When no one doubts about you being you, it means that everyone agrees with the fact that you are yourself, i.e. every "party" identify you as yourself, and the fact that every other party is identifying you as yourself makes individual parties even more sure that you are yourself. But on what evidences rely the third parties confidence in you being you ? How can you trust that third parties aren't corrupted or mistaken ? Take the most extreme case : you must tell if someone is lying or not about its identity AND if you're wrong, you die. I could trust third parties only if they brang some crucial facts; passwords and possession are unsignificant evidences in that context. But if the quantity of third party is enough, and if each third party knows a different passord AND if you know a different password AND the person to identify gave the correct answer for each and everyone of them, it is becoming more and more unprobable that the person is not the one they claimed to be.
But I am not satisfied with this, there must be some more elegant and trustful way of identifying people. Now that we're able to imitate the voice, fingerprints, and etc... what other trick can we find that is not a trick ?
The security model is that everyone expecting a share claims it, and if they disagree, then they duke it out in the courts with what evidence they have. And you must hope that no one can compellingly fake your death prematurely. But there's no first-principles solution for absolute security, short of an infallible death register and next-of-kin register.
But in those cases, you get back to the issue of proving identity, since if you've been in a situation where you're presumed dead, you might not have anything left but your body. Also, such situations are rare enough that they'd be dwarfed by more mundane cases of others trying to claim the identities of the dead, so there would be net pressure to make proof-of-liveness more stringent.
Properly using a password manager provides unique passwords per domain too.
Maybe it's stupid, but the scenario I always have in mind is one from "Bourne Identity" movie, with Jason Bourne found in the sea, with nothing on him, no wallet, no phone. And it's not far fetched scenario either: I travel a lot, internationally, so I always imagine being mugged, having my phone and wallet taken away from me. Being able to login to my accounts, and more importantly, access my money in the bank with nothing but a password stored in my brain is important to me.
For services with TOTP you can store the secret in that encrypted file, so you can reload it back into your authenticator app. Or you could just use a Keepass file or similar which would store all the passwords and keys in a single encrypted binary.
Though you do have to be very circumspect in choosing that app: the news of Authy's desktop app (which you could pull the tokens from) being discontinued is still fresh in my mind.
1: Something you know (Password)
2: Something you have (OTP)
3: Something you are (Bio)
4: Someone you know (3rd Party)
In 2024, the last 2 seem a bit more challenging. With AI voice and biometric data being able to be lifted from internet media, there's some more to think about when designing these systems. These are fun challenges to think about. I'm glad Steve decided to break the 1000 podcast limit, I highly recommend checking it currently along with the archive.