News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Timeless Parable of Mr. Market by jddj on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @08:42AM (#39755120)
Let's rewrite that to work in some real world requirements.

That's 90B of value which could have gone to employees had the capital needs of those growing businesses been met by debt (often requiring coincident equity injections or personal guarantees), by bootstrapping, or by those same employees.

Perhaps now there's space for a conversation. What might a world need to look like for it to be made up of those businesses in place of one where ownership can be traded for capital at risk?

Re:The Timeless Parable of Mr. Market by AndrewKemendo on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @08:56AM (#39755219)
Good idea

My answer is anarchistic syndicalism:

https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/george-woodcock-what...

In short, labor has to organize our own capital to create syndicates that peacefully outcompete existing unethical structures

Its going to take hundreds of years of organizing and reduction in the pervasive sense of social terror and fear which leads people to hoarding behavior

12000 years of this structure won’t end by force or overnight

It can only be done through steady peaceful direct action to transfer wealth from existing hoarders to individuals

We then disincentive personal consumption and vanity the same way we got here, through Bernays style propaganda (marketing) and building infrastructure that incentivizes community development over personal consumption

Re:The Timeless Parable of Mr. Market by randomdata on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @09:32AM (#39755557)
> labor has to organize our own capital

But then labour becomes the business owner – exactly what they don't want to be. Labour chooses to become employees because they don't want the headaches of owning and operating a business. They just want a steady paycheque and let someone else take the risk.

Re:The Timeless Parable of Mr. Market by AndrewKemendo on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @11:12AM (#39756559)
What risk is being taken? Financial risk? Opportunity risk?

Employees take the most risk because they gave the fewest options in the market

The risk a PE or bank takes giving a loan isn’t the same risk a loan holder takes by collateralizing their home.

Re:The Timeless Parable of Mr. Market by randomdata on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @11:55AM (#39757092)
While certain estimations can be made, it is impossible to truly know if work is worth doing until after the work is already done. As such, workers have to make a choice:

1. Do the work and find out. If the work was worthwhile, they'll reap the benefits in spades. If not, they suffer the detriments.

2. Sell the work at a discount to someone else who is willing to find out.

Most workers opt for #2 because they don't care to find out. They want the guarantee and are happy to let someone else suffer the consequences when things go wrong, even if that means letting someone else indulge in the rewards when it does work out.

Re:The Timeless Parable of Mr. Market by ProjectArcturis on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @09:28AM (#39755530)
You should choose a different name, because anacho-syndicalism will forever be linked most closely with a Monty Python scene.

Arthur: Then who is your lord? Woman: We don't have a lord! Arthur: (spurised) What?? Man: I told you! We're an anarcho-syndicalist commune! We're taking turns to act as a sort of executive-officer-for-the-week-- Arthur: (uninterested) Yes... Man: But all the decisions of that officer 'ave to be ratified at a special bi-weekly meeting-- Arthur: (perturbed) Yes I see! Man: By a simple majority, in the case of purely internal affairs-- Arthur: (mad) Be quiet! Man: But by a two-thirds majority, in the case of more major-- Arthur: (very angry) BE QUIET! I order you to be quiet! Woman: "Order", eh, 'oo does 'e think 'e is?

Re:The Timeless Parable of Mr. Market by AndrewKemendo on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @09:44AM (#39755665)
I mean…it’s one of the better sendups of capitalism that persists today

Hard to argue with the logic

Re:The Timeless Parable of Mr. Market by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @08:59AM (#39755256)
Specifically, one of the businesses Berkshire Hathaway invested heavily in is the BNSF Railroad. Railroads take a lot of capital - tens of thousands of miles of track, thousands of locomotives (at $2 million each), railroad cars, and so on. Were the employees going to buy all that? No, they were not - they didn't have the money.

So you need some people with money - some capitalists. Do you expect them to work for free? If so, good luck - you can expect all you want, but they aren't investing in your business.

We can have a conversation about how much of the rewards should flow to investors and how much should flow to the workers. But "anything that doesn't go to the workers is theft" shows a complete lack of understanding.

If labor can get the money and buys the tools, then sure, they get the rewards that flow to labor and the rewards that flow to capital. That's perfectly fair. But at that point, they're not just "labor" any longer - they're at least petit bourgeoisie.

Re:The Timeless Parable of Mr. Market by AndrewKemendo on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @09:04AM (#39755302)
Oh, I fully understand it.

You just seem to think that there is no other way for some reason

How can you just wave away the narcissistic psychopathy of capital return requirements?

On what philosophical principle are you basing your position on?

I’m not really sure how you can stand on any kind of principal here when all you’re doing is capitulating to the existing power structures

“It’s just the way it is” isn’t a branch of ethics

Re:The Timeless Parable of Mr. Market by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @09:23AM (#39755482)
"I demand that it be this other way" isn't a branch of ethics either. And labeling some aspect of the existing way as "theft" doesn't make your argument any stronger. Neither does labeling it "narcistic psychopathy".

If we're going to live a better life than in the stone age, we need tools that are better than stones. The more sophisticated tools are beyond the ability of one person to both make and use them - they take too much time to make. So we wind up with a specialized economy where different people make the tools and use the tools. And they both deserve to be rewarded - the tools enable much more to be produced; those who made that possible deserve to share in the rewards.

But we're a money economy rather than a barter economy, because barter doesn't scale all that well. Well, in a money economy, if someone is going to use a tool they didn't build, then someone has to buy the tool - either the tool user or an investor. If the tool user doesn't have the money, then it has to be an investor.

Do you demand that the investor do so for free? That doesn't sound fair. (It also doesn't sound like it will actually happen - why should the investor invest if there is no expectation of a return?)

So now we have three people who need to share in the rewards - in tool maker, the tool user, and the tool buyer. And it is perfectly fair that all three share in the rewards. It is unfair to expect the investor to invest for free.

Like I said, we can have a conversation about the amounts that different ones receive. But that's a completely different conversation from "everything that goes to the investor is theft".

Re:The Timeless Parable of Mr. Market by AndrewKemendo on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @09:31AM (#39755551)
Your response doesn’t make any new claims or derive any new principles, you’re simply regurgitating capitalist propaganda.

In fact this trope about the “stone age” tells me you have a eurocentric idea of the history of humanity - eg:

“people are fundamentally selfish, things were bad, then society developed and now things are better”

Which is just a totally fabricated history

All your questions will be answered by reading, chapter 4 of Prudhon “What is property?”

Except in extremely rare cases, hoards of wealth come from inequitable deals - that is, someone chooses a bad deal for themselves under duress

If you want things to be better than the stone ages then stop acting like “might makes right” is an ethical position, its “stone age” philosophy that needs to end

https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/pierre-joseph-proudh...

Re:The Timeless Parable of Mr. Market by syklep on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @10:50AM (#39756278)
> “people are fundamentally selfish,

People ARE fundamentally selfish in any groups above 150-200 where the social net breaks down. Most groups of animals don't stay group-serving in giant groups, we are no different.[1] In groups small enough to be inside the social net, tribe survival dynamics work great.

> things were bad, then society developed and now things are better”

Things are not great. Technology makes them better though. Man can't easily escape technology today, but it is the fundamental trade-off society offers at the cost of social health.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sociality#Eusociality

Re:The Timeless Parable of Mr. Market by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @09:41AM (#39755639)
> All your questions will be answered by reading, chapter 4 of Prudhon “What is property?”

Here's one question that it won't answer: Why should I believe Proudhon? Sure, he may sound correct. Lots of other people sound correct, too. What is your basis for saying that I should listen to Proudhon rather than all these other people?

> If you want things to be better than the stone ages then stop acting like “might makes right” is an ethical position, its “stone age” philosophy that needs to end

I did not advocate that as an ethical position - you're imputing that to me. I deny you the right to tell me what my ethical position is. And you should stop trying, not just because you don't have the right, but also because you're lousy at it.

I'm done with the conversation, since you seem quite clearly to be uninterested in listening. I will leave you the last word if you want it.

Re:The Timeless Parable of Mr. Market by AndrewKemendo on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @09:58AM (#39755792)
>What is your basis for saying that I should listen to Proudhon rather than all these other people?

My suggestion is to read them all and come to your own conclusions

Re:The Timeless Parable of Mr. Market by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @10:24AM (#39756039)
I said I was done with the conversation, but: Good answer. Credit where due.
Re:The Timeless Parable of Mr. Market by imtringued on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @04:14PM (#39759788)
>It is unfair to expect the investor to invest for free.

Ok, but in the case of negative market returns, the expectation is that you get no returns. If the investor randomly demands not having to get market returns then who is going to make up the difference if not the investor? The tax payer? That is the answer the average citizen has chosen and they like it.

Re:The Timeless Parable of Mr. Market by tomcam on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @02:42AM (#39763447)
Can you give an overview of labor would obtain the resources to buy and operate a railroad?
Re:The Timeless Parable of Mr. Market by AndrewKemendo on Thursday March 21, 2024 @08:51AM (#39777902)
Some way anyone raises money: Go ask people with money

The difference is that the people you ask will be the people who are doing the work and as a result they become the owners

I haven't started a railroad so I can't tell you how to fund that

I have started a residential trash cooperative which is 100% bootstrapped by the employees and needed ~100k to start

I have also started multiple software startups and those are cheap as hell to start and run if you're not trying to waste money on marketing

Re:The Timeless Parable of Mr. Market by hackeraccount on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @02:28PM (#39758784)
I'd love to know where people get the confidence to speculate how much money a company should spend on labor or capital investments or how any of that money should be raised.

I mean good for you but personally I'm barely sure how I should do the above for my own finances much less on the kind of scale you're talking about.

Re:The Timeless Parable of Mr. Market by jddj on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @03:14PM (#39759217)
I'd guess that in this forum a number of people will have had some experience both raising equity and being in positions of significant ownership and control, but still you're right.

Like most opinions, they're an often unknowable mixture of genuine aptitude and naive bravado and it's good to try to stay humble.

Re:The Timeless Parable of Mr. Market by AndrewKemendo on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @05:15PM (#39760282)
The same way they can say “we think you should stop abusing your workers”