The problem was not the eventual consistency model, was the speed of the object list.
"...Finding objects based on other attributes, however, requires doing a linear search using the LIST operation. Because each listing can return at most 1000 keys, it may require many requests before finding the object. Because of these additional requests, implementing attribute-based queries in S3 alone can be challenging..."
But in 2020, S3 changed to strong consistency model. There is no need to use DynamoDB now.