Negative numbers were first used around the 3rd century in China and took until the 16th century to be used in Europe. Modern double-entry bookkeeping was invented in the 14th century in Europe. So if you ever wonder why they traditionally use a column for debit and one for credit, with definitions that seem a bit strange: that was the best way to make it work with only positive numbers.
(A)ssets - (L)iabilities = (I)ncome - (E)xpense
So if you have more (+100) Assets, then to balance it out, you either need to have: +100 Liabilities (100 A - 100 L = 0) → You took out a loan and increased your liabilities
-100 Assets (100 A - 100 A = 0) → You sold an asset for what it was worth
+100 Income (100 A = 100 I) → You provided a service and earned income
-100 Expense (100 A = 0 I - -100 E) → You got a refund for a previous expense
I think that’s much more intuitive. You can think always think in terms of more or less Assets, Liabilities, Income or Expenses, then use the Accounting equation to check your reasoning.Here’s a deeper explanation: https://fragment.dev/docs#design-your-ledger-ledger-accounts
Disclaimer: I’m CTO at Fragment
* you can actually think of oddball reasons you might consider a "negative credit/debit", but it's more akin to something like a negative mass in physics
There's no need to learn any confusing "credit" or "debit" jargon, you just need to think about the movement of money (which you had to do already).
You don't need negatives in accounting, because anything that is affecting a number differently than the rest (reducing rather than increasing), needs to be accounted for separately. Imagine showing negative revenue. That would be mostly useless. You want to see how much revenue you had, and in a separate entry, how many expenses. Imagine how misleading it could be to show $0 in expenses last month, when in reality, you had $100 in expenses, but you subtracted $100 out because you returned some big purchase from last month and got a refund.
That's actually already how it works, the kind of inverse you use depends on if the account is credit-normal or debit-normal. You end up in the same place.
> Imagine showing negative revenue. That would be mostly useless.
Revenue is already credit instead of debit, which if you were consistent in using negative numbers, a negative revenue be completely correct (so you would want to sweat if revenue was a positive number). It's weird, but it lets your cash on hand be a positive number, which is just a necessary consequence of the system.
> Imagine how misleading it could be to show $0 in expenses last month, when in reality, you had $100 in expenses, but you subtracted $100 out because you returned some big purchase from last month and got a refund.
Wouldn't that be accurate? This would be a debit of 100 and a credit of 100 which nets a balance of 0. But individually you would see the transactions and could sum the credits and debits if you were so inclined.
Alternatively, contra-accounts exist if reporting these individually is material for some reason.
It can also obfuscate it pretty well!
[0]the third basic type of statement, in addition to balance sheet and profit & loss.
For example, see this Apple Corp. financial report[0] -- it includes a statement of cash flows. I think you'd find that all other companies required to publicly share their financials will include the same report.
[0]https://www.apple.com/newsroom/pdfs/FY22_Q4_Consolidated_Fin...
If you are selling widgets for $1.20 and buying them for $1, and they are delivered after you order them, you are limited on how many open orders you can have at any point in time even though you make money on each order.
A companies cash flow will be dependent on employees, capital expenditures, money for stock, returns rates, tax requirements etc. etc. So it's heavily dependent on what type of business is being run and the specifics of how the business is being run.
There are many important aspects of organisational design that are only loosely correlated with financial statements.
It was only after bookkeeping became ingrained into all levels society that negative numbers were considered equally real as positive numbers.
That is very different from understanding concepts like owing someone money, which is a form of negative.
Chinese and Indian mathematicians and accounting from Babylonian times didn't have the same mental blocks.
The Bakhshali manuscript is still the first known example of modernish notation I think, but used +
Just a tiny number of formulas (accounting identities [1]) and statements (P&L, balance sheet, etc.) can represent what's going on in any org in ways that can be roughly comparable. Reminds me of the "fundamental theorem of calculus" or "central dogma of biology".
Accounting is also where we get math and written language [2] as ancient Mesopotamian civilizations initially kept track of commodities using specific "accounting tokens" [3] shaped like the thing represented, and that evolved into written language, imagine: hieroglyphics.
Later, Al-Jajr [4] (aka algebra, literally "balancing") was invented by Al-Khwarizmi (origin of "algorithm") to solve Islamic inheritance law, whose rules of splitting up became a series of equations that led to the need to solve them quickly and correctly. Al-Khwarizmi's quadratic formula was the origin of why "algorithm" gets its name from him.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accounting_identity
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_accounting
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_ancient_numeral_sys...
[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Jabr
[5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Khwarizmi