There is certainly a genetic component to intelligence, but environmental factors have a big role to play as well.
Depends on the standardized test. Some are designed to test knowledge, others are designed to test more fundamental attributes.
ACT is more knowledge, SAT is more fundamental attributes. SAT is still a significant amount of knowledge, but not as focused on it as ACT.
And this is what statistics tells us, rich people are very rarely stupid, quite a lot of poor people are. The world isn't fair, but stupidity is such a massive drawback that it is basically impossible to get rich if you have it. Stupid people get tricked in deals everywhere etc, there is just no way for them to reach anywhere without extreme amounts of support.
Look at any family of 3+ siblings. Intelligence tends to vary significantly despite having the same parents.
The "dumbest" one is potentially the wealthiest. The smartest one (hands down) is the least wealthy.
This is besides the point though. Anecdata doesn't get at what happens on average, and that's what his post is about.
From what I've read, the inheritability of intelligence has a 0.50 correlation. That's not fantastic.
What I am speaking to is the types of marbles and their prevalence in a given bag. Not what is actually chosen in any given drawing.
A better phrasing would be "Kids who draw from bags with higher than average amounts of green marbles, are more likely to end up with green marbles in their bag"
Bien-pensants will tell us to the bitter end "Who are you going to believe, me or your lying eyes?" But they are aware of the truth.
Example: From a 2018 open letter by an eminent geneticist, "How Genetics Is Changing Our Understanding of 'Race'" <https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/23/opinion/sunday/genetics-r...>:
>I am worried that well-meaning people who deny the possibility of substantial biological differences among human populations are digging themselves into an indefensible position, one that will not survive the onslaught of science. I am also worried that whatever discoveries are made — and we truly have no idea yet what they will be — will be cited as “scientific proof” that racist prejudices and agendas have been correct all along, and that those well-meaning people will not understand the science well enough to push back against these claims.
Humans and mice have 85% commonality in their DNA.
More to the point, humans have between 99.6 and 99.9 commonality in their genetics. Even more interesting (quoted directly from below) " impossible to draw discrete genetic boundaries around human groups."
Your point is not accurate.
From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_and_genetics
> Humans are remarkably genetically similar, sharing approximately 99.6%-99.9% of their genetic code with one another. We nonetheless see wide individual variation in phenotype, which arises from both genetic differences and complex gene-environment interactions. The vast majority of this genetic variation occurs within groups; very little genetic variation differentiates between groups. Crucially, the between-group genetic differences that do exist do not map onto socially recognized categories of race. Furthermore, although human populations show some genetic clustering across geographic space, human genetic variation is "clinal", or continuous. This, in addition to the fact that different traits vary on different clines, makes it impossible to draw discrete genetic boundaries around human groups. Finally, insights from ancient DNA are revealing that no human population is "pure" – all populations represent a long history of migration and mixing.
However, having wealth provides tutors, better schooling and teachers which lead to better outcomes from having better mentors, opportunities and education which leads to...
and so on and so on.
If you go over the research, you realize that they all assume the premise "everyone is born with an identical blank slate". Which leads to conclusions (either said outright or implied) like; "If you give enough resources to any given child, they can grow up to be anything."
So we end up with schools that serve low income areas getting enormous amounts of funding to teach admin assistants and tile layers to be heart surgeons. And the data on that end shows unequivocally that it is not working.
Of course throwing money at (sometimes corrupt) school boards isn’t going to be effective. There isn’t much 1/20th of a school teacher can do 8am-2pm M-F to counter a bad environment. It takes a village after all.
Not exactly data that’s useful to your hypothesis.
From my experience this is a large exaggeration to not true at all. For example the Colorado adoption project has been around has been around for a longer time and was well regarded last I checked.
Are there piles of hard science papers out there that are concluding "everyone is born with an identical blank slate" that I am missing?
[1] edit to clarify, I mean “not worth pursuing” past the point of equilibrium. We can improve equality of outcome to a point but then will hit a plateau. Pretending that plateau doesn’t exist is one of humanities biggest problems. It’s a costly lie that doesn’t serve anyone but certain professional groups.
Define justifiable. I would agree with “unfair.” Life is not fair. Is life “justifiable” to you? In nature, there are predators and prey, is that “justifiable”?
I like to simplify my thinking too, but your view seems inherently suppose almost superhuman discernment, that you (or other humans individually or collectively) can judge what is justified on a case by case basis without any concrete principals or criteria, and without bias! Doesn’t seem simple to me at all! How to distinguish the bill gateses from the other guys is a problem as old as civilization. There is more law and tax code written on this than you can ever hope to capture in your thinking. Ignoring policy and centuries of human knowledge isn’t “simple” as much as it is ignorance.
People who continue working to expand their impact even when they don't need to are rare.
The phrase, "I believe in equality of opportunity, not equality of outcome" explicitly acknowledges that equality of opportunity will not yield equality of outcome. In part, because of the unequal distribution of talent that you point out.
2.) Intelligent people get higher paying jobs.
3.) Intelligent people live in wealthier areas.
4.) Intelligent people marry other intelligent people.
5.) Intelligent people birth intelligent children.
6.) Intelligent people use their intelligence to augment their kid's intelligence.
7.) Intelligent kids go to step 1.)
The emperor is walking around naked, and virtually all of academia is terrified to acknowledge it (namely step 5). Right there is the solution to 50 years of sociological fumbling to avoid saying "Intelligence has a strong genetic component, and we are not all born with equal mental capabilities"
Once academia can acknowledge this, then they can finally work on real solutions to close the disproportionate economic gaps it creates.
(Yes, I am aware of your anecdote that counters this. It's a broad generalization to counter the mainstream broad generalization.)