News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google restricts Gemini chatbot election answers by ImHereToVote on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @04:55AM (#39689322)
Curious. Google has a long history of controlling elections via ephemeral content. Why are they so shy now?

EDIT: Criticisms are more useful than downvotes, stop being butthurt Sundar.

Re:Google restricts Gemini chatbot election answers by internet_toucan on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @05:39AM (#39689581)
What do you mean by this, do you mean actively and purposefully controlling elections? Do you have any sources on this?
Re:Google restricts Gemini chatbot election answers by ImHereToVote on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @05:40AM (#39689588)
Sure. Here is a deposition that goes fairly in-depth:

https://www.judiciary.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Epstein%20Tes...

Re:Google restricts Gemini chatbot election answers by foldr on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @06:09AM (#39689728)
Some of this is plainly ridiculous, e.g. the last sentence of the following:

>On Election Day in 2018, the “Go Vote” reminder Google displayed on its home page gave one political party between 800,000 and 4.6 million more votes than it gave the other party. Those numbers might seem impossible, but I published my analysis in January 2019 (https://is.gd/WCdslm) (Epstein, 2019a), and it is quite conservative. Google’s data analysts presumably performed the same calculations I did before the company decided to post its prompt. In other words, Google’s “Go Vote” prompt was not a public service; it was a vote manipulation.

Re:Google restricts Gemini chatbot election answers by itsoktocry on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @07:42AM (#39690286)
>Some of this is plainly ridiculous

Or, is it "plainly ridiculous" to think that Google started on their version of political correctness when they built Gemini, but not before?

The Twitter Files revealed how much the FBI and CIA have their hands in social media. The biggest data source on the planet was untouched?

Re:Google restricts Gemini chatbot election answers by ImHereToVote on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @06:15AM (#39689764)
Seems like just some gentle nudging sure. But do that at scale and it's certainly more effective than campaigning for a politician. If they did that in the open, then sure. But they don't.
Re:Google restricts Gemini chatbot election answers by foldr on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @06:18AM (#39689789)
There's no way for any person or organisation to address the entire voting population at once. So according to this guy, any time anyone encourages people to vote via any medium, they're engaging in election manipulation. This is exactly the sort of duff reasoning that finds non-existent conspiracies in every corner.
Re:Google restricts Gemini chatbot election answers by itsoktocry on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @07:45AM (#39690312)
>This is exactly the sort of duff reasoning that finds non-existent conspiracies in every corner.

Have you been living under a rock? The tech companies taking sides in politics is not a conspiracy theory.

Re:Google restricts Gemini chatbot election answers by foldr on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @09:58AM (#39691276)
Reminding people that there’s an election is not taking sides. It’s certainly not an instance of “vote manipulation”. I’m not commenting on the broader issue, just this specific claim, which is bonkers.
Re:Google restricts Gemini chatbot election answers by ImHereToVote on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @06:36AM (#39689905)
I think you see this as ok since your political presuppositions are being rewarded.
Re:Google restricts Gemini chatbot election answers by hoffs on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @07:02AM (#39690048)
Wow, the best comeback to that is attack of the poster not the argument.
Re:Google restricts Gemini chatbot election answers by johnnyanmac on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @05:34AM (#39689550)
Litigation, perhaps? Google is already being hit on multiple fronts over being a anti-trust violations, invading privacy, and a litany of other issues over the past decade. spreading false news on a domestic election with very premature tech that is not fully within their control would just be the cherry on top.
Re:Google restricts Gemini chatbot election answers by crollywood on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @06:02AM (#39689689)
Yeah I had the same thought. Perhaps they are trying to regain some trustworthiness back.
Re:Google restricts Gemini chatbot election answers by okokwhatever on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @05:22AM (#39689482)
I dont understand the downvotes. The guy is right.
Re:Google restricts Gemini chatbot election answers by ptero on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @06:40AM (#39689919)
He might be. Or he might not be. He did not provide any justification or even argument, so his post reads like a simple flamebait. We should keep those on reddit. My 2c.
Re:Google restricts Gemini chatbot election answers by worksonmine on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @07:52AM (#39690356)
You can't expect people to back up everything with sources in every comment. If anyone is curious they can just ask for an elaboration, as someone did and they got one. Downvotes are for lazy people afraid of discussion, if it violates any rules there's the flag.
Re:Google restricts Gemini chatbot election answers by ImHereToVote on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @08:29AM (#39690579)
How could it violate the rules? The article is directly about how Google handles voting. Maybe the article is inappropriate.
Re:Google restricts Gemini chatbot election answers by worksonmine on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @08:56AM (#39690798)
I wasn't referring to your comment, I agree with you.
Re:Google restricts Gemini chatbot election answers by ptero on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @08:43AM (#39690684)
Downvoted are for comments that do not appear to add value. That's not a rigorous definition, but in practice it works reasonably well.

The original comment made a pretty explosive claim without any rationalization. Without some substantion that comment just inflames folks without fostering an interesting discussion. My 2c.

Re:Google restricts Gemini chatbot election answers by jsnell on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @08:53AM (#39690772)
It cuts both ways.

You also can't expect people to write long rebuttals to every inane conspiracy theory. That just allows people like the OP to commit what are effectively denial of service attacks on the community, by posting low effort ramblings with the expectation that they deserve a discussion, which the other people would need to put way more effort into than the OP would. Downvotes are for hiding this crap at the bottom of the page, so that it at least doesn't take away the oxygen from discussions grounded in reality.

Re:Google restricts Gemini chatbot election answers by worksonmine on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @09:03AM (#39690864)
Someones conspiracy theory is someone else's truth. And often they become everyone's truth after some time, see the lab leak theory for a recent example. This is the internet, you don't get to control what others say and still get to speak your own mind. I assume you don't need to back your claims up, am I right? Just dropping the magic words is enough.

I hate that word with a passion, it's used as the one and only argument to shut down discussion. Did you know that Google recently changed their terms to allow to censor results during "special events" or some bullshit like that? Big-tech trying to control the narrative is not a conspiracy theory, it's in the open.

If you don't have the attention span to argue your point or ask for an elaboration just move on. We are in the comment section for the discussion not for validation from the hive mind, right? Am I expecting too much from HN?

Re:Google restricts Gemini chatbot election answers by jsnell on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @09:50AM (#39691197)
See, this is funny, because it's actually you who is trying to control others, by demanding that they put in time and effort on engaging with low quality and low effort content rather than just downvote and move on.
Re:Google restricts Gemini chatbot election answers by worksonmine on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @10:47AM (#39691851)
"But what about you".

No, I don't. I'm arguing that downvoting is a lazy way to discuss. It's anonymous, drive-by and a completely useless way to speak your mind. I'm arguing that the option to downvote discourages discussion.

They don't have to engage at all if the quality was so low. What about the comment was low quality? How can it be improved? Are the claims incorrect? Or was someone just offended? All that information is lost with the downvote and there's no way to find out. If they know so much better why don't they use that knowledge and educate?

What is low quality is subjective, I don't think the comment was low quality, but the downvote brigade managed to hide it. It's a shame because this could've been an interesting thread. Ironic given the context don't you think?

Re:Google restricts Gemini chatbot election answers by ImHereToVote on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @05:41AM (#39689595)
Maybe Sundar Pichai is browsing Hacker News.