Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S...
by nradov on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @04:07PM
(#39696745)
Denser housing sounds good in theory; I support it myself and vote accordingly. The problem is that it comes with other people. The more immediate neighbors you have, the greater the risk that one of them will be an antisocial asshole who makes life hell for everyone else. You're going to occasionally get drug dealers (or other habitual criminals), aggressive dog owners, serious mental illness cases, couples that have screaming arguments every night, motorcyclists who rev their engines at 5:00 AM, etc. And the police/code enforcement/apartment manager usually won't do anything to fix the problem. It only takes one bad neighbor experience to send a family fleeing to a single-family house in the exurbs regardless of costs or environmental impacts. So far I haven't seen the YIMBYs propose serious solutions to the antisocial behavior problem, or even acknowledge that it's an obstacle to their goals.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S...
by foxyv on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @05:45PM
(#39697938)
American apartments are horrible. However, that isn't a problem with dense housing itself so much as how our cities are built.
Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S...
by nradov on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @06:47PM
(#39698514)
I don't understand your comment. Changing how cities are built won't prevent antisocial people from moving in next door. That's more of a social policy and law enforcement issue than an urban planning issue.
Re:Mass Timber Is Great, but It Will Not Solve the Housing S...
by fragmede on Sunday March 17, 2024 @10:31PM
(#39740040)
> You're going to occasionally get drug dealers (or other habitual criminals), aggressive dog owners, serious mental illness cases, couples that have screaming arguments every night, motorcyclists who rev their engines at 5:00 AM, etc.
I'm not downplaying how much those suck. but half of those problems go away if you don't have to hear them. The couple that argues at all hours of the day? How do you know they're arguing if you can't hear them? If there's a dog that barks all day long but you can't hear it, how is that a problem? Not all of the problems go away, yes, but some of them go away if apartments are built better.