News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by andy99 on Sunday April 07, 2024 @03:12PM (#39962982)
Canadian government "investments" like this end up just sucking all the oxygen out of the ecosystem and incentivizing everyone to work to get government money instead of actually working on something industrially relevant. This will be a net loss for the country and a gain for a few well connected groups.
Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by abdullahkhalids on Sunday April 07, 2024 @03:45PM (#39963244)
> The bulk of that — $2 billion — is going into a fund that will aim to provide access to computing capabilities and technical infrastructure.

What else should the Canadian government do? How do other more successful countries use such money to jumpstart some industrial sector?

Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by skeeter2020 on Sunday April 07, 2024 @04:21PM (#39963553)
Instead of giving Microsoft $$$ for compute, and other loosely-aligned, established companies (your Nortels, RIMs and SNC Lavalins) a bunch of hand-outs, they could fund primary research that will actually add long-term value, address skills shortage with immigration support & accompanying challenges (like housing) and stop taxing the sh!t out of both companies and individuals.
Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by AwaAwa on Sunday April 07, 2024 @07:44PM (#39964925)
This sounds sensible. Which means it's off the table.

Instead ArriveCan part deux would be a better money pit.

Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by tlavoie on Sunday April 07, 2024 @11:30PM (#39965971)
We do have the National Research Council, which does real research (and then spins off companies from developed tech.) Sounds useful to me.
Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by ompogUe on Monday April 08, 2024 @10:05AM (#39969840)
fingers crossed that could work. but a when harper came in he gutted the nrc, so hopefully these things don't push us there again
Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by andy99 on Sunday April 07, 2024 @04:18PM (#39963529)
The premise that they need to borrow $2.4B and spend it on something is incorrect.
Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by reducesuffering on Sunday April 07, 2024 @04:09PM (#39963447)
They should prioritize making Kitchener and Toronto have a very affordable high quality of life *cough* build housing *cough*, so that UW students will stay in the country making businesses rather than emigrating for a better quality of life in the US.
Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by mitthrowaway2 on Sunday April 07, 2024 @04:18PM (#39963530)
This exactly. A sizeable slice of talent at US tech companies are Canadian expats who realized that ironically, the only way they'd ever be able to afford to live in Canada someday would be to move to the States for their career.
Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by personjerry on Sunday April 07, 2024 @04:55PM (#39963836)
Being a Canadian, having worked in SF, London, and Toronto, this actually seems like a reasonable approach. It's certainly hard to compete on wages but a lot of people do appreciate Canada and life here, and cutting these costs would go a long way.
Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by rdsnsca on Sunday April 07, 2024 @05:26PM (#39964091)
Housing is a provinivcal responibility
Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by reducesuffering on Sunday April 07, 2024 @08:27PM (#39965145)
It is the state’s responsibility to intervene when provinces have neglected or are unable to support their people. The % of income a median Canadian has to spend on housing is crisis level.
Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by barfard on Sunday April 07, 2024 @03:49PM (#39963285)
tax cuts instead of subsidies might do better
Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by abdullahkhalids on Sunday April 07, 2024 @04:02PM (#39963392)
Interestingly, last year, Canada introduced tax credits to support the clean energy technology sector [1]. Its "total over $60 billion over the coming ten years" [1]. But there is also some actual money in the same package.

So I wonder, what the thinking of the government is in deciding when tax credits and when direct subsidy.

[1] https://www.canada.ca/en/environment-climate-change/news/202...

Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by depereo on Sunday April 07, 2024 @04:29PM (#39963618)
Tax cuts are used more often when the government wants to see more private investment into an industry. Not really an issue with 'AI' right now.

Direct subsidy is more common when the government wants to see a particular outcome; then they can more easily steer those funds to realize it.

Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by mitthrowaway2 on Sunday April 07, 2024 @04:15PM (#39963504)
I would say not necessarily cuts, but at least tax reforms to de-risk equity compensation. Canada doesn't have an 83b election equivalent, and it's easy to end up losing a lot of money through taxes on illiquid stock options that end up amounting to more than the stock options are eventually worth. An alternative, for example, would be to allow paying taxes on stock options "in-kind": have the option to give the government a share of the stock options themselves, rather than paying that percentage in dollars on a valuation that you can't actually sell them for.
Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by 1attice on Sunday April 07, 2024 @04:06PM (#39963427)
citation needed.
Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by WhereIsTheTruth on Sunday April 07, 2024 @04:24PM (#39963580)
Nuclear energy is the fruit of government money, what VCs do with AI currently is a waste of both time, energy and talents, generative AI is not what's important

https://www.ft.com/content/0cdf78f9-e2cc-48ff-ba65-027f1cf83...

Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by WhereIsTheTruth on Monday April 08, 2024 @09:22AM (#39969463)
Obviously downvoted, hence why the current climate ;)
Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by belter on Sunday April 07, 2024 @03:43PM (#39963232)
It's exactly the same with EU Funds.
Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by wongarsu on Sunday April 07, 2024 @04:02PM (#39963393)
Many of the big EU grants are very broad, so you can bring nearly any project and argue your case.

Sure, certain things increase your chance of acceptance, and those don't always align with industry needs, but the same can be said about any funding source. It's not like VCs are known for wisely allocating money according to industry needs either. What matters is giving enough projects a chance and letting the market solve the rest.

EU grants do have other issues and are difficult as your sole source of money. But I don't think funneling everyone away from industry needs is one of them.

Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by svara on Sunday April 07, 2024 @03:46PM (#39963259)
That's a risk, but really in Europe the alternative often isn't to find private investment somewhere else, but to continue working for some big company or university or whatever. The EU runs the programs it does because otherwise no one would be funding innovation.
Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by CalRobert on Sunday April 07, 2024 @04:09PM (#39963449)
Honest question.. where do we find these EU programs?
Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by svara on Sunday April 07, 2024 @04:13PM (#39963484)
Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by mistrial9 on Sunday April 07, 2024 @04:11PM (#39963464)
this is overly pessimistic -- for example 'Horizon 2020' in the EU had half failures perhaps.. but a couple of the projects are really strong and now growing.. so, no.
Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by postepowanieadm on Sunday April 07, 2024 @04:16PM (#39963517)
That's really optimistic.
Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by ein0p on Sunday April 07, 2024 @03:50PM (#39963294)
Drop the word “Canadian” - it applies worldwide, with very few exceptions.
Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by eli_gottlieb on Sunday April 07, 2024 @04:00PM (#39963373)
Ummm... where do you think industrially relevant research comes from?
Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by 1attice on Sunday April 07, 2024 @04:19PM (#39963537)
That's the crux of the problem.

1. You have a country that is, broadly speaking, industrially oriented towards selling raw goods (wood, metals) to other countries, from whom you buy back finished products. It might not technically be mercantilism, but the dynamic is the same, and, like mercantilism, it's a mug's game. It's also increasingly unpopular with your population, which is increasingly aligned with environmentalists, because of this whole world-endy forest-firey junket that's on trend. (Fun aside: look up 'TMX'. They will never get that built.)

2. So: you want to move to a more modern economy that doesn't make you a vassal state to 'allies' (who are also your customers, who are also your employers, who also run the general store from which you buy your shovels,) and does not inflame the ire of your increasingly restive voters, who have just spent a summer inhaling the fumorous remains of several hundred thousand trees. (And not the fun kind.) So, why not just laissez the faire and let the economy sort it out?

3. (Answering 2) Because, it turns out, that unguided markets entrench existing patterns. Left to their own devices, I'm sure Canada's engineering firms would come up with _even better ways_ of ripping oil from tar sands, but, again, by 1. and 2., you really don't want to do that these days, and besides, what are you going to do when demand for dilbit goes down? There are these 'solar' panels, now, you see, and ---

And so,

4. You meddle with the shape and direction of the market. You know this will cause ineffiencies, and you know that some quotient of well-connected asshats will get rich from this by doing essentially nothing. But it's still more appealing than sticking with 1 and 2.

5. If you can do this in a way that hooks into existing trends (and AI is, for most normal people, still a Big New Thing,) you may also win a leapfrog opportunity over your neighbours, pulling a TSMC-but-AI out of thin air. (Perhaps the aurora borealis.) That's a lotto ticket worth scratching. Just ask Taiwan.

That's why the government funds things up here. Because they wouldn't happen at all, otherwise, and that outcome is less optimal than having them happen inefficiently. The waste along the way is a necessary evil. No pump is 100% efficient, but if gets water from the well, who cares?

In a hundred years, we don't want to be still selling maple syrup to the ever-warring states of Trumpida and Greater Oregonifornia. We want to be selling the shovels. (A nation can dream, can't it?)

And this fund, which is less than a 40th of what was spent on a nonexistent and unworkable oil pipeline, helps get us closer to that.

Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by skeeter2020 on Sunday April 07, 2024 @04:25PM (#39963589)
We are huge exporters, but I don't agree with your premise; one of the things we export in huge volume is the engineering talent needed to make progress. These are young economic migrants, who leave to enrich a new country, typically the US. If they come back it's generally after they've made their career contributions and are ready to draw on a more generous social system.

>> You meddle with the shape and direction of the market.

It's worse than that; they're picking winners and losers, and that's inexcusable.

Re:Justin Trudeau announces $2.4B for AI investments in Canada by 1attice on Sunday April 07, 2024 @05:01PM (#39963882)
Why, to you, is that inexcusable? This sounds like market-worship to me.

Markets are a useful tool. But like LLMs they can make mistakes.

Also, why not put those brilliant young minds to work here instead, rather than give their best years to the competition?

That's brain drain, my friend