News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenAI says it can clone a voice from just 15 seconds of ... by lr4444lr on Saturday March 30, 2024 @08:23AM (#39874160)
First text, then images, soon video and speech.

It feels like OpenAI is mostly concerned with developing proofs of the untrustability of every digital medium, creating a convincing case either for doing everything in person again, or necessitating cryptographic signatures on absolutely everything.

Re:OpenAI says it can clone a voice from just 15 seconds of ... by anon373839 on Saturday March 30, 2024 @08:53AM (#39874388)
In some ways, this just feels like a reversion to the mean for humanity. “Don’t believe everything you read” is a maxim as old as print, and it’s good advice. If people ultimately learn that videos and recordings can’t be trusted, is that a huge loss? I’m not sure.

Of course, the road from here to there may be bumpy...

Re:OpenAI says it can clone a voice from just 15 seconds of ... by mewpmewp2 on Saturday March 30, 2024 @09:32AM (#39874693)
In which cases anyhow would they have been a trustworthy content. You could easily take real videos out of context which people were already doing to mislead.

Ultimately you should reason and investigate deeper to hold somewhat accurate opinion on anything.

Most media and news out there already is where the agenda comes first and then it is about compiling cherry picked content from wide variety of content as evidence for that agenda. And you can find content to support any agenda already.

It is a simple algorithm of:

1. We want to prove X.

2. From millions of datapoints we pick the 100 that support X the most.

3. We write an article on it.

4. Most of our readers already agree with X so they will be happy about it. No need to go deeper.

5. Anyone who doesn't agree would probably not read our platform anyway.

Re:OpenAI says it can clone a voice from just 15 seconds of ... by scarface_74 on Saturday March 30, 2024 @09:37AM (#39874742)
Re:OpenAI says it can clone a voice from just 15 seconds of ... by Shawnj2 on Saturday March 30, 2024 @10:04AM (#39875014)
The answer we see is that if you put AI generated stuff in places people don’t look at too carefully they won’t care because they won’t notice. I’m not sure that’s great precedent
Re:OpenAI says it can clone a voice from just 15 seconds of ... by fragmede on Saturday March 30, 2024 @09:00AM (#39874447)
scammers have already used this technology to convince people that someone they know needs money for some reason
Re:OpenAI says it can clone a voice from just 15 seconds of ... by anon373839 on Saturday March 30, 2024 @10:10AM (#39875065)
Right, we're in a somewhat dangerous period where the general public doesn't understand the capabilities that exist and how they can be misused. But if you mentally fast-forward to a time when people do understand this and have even become blasé about it, what does that time look like? (Presumably, you don't wire money based on a phone call without kicking the tires a bit...)
Re:OpenAI says it can clone a voice from just 15 seconds of ... by taskforcegemini on Saturday March 30, 2024 @10:35PM (#39880831)
it also means that audio and video proof that someone did you dirty can not be used anymore, because they could be fake
Re:OpenAI says it can clone a voice from just 15 seconds of ... by testacpwoek on Saturday March 30, 2024 @01:42PM (#39876909)
> In some ways, this just feels like a reversion to the mean for humanity.

No it doesn't, this is ridiculous. All of you guys with your "this is just like the printing press" arguments are so intellectually lazy, think a little more about the problems of scale and speed and the way information spreads in the modern world.

Re:OpenAI says it can clone a voice from just 15 seconds of ... by anon373839 on Saturday March 30, 2024 @07:27PM (#39879654)
Your tone is unwarranted. Also, an empty appeal to modernity, lacking any specifics whatsoever, is about as lazy as arguments get.
Re:OpenAI says it can clone a voice from just 15 seconds of ... by leovailati on Saturday March 30, 2024 @08:41AM (#39874308)
> It feels like OpenAI is mostly concerned with developing proofs of the untrustability of every digital medium

Which, to me, makes sense. Once the underlying technology exists, a malicious actor would not think twice before developing tools of deceptionlike those. It makes sense that OpenAI would work on that "in the open" to demonstrate that we now need to be skeptical of audios.

Re:OpenAI says it can clone a voice from just 15 seconds of ... by reaperducer on Saturday March 30, 2024 @08:41AM (#39874301)
It feels like OpenAI is mostly concerned with developing proofs of the untrustability of every digital medium

Agreed. I'm still waiting for the part of AI where it's supposed to benefit mankind.

So far, it's 10% entrainment, 20% employment elimination, and 70% crypto-grade hype.

The next AI winter can't come soon enough so the tech industry can get back to doing useful things.

Re:OpenAI says it can clone a voice from just 15 seconds of ... by Asraelite on Saturday March 30, 2024 @09:03AM (#39874480)
> 20% employment elimination

How is this not benefiting mankind?

If you're concerned with unequal distribution of the generated wealth then that's a political problem, nothing to do with AI.

Re:OpenAI says it can clone a voice from just 15 seconds of ... by anileated on Saturday March 30, 2024 @09:39AM (#39874767)
When I hear “ML-based generative tools pushing people out of their jobs is just a political problem”, that I hear is “ClosedAI and Microsoft definitely had nothing to do with choosing to not license and compensate original creators whose works they have acquired in order to build their commercial products, it’s all the government’s fault”.

Often the same people will cry over-regulation about ML tech rollout potentially being suppressed and controlled via policy, even though that is literally the implication of their position.

Re:OpenAI says it can clone a voice from just 15 seconds of ... by Turing_Machine on Saturday March 30, 2024 @10:55AM (#39875457)
> OpenAI is mostly concerned with developing proofs of the untrustability of every digital medium, creating a convincing case either for doing everything in person again, or necessitating cryptographic signatures on absolutely everything.

Am I alone in thinking that this would not be a bad thing?

Re:OpenAI says it can clone a voice from just 15 seconds of ... by tomjen3 on Saturday March 30, 2024 @09:01AM (#39874449)
Honestly cryptographic signatures being more widespread does not seem a bad thing to me.

Obviously not everywhere: I don't need a reddit worldnews comment or a recipe for blueberry muffins signed.