Re:42% of URLs have Open Graph tags
by nthitz on Tuesday May 15, 2012 @02:42PM
(#3978069)
Probably not quite 42% given:
"Embedly's crawler doesn't go out looking for URLs. We only process URLs that have been shared through our API. You can then postulate that our Open Graph average is actually higher as the sites that are shared more are optimized to be shared in Facebook."
Re:42% of URLs have Open Graph tags
by ytadesse on Tuesday May 15, 2012 @03:52PM
(#3978445)
Semantics aside, this is the reason FB will own the search/discovery space in the future. That's not just a troll comment, that's fact.
FB is amassing a huge database of well organized & socially relevant online documents that other companies are going to have a hard time even coming close to. It's like PageRank on steroids.
Re:42% of URLs have Open Graph tags
by CodeCube on Tuesday May 15, 2012 @04:45PM
(#3978727)
FB may be amassing that database today, but the OpenGraph metadata is publicly available to anyone who crawls that same page no? So what's stopping anyone else who crawls the web from using that same data (G+)?
Re:42% of URLs have Open Graph tags
by guard-of-terra on Tuesday May 15, 2012 @03:18PM
(#3978282)
OpanGraph has numerous problems which hinder it appearing by default in HTML:
- It is verbose and bloats the page. You have a dozen of tags in the best case, but if you have an album of something you might need to provide a set of og tags for every object, which is a lot.
- You often need a different set of og tags on the same page in order to make facebook treat that page differently (you can be doing different things on the same page). So you end up serving a special version of page with og tags to facebook by user-agent.
For simplier cases, you don't even need og, and for more complicated ones, they are facebook-specific and you'll have trouble using those for anything else.
The overall experience from og and facebook: Bad. Don't like.
Re:42% of URLs have Open Graph tags
by acdha on Tuesday May 15, 2012 @03:26PM
(#3978328)
Also: OpenGraph hates the web and cannot be embedded in any valid HTML document and XHTML validation requires using a custom DTD. I'd really like it if they'd just adopt the standard HTML5 microdata approach and avoid the need to end up bloating out <head> with a bunch of <meta> tags duplicating content found elsewhere on the page.
Re:42% of URLs have Open Graph tags
by officialchicken on Tuesday May 15, 2012 @04:08PM
(#3978511)
The ultimate question still hasn't been answered - viewing the page source reveals NO tags with og attributes, which one would expect in the search for life, the universe, and all facebook profiles.
"Embedly's crawler doesn't go out looking for URLs. We only process URLs that have been shared through our API. You can then postulate that our Open Graph average is actually higher as the sites that are shared more are optimized to be shared in Facebook."
FB is amassing a huge database of well organized & socially relevant online documents that other companies are going to have a hard time even coming close to. It's like PageRank on steroids.
- It is verbose and bloats the page. You have a dozen of tags in the best case, but if you have an album of something you might need to provide a set of og tags for every object, which is a lot.
- You often need a different set of og tags on the same page in order to make facebook treat that page differently (you can be doing different things on the same page). So you end up serving a special version of page with og tags to facebook by user-agent.
For simplier cases, you don't even need og, and for more complicated ones, they are facebook-specific and you'll have trouble using those for anything else.
The overall experience from og and facebook: Bad. Don't like.
The problem is that we do not know what the ultimate question is.