>> I find these issues difficult when also considering security keys like Yubikey. Like you can't clone a yubikey and that's considered a feature not a bug.
Yes, I am quite aware of this. My complaint is that I cannot expect my grandma to be able to perform this action. It would even be difficult if there was a cloning program, but without it, this is certainly an insurmountable task.
Sure, you can make the argument that my grandma is dumb and tech-illiterate, but the truth of the matter is that this is the bar for the average person. You, me, and other Hacker News users would have no issues with these tasks, but this is not representative of the general FIRST WORLD population. Not to mention those in developing countries.
The technical aspects are great! But they also need be made available for the average person. Be that by bringing the average person up to sufficient level or through careful design to bridge this gap. But what is clear is that the current state of things is insufficient. Especially consider that this is Apple's main value: design.
I am really happy that there are people doing security and making things more secure, but the truth is that usability is necessary too. The reason Signal is so great is not just because encryption, it is because my Grandma can use it. Not aware of any other encrypted text message system besides iMessage and WhatsApp that has that usability and those come with strings. I really think there needs to be something similar for MFA. Consider the user.
Edit: A possible suggestion for FindMyDevice is to have trusted users. That you can give your wife, friend, whatever permission to find your device without needing to sign into your account or any other permissions. This seems like a relatively obvious solution, is there something wrong with it? Google devs, can't you patch this in in a few weeks (or less? But we all know, bureaucracy exists)