reasons come to mind: some co-workers don't mind the disruptions themselves (e.g. if they do a different kind of work), and some managers simply just like the view.

I'm a cynic and tend to believe that in most cases it comes down to a belief (rooted in short-sighted thinking) that open-plan saves money by compressing more people into a given number of square feet of office space. That is, I think few - if any - managers actually believe that open-plan is better for productivity or anything... they just think it's cheaper, and they don't bother balancing the cost savings with the other factors.

Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by luser001 on Sunday May 20, 2012 @12:58PM (#3999276)
This explanation makes sense: one (cost) is easily measurable, the other (productivity) isn't. The first gets optimized.
Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by antidoh on Sunday May 20, 2012 @03:49PM (#3999855)
Imagine a large open plan space full of cubicles.

Now imagine that same space, redesigned with walls and doored-offices. It would be a rabbit warren, and not only would most people not have a window, you couldn't even see a window while walking around.

Which got me thinking. A compromise between open plan cubes and rabbit warren offices would be to slightly enlarge the cubes, and extend their walls up to the ceiling, but the wall material above chest height would be glass, so natural light has a chance to distribute throughout the space.

Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by kabdib on Sunday May 20, 2012 @04:20PM (#3999956)
A ring of offices surrounding a common area (with couches and whiteboards) is the best environment I've been in. I have fond memories of parts of Apple's Infinite Loop 1.

Reportedly Apple was going to put cubicals in the IL buildings, but decided to go with hard-walled offices because it was cheaper in the long term.

(I haven't worked there since '94 or so -- for all I know it's wall-to-wall cubicals, with three minions to a cubie and the fourth hunkered under the table beside the power strips).

Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by ericras on Sunday May 20, 2012 @05:11PM (#4000114)
That's essentially how offices were in the 60s/70s - giant open floors with wall-like solid/glass partitions up to the ceiling. Also more configurable than drywall when the floorplan needs to change. Take a look at the current season of Mad Men for example.

I think what changed was cubical walls are much cheaper and easier to move and some managers like being able to walk around and keep an eye on everyone (Lumbergh).

Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by andrew93101 on Sunday May 20, 2012 @02:12PM (#3999537)
If you compare the cost of renting commercial space to the cost of software engineer labor, this explanation doesn't hold up.

The cost of commercial rent is minuscule when compared to the cost of engineering labor. If a business believed doubling floorspace would genuinely increase productivity by even 10%, it would be a no-brainer financially.

Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by luser001 on Sunday May 20, 2012 @04:57PM (#4000077)
One (space per engineer) is much more controllable than the other (pay per engineer). Hence it gets controlled.

You've got to cut what you can, not necessarily the biggest expense.

Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by rhizome on Sunday May 20, 2012 @11:14PM (#4001088)
I have to wonder whether the managers using that rationale notice whether compression comes at the cost of efficiency.
Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by andrew93101 on Sunday May 20, 2012 @12:40PM (#3999224)
I think the successfulness of open space plans depends greatly on the work you're doing.

If you're working primarily alone on difficult engineering problems, with well-defined specifications and a clear division of who owns what part of the code, then (from my experience) solitary offices are more productive. Communication doesn't need to be as high-bandwidth, and concentration needs to be deep.

On the other hand, there are many environments that are different. If your organization intentionally has low-fidelity product requirements, the cost of communicating with business stakeholders needs to be low. If you intentionally eschew code ownership, engineers will frequently be working in areas of the codebase they haven't worked in before and need to talk to colleagues who know it better.

Open plans make concentration harder and communication easier. Closed office plans are the reverse. I think no office plan is "better" than the other, but rather our office plan should fit the work style of your organization.

Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by nessus42 on Sunday May 20, 2012 @12:56PM (#3999266)
I've always had an office until the last few years. Now I work in a cubicle. My feeling is that communication was much easier for me in an environment with offices. The reason for this is that I could have in-depth conversation with others in an office. In a cubicle, I feel that having a conversation with someone else is antisocial because it will annoy everyone else.

The real reason for cubicles and open floor plans is that it makes the bean counters happier. Everything else is rationalization, IMHO.

Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by icebraining on Sunday May 20, 2012 @03:27PM (#3999774)
Are the two really opposed? At my job, we have an open floor plan and a couple of closed rooms where people go for conversations, talking on the phone, etc. Seems to work fine, although I don't have much of a gauge to measure by.
Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by nessus42 on Sunday May 20, 2012 @05:12PM (#4000123)
We tend to call those "meetings" rather than "conversations".
Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by ericras on Sunday May 20, 2012 @05:14PM (#4000127)
What if two people need to work together on a computer and they only have desktops. The commom-area closed room doesn't do them any good.
Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by grannyg00se on Monday May 21, 2012 @12:54AM (#4001345)
The common-area closed room should have a desktop computer in it.
Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by jlarocco on Sunday May 20, 2012 @01:57PM (#3999495)
I don't buy your arguments in favor of open space plans.

In my experience, clarifying a requirement or requesting a feature always takes far less time than coding it up. As a developer, I'd rather you call me over to your office and we spend 30 minutes discussing what you want, then I go back to my office and spend an hour working on it and get back to you if I have any more questions.

If the business stakeholders are changing requirements and coming up with new ones so often that they need constant communication, then there's a problem. Hold a meeting to get the requirements nailed down, then give the developers some quite time to work.

For developer-developer questions I've found it's almost always easier to ask questions via email, instant message or IRC because of copy/paste.

Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by mindcrime on Sunday May 20, 2012 @12:54PM (#3999262)
Open plans make concentration harder and communication easier. Closed office plans are the reverse. I think no office plan is "better" than the other, but rather our office plan should fit the work style of your organization.

I actually mostly agree with that in a sense. I won't deny that - at times - there can be advantages to the increased communications bandwidth of having everybody in one small space, communicating freely. I just don't think it's the optimal setup for all the time.

To elaborate on what I said above, if Fogbeam Labs had funding and employees and all that jazz, I would plan on putting employees in private offices. But, I'd also want to accompany that with plenty of open space, with tables, chairs, couches, and lots of big whiteboards-on-wheels, so that people would have a place to spontaneously self-organize into small groups to collaborate on an ad-hoc, as-needed basis. But yet, everyone would have the option of retreating to their private office for periods of deep thought and intense focus.

The thing is, I think that it would be better to put the open-space lounge like areas near the outside walls of the building, where the natural light is... which would mean putting individual offices near the core, away from the natural light. On that point, I'd love to hear the opinions of other HN'ers. What would you prefer, a private office with less access to natural light, and the lounge-like area described above near the windows, OR an office with a window, and the collaborative space in the middle, away from the natural light?

Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by nessus42 on Sunday May 20, 2012 @01:05PM (#3999307)
Natural light in offices, lounges in center. A few nooks with natural light.
Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by MDCore on Sunday May 20, 2012 @04:47PM (#4000042)
You're missing out on a potentially happy medium: Small offices of up to (for example) four people. When you're all working together on a project, the communication is likely to be relevant to everyone in the small room. Better than being out in the open plan where unrelated people are having discussions that might be interesting, but are really just distracting.
Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by rhizome on Sunday May 20, 2012 @11:17PM (#4001094)
Open plans make concentration harder and communication easier

So in other words, all else equal, they reduce the signal to noise ratio.

Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by cdcarter on Sunday May 20, 2012 @03:05PM (#3999709)
I work in a non-programming office. My team actually just has a large room with two tables in the middle of it, that we set ourselves up at. When we're hard at work, we look a lot like the Scoble picture of the "Facebook war room" [1].

Most of our tasks are either very individual and require good mental flow (like programming), or are done in pairs. The open layout let's us communicate when we need a pair. We also have designed our workflow so that almost all of the tasks we complete can be done by any member of the team. If someone is bored or sick of what they are doing, they can just bounce on to another task, as long as it doesn't screw up the timeline. If two people are bored, they usually just...swap.

We're able to keep a level of friendly camaraderie really easily. We all hear what is going on, so when someone needs to pick up the slack on a project, we all know the requirements.

It works well. But everyone on my team is the sort of person who it'd work well for.

[1]: http://www.flickr.com/photos/scobleizer/5179447062/

Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by shurane on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @02:26PM (#4044085)
That actually sounds kind of cool, but I can't imagine it fitting a big company. Maybe it works for ultra-small companies or individual teams.

Where do ya work, might I ask?

Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by jrockway on Sunday May 20, 2012 @08:17PM (#4000662)
Why have offices at all? Since people won't be talking in person (are you going to walk into someone's office to interrupt them?), why make everyone commute?
Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by bdunbar on Monday May 21, 2012 @12:05AM (#4001230)
Why have offices at all?

Meetings. Nothing says 'I'm the boss' like assembling one's minions in a conference room for an hour.

But one might really want to provide your knowledge workers with office in the same suite so they do physically interact when they want/need.

For everything from 'just a quick chat to eradicate a problem' to chance chit-chat in the breakroom ... physical presence makes all kinds of good things happen.

Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by mindcrime on Monday May 21, 2012 @01:17AM (#4001396)
Since people won't be talking in person (are you going to walk into someone's office to interrupt them?),

What? That's totally ridiculous. Of course I'll walk into someone's office, if the door is open. I've worked in offices where developers have individual offices before, and there's plenty of "in person" conversation that goes on. The difference is, the "in person" between, say, mindcrime and jrockway, isn't disturbing / interrupting joerandomuser. And, jrockway has the option to close his door, which is a very strong signal indicating "I don't want to be bothered right now."

Re:From Cubicles, Cry for Quiet Pierces Office Buzz by dionidium on Sunday May 20, 2012 @03:48PM (#3999851)
A hipster-trash response that completely ignores the main point of your comment and focuses on one throwaway portion of it: "Pet Sounds" is one of the best albums ever made.