Maybe the person who found it doesn't care that they didn't get a reward and is just happy to have an amazing story and to have helped all of humanity learn a little more about the collective past that somehow all of man managed to forget about after it happened.
There are much more important things in this world besides fortune, and not everything is a conspiracy by the shadow government to oppress you.
If you find something that might be treasure, you must report it to a coroner, who will first determine whether it really is treasure. Typically treasure is something valuable or historically significant.
If it is treasure, an independent body will then value the treasure, and also make decisions about who the treasure belongs to - typically it will be split between the finder and the landowner. At this point, the treasure will be offered to a museum for the price set by this independent body. If the museum doesn't want it or cannot afford it, then the finder/landowner get to keep the treasure, otherwise the museum buys the object and pays the finder and landowner.
So ultimately, assuming you find something, you'll always get to either keep the item, or have someone buy it off you.
That said, there are stipulations around not being able to just go around and dig up anyone's ground, and you always need to get permission from the landowner before going treasure hunting. In this case, magnet fishing is apparently not allowed on rivers, hence why they figured out an arrangement to donate the sword rather than be paid for it.
EDIT: And if you want to watch a light-hearted comedy series about metal detecting, you can't go wrong with Detectorists!
The US inherited the term before it gained that treasure-inquest aspect. The connection to the "crown" has been completely lost, but we kept the word.
https://www.thorntons-law.co.uk/knowledge/finders-keepers-tr...
What made me wonder was the use of the term "coroner" - I'm pretty sure we don't have those - seems to be covered by Procurators Fiscal.
Here my issue is the plain threat to make the finder give away the sword.
i am simply refererring to facts stated in the article:
> There was a little dispute with the landowner and the rivers trust who don't permit magnet fishing. The latter sent a legal document saying they wouldn't take action on the condition that the sword was passed to a museum, which I had done.
I've read stories where they evacuate whole blocks when someone digs up a 500lb bomb in their basement until they can properly evaluate how safe it is.
But still gotta get stuff done in any case, otherwise nobody'd be digging anywhere, forever.
Bro, this is in the UK. Fair play is a long way down the government list of priorities these days.
You're arguing against a strawman of your own making. I addressed your point about incentives, and nothing else: The incentives here are exactly as the relevant authorities want them to be.
You're free to disagree that is not how they should be, but that is an entirely separate discussion.
Keep them uneducated and unskilled and tax them out of options into poverty and dependence. Don't let them leave - the people are the governments assets.