News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Going from CTO to Developer? by convolvatron on Saturday March 30, 2024 @03:24PM (#39877806)
the only problem with this is that as an IC when your manager is really doing poorly and not grasping their job, its _really_ hard not to say 'dude wtf, that's just not right'. that can go pretty badly. so you really have to work hard to stay extra constructive and support them as if you were _their_ manager, without the authority that usually implies. and that's a heavy burden as an IC
Re:Ask HN: Going from CTO to Developer? by ed312 on Saturday March 30, 2024 @03:53PM (#39878037)
As an eng manager, I always make it super clear (many times) when new engineers onboard they're always welcome to say "this doesn't make sense" ask for more details. Sometimes (maybe even often) they're right. I also enourage them to "assume good intent" from other devs and managers. Fundamentally no one manager knows everyone and no one engineer is right about everything.
Re:Ask HN: Going from CTO to Developer? by hnfong on Saturday March 30, 2024 @03:58PM (#39878075)
Yea, the problem is that bad managers likely end up being bad because they don't have this humility.
Re:Ask HN: Going from CTO to Developer? by convolvatron on Saturday March 30, 2024 @04:11PM (#39878171)
I don't think it's really a question of humility. it's more about placing the highest value on the functioning of the team. once your overriding goal is 'not looking bad', and 'escaping blame', that goal, which should be primary gets completely lost.
Re:Ask HN: Going from CTO to Developer? by random99292 on Monday April 01, 2024 @03:28AM (#39891647)
It's not humility, it's ego. A lot of managers can't take the ego hit and will treat an IC as a threat. This is especially true if the manager has reached Peter Principle.
Re:Ask HN: Going from CTO to Developer? by tylerrobinson on Saturday March 30, 2024 @03:36PM (#39877894)
This is true, and it’s also true when you’re a manager. You always need to manage up and down.
Re:Ask HN: Going from CTO to Developer? by ldjkfkdsjnv on Saturday March 30, 2024 @03:38PM (#39877914)
This is partly why ageism exists. The longer you have worked, the more obvious the failings of your superiors are. Older workers are harder to trick into working on some project that will fail/produce no business value.
Re:Ask HN: Going from CTO to Developer? by jf22 on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @10:08AM (#39905937)
Conversely, older workers don't really care about what has business value and what doesn't, and if they did, they certainly care less about getting entangled in a discussion about it.

I know a lot of older workers, myself included, who don't want a seat at that table anymore.

Re:Ask HN: Going from CTO to Developer? by erkmene on Saturday March 30, 2024 @03:34PM (#39877879)
This is an exceptionally profound observation. IMO not having a strong ego helps and if it goes right, everyone benefits from this.
Re:Ask HN: Going from CTO to Developer? by yieldcrv on Saturday March 30, 2024 @03:42PM (#39877933)
hm, that might be happening to me, I'm an IC right now

I make it pretty clear during hiring that I don't have aspirations beyond IC anymore. Been there done that kind of vibes, I like to build. I say my value add is that I can add a vote for whatever policy or method would improve an org, people seem to like that.

But I'm currently on a team where leadership is doing everything outside of the sprint cycle, random demos in the middle of the week that nobody ever heard of before that day and so we must have all these features ready for right then, so I asked - I thought - a light question in the middle of the standup "are we using the sprint cycle?" because we have 2 week sprints and standups. and that was the.biggest.deal I've ever seen, all the leadership was convulsing amongst each other because they all have to show face to each other, instead of addressing their incompetence. "We- we- we'll take this offline!"

the meeting offline never happens. leadership can't be reached throughout the day. and the other IC's I do talk to (who don't know I've been in other non-IC roles before) act like I asked the biggest boat rocking question ever and I'm putting a target on myself.

To me, thats funny because the biggest boat rocking question would have been "why don't you do a demo from the staging branch that you're supposed to merge from dev in a schedule that's parallel and independent of the sprint" "why don't we have a staging branch, do you know what you're doing?" "why are you merging our pull requests in any order, not knowing the code base, and then yelling at us when there are merge conflicts, we should be reviewing each other's PRs"

Its actually a tolerable position,

but maybe there is a reality that I do have other jobs and maybe more comfortable about my prospects than other ICs there, and also have management experience that is impossible to hide.

Re:Ask HN: Going from CTO to Developer? by vrinsd on Sunday March 31, 2024 @05:30PM (#39888231)
This reeks of a situation where the people in the management position(s) really aren't the right people for the job and having a logical discussion or trying to explain how or why something should be done differently falls on deaf ears (or worse, antagonizes them).

Maybe I'm projecting from my own experiences but this usually is because the leadership has a "top down" mentality, "we know better because we are in this role" and your other team members who are likely less experienced than you can't tell the difference between "dissenting with evidence" vs. "being contrary".

Seems like the best plan is to keep your eyes open for other opportunities when it's no longer tolerable.

Re:Ask HN: Going from CTO to Developer? by yieldcrv on Monday April 01, 2024 @04:43AM (#39891966)
Yes, it is top down management, and comically ineffective for application development

We’ll see.

Re:Ask HN: Going from CTO to Developer? by yieldcrv on Monday April 01, 2024 @09:27PM (#39901399)
edit: I got fired today for that
Re:Ask HN: Going from CTO to Developer? by yowlingcat on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @05:07AM (#39903695)
You're a newly fired IC? In a comment several days ago about vesting schedules it sounds like you were speaking as a cofounder. If these were the same role then something smells suspicious about how your coworkers were treating you from the start IE any of these leaders and the general style of operating the company should have included your input. Moreover, I'm surprised they'd make a decision like this so flippantly as I'm not sure how it could be easy to fire a cofounder without significant legal headache to the company.
Re:Ask HN: Going from CTO to Developer? by yieldcrv on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @10:44AM (#39906305)
I’ve been everything

I work for other people right now

These were not the same roles

Re:Ask HN: Going from CTO to Developer? by yowlingcat on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @02:13PM (#39908993)
I guess I don't get it -- if you've founded a company and it went successfully enough to where you can be an LP (or you are otherwise independently wealthy), why would you join an early stage company full-time as an IC when you could join as a consultant or advisor to smoke out whether the collaboration is a good fit for you?
Re:Ask HN: Going from CTO to Developer? by yieldcrv on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @03:36PM (#39909970)
bear market in my asset class and fallback employment sector was a little long

and its not an early stage company

I want fresh IC references and thats been successful

I want subsidized health insurance / contribute to an HSA and that's been successful, at least I have COBRA again and can keep contributing to an HSA uninterrupted

I want professional validation on stacks I want to use, get paid to do that

I want structure because doing side projects on my own schedule didn't have the same motivation for me

why does being versed in other parts of the industry dilute the point, need me to log in with an alt to be relatable?

Re:Ask HN: Going from CTO to Developer? by yowlingcat on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @06:30PM (#39911545)
I think it's okay to want the freedom, outsized reward and even the status of being a successful founder, with all the risks attached. I think it's also fine to want the benefits and stability of being an materially comfortable employee in tech with a good career progression. They are different paths and different strokes work for different folks.

But I think it's fair to say you have to pick a lane. You can't have your cake and eat it too. If you haven't succeeded as a founder, it rings ironic to proclaim "4 year vesting with 1 year cliff is just simulating what FAANGs were doing 10 years ago but out of touch tech wannabes are imagining is normal now" or that "we only took non-dilutive capital, nothing that converts to shares - people need to use their imagination."

Do you think it's fair for someone would to ask whether if you were really serious about succeeding as a founder, you should've invested a little less imagination into the capitalization strategy and a little more imagination towards identifying the ideal customer problem to be solved? After all, it's not like there's any dearth of founders who have built successful businesses with the standard VC backed approach. Especially those who were facing bear markets for what they were building.

Lord knows VC could use some competition. The issue I've observed is that everything else (except bootstrapping for very specific kinds of businesses) is purely worse for a founder who isn't already independently wealthy, which is ultimately just a different kind of bootstrapping.

I'd love to be proven wrong if there is, empirically, an alternative.

Re:Ask HN: Going from CTO to Developer? by yieldcrv on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @10:30PM (#39913040)
so you find these ad hominems in my post history to be relevant because they were interesting to you, but then the idea of actually being passionate about being on the coding side is too incongruent with what you think someone that achieved large numbers would do, calling into question that exposure and experience

okay

following my business successes - which can include passing through profits outright, and or exits - I’ve done “thought leadership” and advisory to other companies, I’ve travelled around Europe for extended periods of time half way doing advisory but mostly living out a dream I wanted and enjoyed, I’ve formed funds and managed capital with great legal counsel, fund administrators, the works. I’ve had periods of illiquidity, even periods where liabilities were greater than assets, right now I like to get paid to do nextjs, and rust, and a couple other stacks.

turns out, you don't have to pick a lane. people take the linkedin and resume I choose to show at face value, which only shows IC roles and an Engineering Manager role.

Re:Ask HN: Going from CTO to Developer? by yowlingcat on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @05:18PM (#39923287)
Well, there's only so much time I can spend on the internet convincing someone with an oversized sense of their own success that they're doing it wrong, so I'll try to be brief and I wish you all the best after this interaction.

If we're being frank, if the idea of picking a lane is doing something well, by choosing both lanes, you've actually chosen neither lane.

1. You are clearly not independently wealthy enough to have to never work again; otherwise you wouldn't care about "subsidized health insurance / contribute to an HSA" (both of which are things that the independently wealthy couldn't care less about), so either you are a) making up achieving outsized exits as a financier and you never actually achieved it, or b) worse, you made the outsized exit, became independently wealthy, and due to fiscal irresponsibility lost your position of independent wealth

2. You clearly aren't in a stable career position at a company with a long tenure steadily moving upward seeing as how you ended up having to take a job at a company with incompetent leadership that ultimately ended up firing you for making ultimately a reasonable suggestion

If anything, I think you have proven my point which is that you very much do need to pick a lane. There's the old saying that "startups don't die of starvation, they die because of indigestion" owing to the common and real risk of overly broad scope and dilution of focus. I think that same warning applies equally to careers -- your dilution in long-term focus may have played a role in you not achieving the success you might otherwise have been able to achieve. But I can't tell you for sure. Only you will be able to figure out that answer. And in order to figure out that answer, you have to be willing to be honest with yourself.

Best of luck.

Re:Ask HN: Going from CTO to Developer? by mousetree on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @09:32AM (#39905571)
You got fired for just asking "are we using the sprint cycle?" There must be more to this story, no?
Re:Ask HN: Going from CTO to Developer? by yieldcrv on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @10:34AM (#39906197)
the aforementioned guy merging PRs in random order decided that the existence of merge conflicts were all the devs fault, pinned a merge conflict on me and said I wasn't a good fit for their management style, a charitable explanation as none of us would pass an interview if we described an application development process this way

so I did in fact put a target on myself for asking anything

all happened at the end of yesterday, thought I was in the clear but they were conferring. My weekend post and reflection ironically turned out to be foreshadowing.

(hm all the time stamps are wrong, I originally posted the observation two days ago. I posted this sunday or so and got fired on monday afternoon)

Re:Ask HN: Going from CTO to Developer? by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @09:58AM (#39905838)
> and the other IC's I do talk to (who don't know I've been in other non-IC roles before) act like I asked the biggest boat rocking question ever and I'm putting a target on myself.

That tells you much about the culture of the place. The other ICs know that you can't ask questions like that - they know that not only is the place dysfunctional as far as the sprint cycle, but it's vengefully dysfunctional - management will get you if you point out their dysfunction.

Re:Ask HN: Going from CTO to Developer? by VirusNewbie on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @04:27PM (#39910513)
When I've had managers who have less experience than I do... I simply end up not really being managed by them. They appreciate someone who can 'manage themselves' and I don't have to deal with them coaching someone who could coach them.

I've also had peers become my manager, and vice versa, and that's the dynamic that seems quite successful.

Now if your manager is so bad that they can't recognize you are an extremely low touch employee...well, it doesn't matter the experience level, you'll be in for a bad time.