News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mercedes is trialing humanoid robots for 'low skill, repe... by robotburrito on Friday March 15, 2024 @06:01PM (#39721167)
I wonder what happens if your consumer base has all had their incomes replaced by AI? Who buys your product your now making with it? Does AI just lead to the end of capitalism as we know it?
Re:Mercedes is trialing humanoid robots for 'low skill, repe... by reaperman on Friday March 15, 2024 @06:15PM (#39721259)
From a pure game-theory perspective, consumers are important for their potential labor. As long as there is something productive that they can specialize in that might give your group an advantage over other groups --- it is useful to produce and distribute all the things which keep them productive. Maybe 100% of your population will be trained as scientists and mathematicians just on the off-chance they can discover something that AI cannot and give you an edge over other similarly-advanced groups.

If the AI's can truly replace humans to the point where there is nothing useful for your humans to be doing, then it would cease to matter whether or not the rulers produce and distribute the things the consumers need/want. You'd need good enough AI security to handle any unrest which ensues, and protect any natural resources that might be important to you.

If you no longer can utilize any of the labor of your consumers, then the only products you need to make are: 1) The things you personally want, and 2) The things needed to maintain sovereignty against any other similarly advanced groups. Category #1 would be a very small volume, but Category #2 might be industrially more than the entire world's current production of everything, just for your fiefdom. It would be unstable until someone conquered the entire globe, and would likely only need to provide for about 500-5000 people in their "court" to provide for the rulers own selfish social needs.

Re:Mercedes is trialing humanoid robots for 'low skill, repe... by barelyauser on Friday March 15, 2024 @06:11PM (#39721235)
The mistake you make (and a lot of people also do) is to assume the purpose of the system is to somehow cater to your (the consumer) needs. The purpose of the system is to fulfill the needs of the elite (those who benefit from the system). Average people having a car is a thing because then people will be more productive. But make no mistake, if the rich don't get what they want FIRST then your whole economy goes into recession and what not.
Re:Mercedes is trialing humanoid robots for 'low skill, repe... by jamesgreenleaf on Friday March 15, 2024 @07:15PM (#39721672)
If the elite are defined as those who benefit from the system, then we are all the elite.
Re:Mercedes is trialing humanoid robots for 'low skill, repe... by JumpCrisscross on Friday March 15, 2024 @06:29PM (#39721351)
You’re conflating the rich and elite, which the nuance on which entire systems of government are built.
Re:Mercedes is trialing humanoid robots for 'low skill, repe... by barelyauser on Friday March 15, 2024 @06:47PM (#39721480)
Can one achieve elite status without wealth?
Re:Mercedes is trialing humanoid robots for 'low skill, repe... by JumpCrisscross on Friday March 15, 2024 @06:59PM (#39721559)
> Can one achieve elite status without wealth?

Absolutely. AOC became an elite before she became wealthy. Same for J. K. Rowling and most academics at the top of their fields.

Re:Mercedes is trialing humanoid robots for 'low skill, repe... by reaperman on Friday March 15, 2024 @11:38PM (#39723170)
Essentially no academics are part of the upper (ruling) class, except the ones that were born into it (e.g. Jeffrey Laurie or Élisabeth Badinter), or those who moved into academia after retiring from their primary career (e.g. Hillary Clinton becoming a professor of practice at Columbia)[0]

0: https://president.columbia.edu/news/hillary-rodham-clinton-j....

Re:Mercedes is trialing humanoid robots for 'low skill, repe... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday March 16, 2024 @10:07AM (#39726047)
> no academics are part of the upper (ruling) class

Every one that achieves cultural relevance or an administrative post absolutely is. Some of those are born into it. Most are not.

Re:Mercedes is trialing humanoid robots for 'low skill, repe... by reaperman on Saturday March 16, 2024 @01:56PM (#39727980)
Can you give examples? I believe most of those would fall between "still needs to perform labor for a living" and "could live purely off of accrued capital, no longer needing to perform labor". But I don't know too many university presidents / deans / provosts who personally control enough wealth to have the power to change the direction of their society - they control truly large amounts of power only through their official appointments, and they themselves serve at the whims of those that rule them.
Re:Mercedes is trialing humanoid robots for 'low skill, repe... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday March 16, 2024 @02:33PM (#39728284)
> most of those would fall between "still needs to perform labor for a living" and "could live purely off of accrued capital, no longer needing to perform labor"

You’re still confusing wealth with power. Plenty of people who never need work again are not elites, e.g. Steve Wozniak. And plenty of elites don’t have enough saved to survive extended periods of not working, e.g. many in television or politics.

> don't know too many university presidents / deans / provosts who personally control enough wealth to have the power to change the direction of their society

Larry Summers.

They don’t wield wealth as power. They wield influence. Same as how a U.S. Senator need not be wealthy to be powerful; if anything, they wield their power to produce wealth.

Re:Mercedes is trialing humanoid robots for 'low skill, repe... by tyingq on Friday March 15, 2024 @06:03PM (#39721182)
I think people tend to underestimate how awful the shaky interim period might be. Before everyone signs on to some sane way to address this sort of thing.
Re:Mercedes is trialing humanoid robots for 'low skill, repe... by JumpCrisscross on Friday March 15, 2024 @06:04PM (#39721183)
> Does AI just lead to the end of capitalism as we know it?

This reminds me of Marinetti predicting electricity will usher in a post-scarcity world [1]. (Like, students will be hooked up to outlets to learn faster, electricity in the ground will make crops grow faster, flying cities will make land scarcity a thing of the past, et cetera.)

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Filippo_Tommaso_Marinetti

Re:Mercedes is trialing humanoid robots for 'low skill, repe... by hnbad on Friday March 15, 2024 @06:48PM (#39721485)
In retrospect, most of these "technological post-scarcity utopianism" predictions fell flat because they did not account for enclosure.

For example, automation may increase worker productivity but that doesn't benefit the worker but the owner: the worker may actually be worse off because the owner will now likely fire workers due to the reduced labor need and the resulting reduction of available jobs suppresses wages. On the other hand, some jobs where workers would outperform automation will be underpriced to the point that it's not worth paying someone a livable wage for the quality advantage over an automated process at a fraction of the cost so those jobs go away too.

Or for food production we may be producing an abundance but as the total need is limited, instead of reducing prices because of the increased supply, we end up instead importing out of season produce from the other side of the world, min-maxing convenience food for appeal/addictiveness and destroying unsold goods to avoid lowering the market price.

Or for drugs we literally value the sanctity of patents over the lives of people in underdeveloped countries who couldn't afford the medicine in their lifetimes (cf. the refusal to suspend/discount COVID vaccine patents for poorer countries to allow them to produce generics to vaccinate their populations).

Re:Mercedes is trialing humanoid robots for 'low skill, repe... by ximeng on Friday March 15, 2024 @06:58PM (#39721552)
This has the added benefit for the wealthy that people can’t afford children and don’t live as long so there is less competition for resources.