News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by cvwright on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @12:18PM (#39841174)
I find that most nonfiction books follow a common structure:

* 1st third of the book: Lays out the basic ideas, gives several examples

* 2nd third of the book: More examples that repeat the themes from the 1st part

* 3rd third of the book: ??? I usually give up at this point

I sometimes wish that more books were like "The Mom Test" - just long enough to say what they need, even if that makes for a short book.

Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by dionidium on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @04:27PM (#39844186)
I always think of this from Aaron Swartz:

> But let’s say you can narrow it down to one good one, and you can find the time to read it. You plunk down an absurd $30 (of which, I’m told, less than $3 goes to the author) for a bulky hardcover and you quickly discover that the author doesn’t have all that much to say. But a book is a big thing, and they had to fill it all up, so the author padded it. There are several common techniques.

> One is to repeat your point over and over, each time slightly differently. This is surprisingly popular. Writing a book on how code is law, an idea so simple it can fit in the book’s title? Just give example after example after example.

> Another is to just fill the book with unnecessary detail. Arguing that the Bush administration is incompetent? Fill your book up with citation after citation. (Readers must love being hit over the head with evidence for a claim they’re already willing to believe.)

> I have nothing against completeness, accuracy, or preciseness, but if you really want a broad audience to hear what you have to say, you’ve got to be short. Put the details, for the ten people who care about them, on your website. Then take the three pages you have left, and put them on your website too.

Source: http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/001229

Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by stef25 on Thursday March 28, 2024 @07:46AM (#39849986)
Sounds like the man was arguing against spending a wonderful afternoon sitting in the sun reading anecdotes about something you're interested in.
Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by voisin on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @12:25PM (#39841269)
Because most nonfiction books are one, relatively small set of ideas (profound or not, novel or not) that could be concisely written as a few blog posts or a single long form article, but in order to monetize and build the author’s brand, get exaggerated into a full book. It is really painful and something I hope GPT will help the rest of us cut through in the future (“summarize the points. Dig into that point. What evidence is given? Etc etc etc” as a conversation rather than wasting 30 hours reading noise for a book)
Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by geodel on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @01:05PM (#39841733)
Well, life of most people on the earth is just same boring repetitions with few novel events. So I wonder what would people do with their ample amount of saved time thanks to ChatGPT. Perhaps writing another Javascript framework, launch new food delivery apps besides raging on social media.
Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by olvy0 on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @01:02PM (#39841690)
That's exacerbating the original environmental problem, in addition to thick paper books, filled with filler material just to promote the author's brand, you now want to waste electricity on running an LLM that will give you a the short version? That's.... short sighted.

This should be dealt with by pressuring the publishing industry not to inflate books and fill them with fluff. This could be done by not buying these kind of books, and publicly shaming publishers who engage in this behavior. It's easier in non fiction books since the amount of fluff in fiction books is a more subjective matter.

Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by mattmaroon on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @04:32PM (#39844248)
They do it because a short book looks like a pamphelet and nobody will buy it. Most Gladwell books could easily be 30 pages, but nobody will pay $14.99 for that.

You can't shame them into buying books they can't sell.

How much electricity does it take an LLM to summarize a book? I'm sure the carbon emissions involved are trivial, and if they aren't, I've always been of the belief that (like eating meat) people are going to do what they want to do regardless of the environmental cost, so it's better to focus your ire on reducing the environmental cost. The problem here isn't using an LLM to summarize a book, it's that we've got a power grid fueled mainly by fossil fuels. (That is a problem that will fix itself in no time anyway now that renewables are cheaper and the gap is widening.)

Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by BeFlatXIII on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @05:11PM (#39844648)
> They do it because a short book looks like a pamphelet and nobody will buy it. Most Gladwell books could easily be 30 pages, but nobody will pay $14.99 for that.

This applies equally to Sci-Fi and fantasy doorstopper novels. At least those have interesting filler—sometimes even better than the main story.

Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by flawn on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @04:24PM (#39844158)
The latter will happen already by more and more people doing ways to summarize books
Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by CuriouslyC on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @01:32PM (#39842136)
Except that a lot of people read these books for the entertainment value of the anecdotes, and a lot of people enjoy feeling self-important for having read long books.
Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by smcin on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @09:18PM (#39846710)
Not just self-important, but the anecdotes are designed to be bite-sized to be easily retellable, like the 2016 NYT Abraham Wald/ beware survivorship bias on graphing bulletholes on WWII airplanes viz which locations were more damaging.

So you get a decade of "business nonfiction" bookstand fodder which is claims with high shock quality but often not relicable, mixed with anecdotes, to signal the reader's self-declared learnedness.

Combine this with the long-tailed nature of the statistic "the average American only reads one book a year" and it's frightening. I think Scott Galloway said sales of his e-book are >10x more than his paper book.

And during Covid lots of people got exposed for having fake bookshelf backdrops.

Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by mikhailfranco on Thursday March 28, 2024 @11:14AM (#39852605)
There was one Covid Zoom podcast (about economics?) with a middle-aged man sitting in front of a large set of bookshelves, housing row-upon-row of gnarly old books. The only recently-used book was lying flat on top of the other books.

Can you read the title?

https://pasteboard.co/imwZw8fcSpLy.png

Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by owisd on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @12:36PM (#39841398)
You can just leverage the “second brain” crowd — for every vaguely well-known non-fiction book someone has written up a summary for themselves and posted it on their blog.
Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by smcin on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @09:19PM (#39846721)
Sure, but be sure to check they're vaguely objective, not just shills, compensated reviewers or affiliates.
Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by ratg13 on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @12:39PM (#39841444)
Most people don’t absorb concepts immediately with only a simple explanation.

Unless you are reading a topic you are already familiar with, reinforcement of an idea helps you to examine a concept from different angles and to solidify what is being discussed.

If everyone fully absorbed and understood everything they read, schooling could be completed years in advance.

Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by 1letterunixname on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @04:22PM (#39844128)
Apart from CYOA, I think a hypertext "book" would be the most effective way to dynamically scale detail preferences without resorting to skimming or skipping.

Some people want more or less evidence based on their level of skepticism or critical thinking, while others want more evidence to reinforce the soundness of their inferred position on a topic, especially if it's a topic unfamiliar to them. Other people are under time constraints and just want the key points and a brief presentation.

Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by 1letterunixname on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @04:17PM (#39844066)
Perhaps nonfiction works could be ordered neatly such that the thesis and support material isn't buried, but arranged in a tiered detailed manner conducive to a "Choose Your Own Adventure"-like skipping of material. Short-form and long-form must find a way to coexist and be useful without critical compromise. It's not like everyone has or should need Cliff Notes or getAbstract.
Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by prionassembly on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @12:42PM (#39841470)
Counterexample: Gilles Deleuze's "Empiricism and Subjectivity".
Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by vundercind on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @01:20PM (#39841952)
Mainly a business and self-help “airport book” problem. Sometimes pop-science.
Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by paulpauper on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @12:28PM (#39841299)
I sometimes wish that more books were like "The Mom Test" - just long enough to say what they need, even if that makes for a short book.

most non fiction could be well-summarized as a lengthy blog post

Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by arrowsmith on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @01:00PM (#39841672)
I'd go further: many non-fiction books could be losslessly compressed into a tweet.

(Looking at you, The Checklist Manifesto)

Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by yboris on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @02:01PM (#39842496)
Reading a book, say 10 hours, is like a meditation on an idea: you get numerous examples of it and a variety ways of thinking about it.

Our brains learn best when they encounter something often across time (spaced repetition).

Reading a single tweet may summarize the book, but the chances of you recalling the idea in an appropriate situation is much lower than if you had spent hours on it.

Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by arrowsmith on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @03:34PM (#39843581)
I agree, and there are many books which are well worth the time it takes to read them. All I'm saying is that there are many other books which aren't.
Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by 1letterunixname on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @04:24PM (#39844157)
HAHAHA. :@D Challenge accepted.

The right checklist organizes uniformity, success, and safety in almost every human endeavor. - @SomeGuyOnTheInterwebs

Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by arrowsmith on Thursday March 28, 2024 @03:45AM (#39848660)
I'd go further:

"Use checklists." - @AtulGawande

There, now you don't need to read the book.

Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by Yodel0914 on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @07:10PM (#39845733)
There's a quote I love from someone I can't remember:

> Most books should be blog posts. Most blog posts should be tweets. Most tweets shouldn't exit.

Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by BeFlatXIII on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @05:09PM (#39844638)
> 3rd third of the book: ??? I usually give up at this point

History of science books thankfully stave off that final third until at least 80%. However, their final chapter or two universally manages to be a letdown. It's either wild optimistic speculation, hype for a theory that's debunked 5 years after publication, or a focus that accidentally happened to predict the course of science post-publication. The story is told in a tonally jarring manner compared to the tight narrative in the rest of the book.

My #1 suspect for this disease is a desire to connect the content of the book to real life. Such attempts miss more often than they drive the point home, even if they're factually correct.

Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by geokon on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @11:08PM (#39847348)
Counter example: The selfish gene

The last 20% shifts in tone and goes into speculating on a general framework for genetic selection outside of biological systems. Very speculative, interesting, and birthed the term meme

Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by BeFlatXIII on Thursday March 28, 2024 @05:01PM (#39857267)
I haven't read that one, but your description makes it sound to be the exception that proves the rule.
Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by musiciangames on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @06:02PM (#39845136)
As a sample of 1, it seems to me that this is particularly an issue with American non-fiction.
Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by lelanthran on Thursday March 28, 2024 @01:08AM (#39847979)
Well there's a reason for that - consider it a form of spaced-repetition learning.

The author's goal is to convey an idea to the reader. He breaks it up into small overlapping chunks and gradually doles out these small overlapping chunks over the course of the book, sometimes backtracking and repeating an idea with a different example, all accompanied by a compelling narrative.

If he does his job well then the reader doesn't notice that spaced-repetition learning is happening because the supporting examples are entertaining enough to continue reading. In the worst case, the author gets the exact criticism that you are leveling.

Honestly, if you had Mathematics books written like Thinking, Fast and Slow or Freakonomics you'd have a lot more students passing calculus.[1]

So, here's a challenge for you - in your area of expertise (whatever that is), write down the chapters of a hypothetical book you would write to explain one or two foundational principles to an outsider (to that area). It's pretty hard to do. Then compare with best-selling non-fiction aimed at outsiders like Freakonomics, etc.

I did this (chapter overview thing) and realised pretty quickly that I had planned a really boring book.

[1] I read Thinking, Fast and Slow around 2011, and I read The Mom Test last year. Almost all of the sub-themes of the former is still in my memory. The only thing I remember of The Mom Test is that people will lie to you to protect your feelings.

Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by ngc248 on Thursday March 28, 2024 @01:50AM (#39848145)
Yes, most nonfiction books should be pamphlets instead of books.
Re:Daniel Kahneman has died by robfitz on Thursday March 28, 2024 @04:46AM (#39848935)
It's all about that value-per-word ;)