Re:Elon Musk's reputation is falling – and it's taking Tesla...
by idopmstuff on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:55AM
(#39919079)
People see him as a caricature - either Lex Luthor or Tony Stark - but it seems pretty apparent that he's a pretty complicated human being who is very smart, has a weird kind of charisma when speaking on topics he's passionate about and had a pretty terrible childhood.
He's a dumbass Twitter troll, but also he has done maybe more than any other human being for climate change by using Tesla to pull the entire automobile industry forwards at least a few years on the EV transition. He's also the reason that the US is far and away the dominant power when it comes to space, and he got us there by spending basically all of his personal fortune (where a lot of other people would've bought yachts or sports teams or whatever with it).
I wish he didn't have some of his more insane views, and I wish he wouldn't be a dickhead on the internet. Grand scheme, though, it does feel like we're better off with him than without.
Re:Elon Musk's reputation is falling – and it's taking Tesla...
by bloppe on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:25PM
(#39919433)
Elon is not that smart. He's an anomalously hard worker. He can focus on one thing for 18 hours a day, seven days a week, for years. That's his super power. I think he's made a lot of impressive accomplishments, and he certainly keeps a lot of smart people on his teams, but his intelligence never played an outsize role in his success
Re:Elon Musk's reputation is falling – and it's taking Tesla...
by bloppe on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @01:23PM
(#39920304)
Elon lives a very public life. It's not that hard to judge his intelligence with the embarrassment of interviews, tweets, and articles generated by him and about him every day.
I also happen to have met him and have several friends who work with him directly. The people who know him well certainly don't think of him as a genius
Re:Elon Musk's reputation is falling – and it's taking Tesla...
by drcongo on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:52PM
(#39919800)
I'm perplexed by you claiming that he's very smart, so same question to you. Personally, based on all available evidence, I don't think he's smart at all. At a guess I reckon a good 75% of HN users are smarter than him or me.
Re:Elon Musk's reputation is falling – and it's taking Tesla...
by idopmstuff on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @01:46PM
(#39920590)
He is one of the most successful people to have ever lived. We regularly have rockets that launch into the air and then land (200+ of these successfully in a row) because of a company he started.
I know the counterargument is that he's not smart, he just hires smart people, but if you know smart people, they generally don't get recruited by idiots (even rich ones). He managed to surround himself with rocket scientists and engineers who revolutionized space travel. His company successfully navigated not only the engineering side but also the part that involves dealing with the bureaucracy of the US government. He came up with the idea to launch Starlink (and idea that others failed at before him) in order to create revenue to support rocket launches.
I just apply Occam's razor here - given all of these things that he and his companies have accomplished, is it likelier that he's smart or stupid? And if he's stupid but still managed to accomplish these things, why didn't other rich people who are smarter than him accomplish them? How come Bezos is so much worse at creating a space company than Musk? We live in a capitalist society, so if all it takes is a few hundred million dollars and no brains to start SpaceX, which is worth many, many multiples of that, why has no one else done it?
Re:Elon Musk's reputation is falling – and it's taking Tesla...
by drcongo on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @03:58PM
(#39922284)
I mean, you're just applying some loose heuristics for what you think defines a smart person, and so am I. If you know smart people, they generally don't spend their days amplifying nazis on Twitter and replying to everything they say with a "rolls on floor laughing" emoji. I think I'd lean towards @bloppe's hunch long before yours, but yours is just as valid.
Re:Elon Musk's reputation is falling – and it's taking Tesla...
by idopmstuff on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @09:36PM
(#39925608)
There's a difference in capability, though. A smart person is capable of being stupid on Twitter. A dumb person is not capable of recruiting top-tier rocket scientists + engineers and starting a company that has achieved everything that SpaceX has.
Re:Elon Musk's reputation is falling – and it's taking Tesla...
by matthewiiiv on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:49AM
(#39919020)
This is such a non article. There is no attempt to present evidence to support the claim in the title, other the perspective of a guy who did a survey about something unrelated.
Re:Elon Musk's reputation is falling – and it's taking Tesla...
by Finnucane on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:12AM
(#39918529)
The many recalls and occasional explosions probably aren't doing them any favors reputation-wise either. If they had maintained a reputation for impeccable construction despite Musk, Musk would be less of a factor. But they haven't done that.
Re:Elon Musk's reputation is falling – and it's taking Tesla...
by idopmstuff on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:56AM
(#39919093)
The recalls are almost entirely OTA software updates around things that pose basically no safety issues (the last one was related to the size of icons on the touchscreen).
Re:Elon Musk's reputation is falling – and it's taking Tesla...
by JohnFen on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:09AM
(#39918485)
I will never buy a Tesla simply because they come with "features" that I find completely unacceptable. Musk doesn't enter into it.
That said, I consider Musk to be so awful in so many ways that I do my best to avoid doing anything that will put money in his pocket. So even if Tesla produced a product I would enjoy, I wouldn't buy one.
Re:Elon Musk's reputation is falling – and it's taking Tesla...
by leetharris on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:28AM
(#39918731)
Tesla has the #1 selling vehicle in the world for years. They have a weak quarter, just like BYD and others, and suddenly the entire leftist online world is eager to blame it on Elon. They salivate at the idea that every problem is his fault. Successes, of course, are never his fault.
You see the same treatment for anyone who is vocal and isn't leftist. They have even started to come after Joe Biden, likely the most progressive president in history.
People rush to share their anecdata on sites like this where they say, "I hate Musk so much I'd never buy a Tesla." The vast, vast majority of the world doesn't exist in online bubbles.
I say this as a liberal who has never voted right in my life so please don't label me as alt-right or nazi or whatever the current flavor is of "I don't agree with leftist Twitter posts.
Re:Elon Musk's reputation is falling – and it's taking Tesla...
by gamepsys on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:45AM
(#39918968)
> They have a weak quarter, just like BYD and others, and suddenly the entire leftist online world is eager to blame it on Elon.
If a company has a weak quarter then blaming the CEO and largest shareholder is a perfectly valid thing to do. Who else has more blame? How else do you expect people to judge company performance then stock prices? This isn't some witch hunt, this is normal business procedures. A company has a bad quarter we question it's leadership.
Re:Elon Musk's reputation is falling – and it's taking Tesla...
by CodeWriter23 on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:49AM
(#39919012)
Typically the blame is on the CEO’s performance, not his personal views. This is nothing more than a cheap hit piece by a regime that hates Musk giving a voice to the little people.
Re:Elon Musk's reputation is falling – and it's taking Tesla...
by gamepsys on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:56AM
(#39919091)
This isn't an auto industry problem. This is a Tesla problem. Toyota is doing fantastic. Ford and GM are performing well. If you argue that this is an EV problem then we can easily blame the leader of the EV market for the reason why EV is down.
Re:Elon Musk's reputation is falling – and it's taking Tesla...
by Tiktaalik on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:49AM
(#39919013)
> A separate study from analytics firm CivicScience tracking Musk’s approval among US consumers found that 42 percent of respondents viewed him unfavorably, compared to 34 percent when his stake in Twitter was announced in April 2022.
Re:Elon Musk's reputation is falling – and it's taking Tesla...
by seanhunter on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:52AM
(#39919054)
The source for the story isn't the "entire leftist online world" (Whatever that is) but rather is a survey called the "consideration" survey published by reuters. In the latest version tesla's score (which is basically the percentage of people who would consider a particular brand when deciding on a new vehicle) has gone down a lot and in the survey of results people cited Musk as part of the reason they would not consider a tesla.
This is only a left/right issue insofar as the respondents to the survey cited his right-wing online views specifically as a reason.
I would think if your pitch is at least partly to the environmentally-conscious, being toxic to left-leaning people is probably bad business.
Additionally, as far as the stock goes, it has an extremely high P/E ratio meaning very high future expectations are priced in. IN that world, failing to meet expectations is much worse than for a more reasonably-priced stock. That's just how the maths works out (given how P/E ratio relies on discounted future earnings).
Re:Elon Musk's reputation is falling – and it's taking Tesla...
by bloak on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:43PM
(#39919673)
Is that a well-defined thing? How is one supposed to know whether the FooBar WomBat 20 is the same vehicle or not as the FooBar WomBat 20i? Do auto industry insiders have a clear concept of this?
Re:Elon Musk's reputation is falling – and it's taking Tesla...
by The_Colonel on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:54AM
(#39919076)
> Tesla has the #1 selling vehicle in the world for years
To avoid getting a wrong impression, Tesla has a worldwide marketshare of 2% and is outside of top ten largest producers.
Companies spend billions on marketing and advertisement, to evoke association of pleasant feelings with their products. But somehow Elon spitting into the face of Tesla's target demographic (affluent, tech affine, ecology-conscious people who typically lean left) has absolutely zero effect on sales. Color me skeptical.
Re:Elon Musk's reputation is falling – and it's taking Tesla...
by infamouscow on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:56AM
(#39919098)
Progressivism is indistinguishable from secular religion.
The good news is it's internally inconsistent and eventually destroys itself and it's followers.
You're seeing it first hand, receiving downvotes for an interesting comment made in good faith. You failed to uphold a never ending litany of purity tests. The progressive lunatics cannot abide by blasphemous comments and have designated you a heretic.
The greatest trick the devil ever pulled was to convince the world that he was an artist.
Everyone has weird and extreme views somewhere on some topic. Most just won't express them.
He's a dumbass Twitter troll, but also he has done maybe more than any other human being for climate change by using Tesla to pull the entire automobile industry forwards at least a few years on the EV transition. He's also the reason that the US is far and away the dominant power when it comes to space, and he got us there by spending basically all of his personal fortune (where a lot of other people would've bought yachts or sports teams or whatever with it).
I wish he didn't have some of his more insane views, and I wish he wouldn't be a dickhead on the internet. Grand scheme, though, it does feel like we're better off with him than without.
I also happen to have met him and have several friends who work with him directly. The people who know him well certainly don't think of him as a genius
I know the counterargument is that he's not smart, he just hires smart people, but if you know smart people, they generally don't get recruited by idiots (even rich ones). He managed to surround himself with rocket scientists and engineers who revolutionized space travel. His company successfully navigated not only the engineering side but also the part that involves dealing with the bureaucracy of the US government. He came up with the idea to launch Starlink (and idea that others failed at before him) in order to create revenue to support rocket launches.
I just apply Occam's razor here - given all of these things that he and his companies have accomplished, is it likelier that he's smart or stupid? And if he's stupid but still managed to accomplish these things, why didn't other rich people who are smarter than him accomplish them? How come Bezos is so much worse at creating a space company than Musk? We live in a capitalist society, so if all it takes is a few hundred million dollars and no brains to start SpaceX, which is worth many, many multiples of that, why has no one else done it?
More discussion:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39895207
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39906147
Correlation != Causation
Damn, watching a little too much Fox News, eh?
To me this idea seems more divisive than any of the actual political differences.
That said, I consider Musk to be so awful in so many ways that I do my best to avoid doing anything that will put money in his pocket. So even if Tesla produced a product I would enjoy, I wouldn't buy one.
You see the same treatment for anyone who is vocal and isn't leftist. They have even started to come after Joe Biden, likely the most progressive president in history.
People rush to share their anecdata on sites like this where they say, "I hate Musk so much I'd never buy a Tesla." The vast, vast majority of the world doesn't exist in online bubbles.
I say this as a liberal who has never voted right in my life so please don't label me as alt-right or nazi or whatever the current flavor is of "I don't agree with leftist Twitter posts.
If a company has a weak quarter then blaming the CEO and largest shareholder is a perfectly valid thing to do. Who else has more blame? How else do you expect people to judge company performance then stock prices? This isn't some witch hunt, this is normal business procedures. A company has a bad quarter we question it's leadership.
But if everybody in the sector is having a weak quarter, generally you blame it on macroeconomic or outside conditions.
The leader of the EV market is BYD. So by your logic we should blame their CEO. Yet nobody knows his name, so we obviously aren't.
It seems to mostly be a China problem. Tesla has massive China exposure, but a lot less than BYD. BYD was hit harder than Tesla.
The world is more complex than american politically rotted brains believe it to be
Sure are a lot of "leftists" out there.
This is only a left/right issue insofar as the respondents to the survey cited his right-wing online views specifically as a reason.
I would think if your pitch is at least partly to the environmentally-conscious, being toxic to left-leaning people is probably bad business.
Additionally, as far as the stock goes, it has an extremely high P/E ratio meaning very high future expectations are priced in. IN that world, failing to meet expectations is much worse than for a more reasonably-priced stock. That's just how the maths works out (given how P/E ratio relies on discounted future earnings).
With that said, I do largely agree with your main point.
To avoid getting a wrong impression, Tesla has a worldwide marketshare of 2% and is outside of top ten largest producers.
Companies spend billions on marketing and advertisement, to evoke association of pleasant feelings with their products. But somehow Elon spitting into the face of Tesla's target demographic (affluent, tech affine, ecology-conscious people who typically lean left) has absolutely zero effect on sales. Color me skeptical.
The good news is it's internally inconsistent and eventually destroys itself and it's followers.
You're seeing it first hand, receiving downvotes for an interesting comment made in good faith. You failed to uphold a never ending litany of purity tests. The progressive lunatics cannot abide by blasphemous comments and have designated you a heretic.