News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decad... by zachmu on Monday March 18, 2024 @09:51PM (#39752221)
Mesothelioma from household exposure is very rare, nearly all cases come from industrial exposure, involving chronic exposure to concentrations of airborne particles millions of times higher than you would ever find in a residential setting, even during a renovation that disturbs asbestos.

I looked into this when I discovered some old asbestos paper in my basement that I had abated by professionals (which I always recommend). I was freaking out about my family being exposed to the fibers for years before that, so I went digging for hard numbers. To my surprise, there is almost zero good quantitative data on the risk of mesothelioma from residential asbestos exposure. The best info we have suggests about a doubling of the risk of MM from residential exposure, from about 1 per million person-years to 2.5 per million person years:

https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanpub/article/PIIS2468-2...

> However, the chief interest from this study will be in the more than doubling of risk of mesothelioma in men who had lived in an affected house, compared with unexposed males (SIR 2·54, 95% CI 1·02–5·24). ... The background incidence of mesothelioma without exposure to asbestos is very low (highly age-dependent and roughly one case per million person-years), so any rise would be indicative of previous asbestos exposure

Other studies indicate that home renovations that disturb asbestos could increase the risk by about a factor of 5 from baseline, which sounds high until you realize that it means about 5 per million person-years. The base rate is very low! And there is no such thing as zero exposure to asbestos: there are a couple fibers, on average, in every liter of air you breathe. Everybody is constantly exposed to a very small amount of these fibers, and it's not the case that it gives everybody MM:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7721955/#:~:tex....

So the bottom line is: get your asbestos abated by professionals, but don't freak out if you have been living with the stuff. It's not the same as being an asbestos miner, your risk is higher but still very low.

Re:EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decad... by hanniabu on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @12:00AM (#39752827)
> Mesothelioma from household exposure is very rare

> To my surprise, there is almost zero good quantitative data on the risk of mesothelioma from residential asbestos exposure

Love it when comments state something so confidently, yet contradict themselves a few sentences later

Re:EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decad... by zachmu on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @12:35AM (#39752976)
There is no contradiction there
Re:EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decad... by leke on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @12:39AM (#39752995)
There isn't?
Re:EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decad... by zachmu on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @12:44AM (#39753014)
Rare but difficult to precisely quantify.

We know the rate of mesothelioma in people with no known occupational exposure, but we have very little quantitative data about how much a given amount of asbestos exposure might increase one's risk. The disease takes decades to develop after exposure.

Re:EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decad... by roenxi on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @01:01AM (#39753090)
Deducing that something is rare from limited evidence is really easy. If there is no good evidence regarding something, that default position should be that the thing is rare.
Re:EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decad... by 2devnull on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @10:29AM (#39756084)
There’s a handy cliche: absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. In concrete terms a zero is different from a missing value.
Re:EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decad... by roenxi on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @08:10PM (#39761654)
The cliche is wrong. The absence of evidence is evidence of absence. Not conclusive evidence.

There are an infinite number of things that don't exist and that we don't have any evidence of. It is nice if we can positively disprove them, but that is not necessary to justify disbelief.

Re:EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decad... by YeBanKo on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @04:34AM (#39753874)
I think the point that are trying to make is that if it was more common, it would be noticeable and more quantifiable. Otherwise, most of the cases seems to have been tracked to industrial exposure.
Re:EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decad... by pcchristie on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @12:23AM (#39752926)
This is really interesting, thanks.
Re:EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decad... by ro-ka on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @03:06AM (#39753541)
My parents house (in the EU) was covered in plates of asbestos. As far as I know it only is dangerous when you install / remove it as these plates break and release chemicals to the air. I’m no expert though.
Re:EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decad... by sdwr on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @11:30AM (#39756796)
I believe the interaction with asbestos is material, not chemical. It breaks into tiny shards that are light enough to breathe, and sharp enough to cut up your lungs.

Which is why a single exposure will damage your lungs, but it takes lots of cycles of damage and repair to chance into getting cancer.

Re:EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decad... by HdS84 on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @03:30AM (#39753641)
While true, domestic use is super problematic and balloons any bill. E.g. our house in germany is from 1968. We where lucky and the builder did not use any asbestos so I could do most renovations myself. If you have asbestos, you need specialized equipment and procedures or involve experts. That is really expensive and can easily double or triple your estimated cost. You can ofc ignore it, but especially with small children it seems ill advised to do so. NTM there are fines if you expose the public.
Re:EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decad... by speleding on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @04:44AM (#39753903)
If you involve a specialised removal firm it's super expensive and stalls your project by weeks. I was advised by the builder I could just remove a few plates of asbestos myself, about half a day of work, most of which was spent getting the right plastic bags and then driving them to the correct dump, the actual removal of the asbestos plates took minutes. Used mask etc, but really a single exposure was a very acceptable risk for me to save on cost and time. (There's different types of asbestos, some more dangerous than others, so you should do a bit of research into what you're doing)
Re:EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decad... by wizerdrobe on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @05:33AM (#39754103)
Meanwhile in America I am allowed to self-remove asbestos as a homeowner no verifications required. Whereas a commercial builder is required to have certifications.

Another “fun fact,” when the asbestos ban went into place builders were still allowed to use any remaining stock they held in their warehouses. No new product could be purchased. So homes could still be built years later with a now banned substance.

Fascinating bit of law there.

Re:EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decad... by Sander_Marechal on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @10:11AM (#39755897)
In The Netherlands you can remove asbestos yourself and bring it to the local trash collection and recycling center for free. You do have to get a permit (free, but takes a few days) and follow some simple guidelines for handling and packaging. But, this applies only to private homeowners.

In my case, my house had a facade made of aluminium frames with prefab slabs slotted in. The slabs had a layer of asbestos on the inside. I just slotted the slabs out, packaged them in two layers of plastic and took them to the recycling center.

Re:EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decad... by gwbas1c on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @07:20AM (#39754639)
> nearly all cases come from industrial exposure

That is how my grandfather got mesothelioma. He insulated ships in WWII and didn't have proper protection. He had a rather painful last year of his life.

At this point, I would only allow asbestos when there are no safer alternatives. I didn't know if any cases where asbestos is the only practical option.

Re:EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decad... by riverdroid on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @10:04AM (#39755837)
While most mesothelioma (a rare cancer) is known to be caused by asbestos and not other agents, asbestos is known to cause other cancers of the lung, larynx, and ovary, with limited evidence of some other cancers as well.

https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/causes-prevention/risk/s...

These are more common cancers, and not usually possible to map to a precise cause when they occur.