News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other direc... by minimaxir on Friday March 08, 2024 @05:51PM (#39647481)
> The company will also announce the appointment of three new directors, Sue Desmond-Hellmann, a former CEO of the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, Nicole Seligman, a former president of Sony Entertainment, and Fidji Simo, CEO of Instacart, the Information said.

This selection of directors seems...random? Is there a business reason for these directors? (aside from the obvious YC link with Instacart)

Re:OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other direc... by code51 on Friday March 08, 2024 @06:00PM (#39647563)
All women, announced on International Women's Day.

The only significant side that's obvious.

Re:OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other direc... by DSingularity on Friday March 08, 2024 @06:39PM (#39647866)
We (humans) are so cheap and easily deceived.

They pick us large salaries and we build whatever. They pander and we become subservient.

Re:OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other direc... by nozzlegear on Friday March 08, 2024 @07:26PM (#39648162)
Do you feel that none of them have any merit outside of them being women, and that there was some kind of “best potential OpenAI director” exam that all men are required to take but these three were allowed to skip because of their gender? Is that the deception?
Re:OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other direc... by jprete on Friday March 08, 2024 @07:43PM (#39648246)
I'm not the GP, but one can believe that it's cheap pandering, and simultaneously that the three of them have merit outside of that pandering. It's not required to be all one or all the other.
Re:OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other direc... by DSingularity on Saturday March 09, 2024 @04:11AM (#39650482)
Yes. I don’t know them to know if they are not qualified — overall I think they are unlikely to be unqualified. What I am saying is it is easy to find qualified stooges. Like I said: pay us humans enough and we build whatever. Note: not all pay is in dollars. Prestige and power are also sought by man.

Overall: I am cynical wrt OpenAI. I just don't think that OpenAI is acting in the best interests of humanity and these appointments are strategic decisions taken to prolong survival long enough to execute their strategy and dominate. That was what I was originally insinuating.

Technological development keeps intersecting into the space of ethics. Time and time again man proves that he cannot rise above his own personal world views to focus on universal values when developing technology. We’ve seen this repeatedly. These people designing these APIs and building the underlying models are making consequential decisions on behalf of mankind. In a way the world is delegating all this power to unelected individuals who have very little in common — in terms of values and ethics — with mankind at large.

Re:OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other direc... by nozzlegear on Saturday March 09, 2024 @10:37AM (#39652301)
> Overall: I am cynical wrt OpenAI. I just don't think that OpenAI is acting in the best interests of humanity

For what it's worth, I agree with you on this part. Despite their stated goals and unique corporate structure that supposedly puts the non-profit at the center, I see OpenAI benefiting Sam Altman and Microsoft more than humanity.

Re:OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other direc... by baking on Friday March 08, 2024 @11:38PM (#39649417)
Well, in the whole brouhaha back in November many people pointed out that two women were forced off the board and replaced with two men.
Re:OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other direc... by FanaHOVA on Friday March 08, 2024 @05:54PM (#39647500)
Non profit / social focus person, media and entertainment person (that NYT suit might be followed by other m&e companies), direct to consumer + "real world digitalization" person.
Re:OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other direc... by swatcoder on Friday March 08, 2024 @06:10PM (#39647646)
Exactly. It's not random, it's revealing. You can see them starting to aim towards their first commercial bets beyond search and developer tools while still paying lip service to the safety cult.
Re:OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other direc... by coffeebeqn on Friday March 08, 2024 @07:38PM (#39648229)
I still don’t understand the safety concerns. I see a 0% chance that we can control a superhuman AI. What could ants invent to keep humans aligned with them? Alignment meaning that people would think of ants first instead of whatever their current ranking is. Maybe they’re in the top 10000 priorities
Re:OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other direc... by pests on Friday March 08, 2024 @09:04PM (#39648796)
Can you describe how it would be uncontrollable to us?

Everyone says this but no one has any details.

Also,

> What could ants invent to keep humans aligned with them?

I think humans aren't _not_ aligned with ants. I don't go out searching to destroy all ants, or really worry at all, we just kinda coexist.

Re:OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other direc... by jimkleiber on Friday March 08, 2024 @11:48PM (#39649452)
I'd say there's probably more human indifference to ants than anything. Maybe some hatred. Probably not a lot of love.
Re:OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other direc... by Atotalnoob on Friday March 08, 2024 @10:05PM (#39649087)
There are exterminators and ant infestations
Re:OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other direc... by ecoquant on Sunday March 10, 2024 @07:37AM (#39658382)
This is just typical doomer stupidity.

Of course, no one goes around trying to stomp on every ant hill they can because ants aren't good at math.

Not to mention, so much competition in humans is related to sexual competition. I suspect many doomers have no sex life and much of these ideas are projecting sexual frustrations on to AGI and AI.

The computer/software is not going to build a harem and try to eliminate competitors to the harem. Assuming software possessing being and consciousness isn't complete nonsense, even assuming the software is not an asexual being, humans and software are not going to be competing for the same sexual patterns lol.

This whole line of thought is just ridiculous.

Re:OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other direc... by CamperBob2 on Friday March 08, 2024 @11:32PM (#39649390)
What could ants invent to keep humans aligned with them?

Well, the bees figured it out.

Re:OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other direc... by jimkleiber on Friday March 08, 2024 @11:50PM (#39649455)
Kinda. We've invented many things to control and/or kill bees.
Re:OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other direc... by coffeebeqn on Saturday March 09, 2024 @02:32PM (#39654138)
We killed off a very large percentage of wild bees with pesticides and land “development” and keep one subspecies in artificial colonies and harvest their most prized outputs while controlling their rate of reproduction and even their queens. We also mass murder colonies when they are in any way inconvenient to a single human.

If anyone hopes AI will treat people like we do other species they’re not thinking very hard. What’s the best case - dogs? They have basically no freedoms and we breed them for whatever funny qualities someone thinks might be amusing. A pack of wild/free dogs will be rounded up and killed if it inconveniences a single human

Re:OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other direc... by jimkleiber on Saturday March 09, 2024 @10:36PM (#39656544)
Yeah, I appreciate you saying this. I think we often overlook how our behaviors towards most animals seems similar to slavery. I think some people back in the day thought, "Oh, we treat animals like this, why not treat humans like this?" And I wonder what if we were to go the other way, "We don't treat humans like that, perhaps we should stop treating animals like that?"

And that doesn't even get to the level of indifference we have towards plants.

I don't really know "the answer," just reflecting on how we domesticate other beings and what might happen if some being or thing (e.g., AI) decided to domesticate (or enslave) us.

Re:OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other direc... by dhruval on Saturday March 09, 2024 @12:34PM (#39653255)
There is a non-0% chance. You are looking at scenarios where evolution has selected for competition rather than nurturing.

So as a counter example:

A mom is a super intelligence compared to a baby. And yet does the babies bidding doing her sense best to make sense of the baby low fidelity crying.

Intelligence in AI is even more alien, it doesn’t need to have any survival instinct of its own at all

Re:OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other direc... by AnotherGoodName on Friday March 08, 2024 @07:36PM (#39648206)
You've listed the single previous role but they all have a long long list of achievements in tech? Nothing random about it.
Re:OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other direc... by yterdy on Friday March 08, 2024 @06:18PM (#39647718)
Club, ain't in it, etc.
Re:OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other direc... by drak0n1c on Friday March 08, 2024 @11:37PM (#39649411)
Nicole Seligman's husband Joel Klein famously prosecuted Microsoft with anti-trust in 2001. Time heals all wounds as they say.

Interestingly, soon after Seligman left Sony Entertainment in 2016 it started compelling PlayStation devs to censor character depictions and dialog - by 2018 this policy from California HQ was even imposed on long-loyal Japanese studios who made games solely for the Japanese market. I wonder what her opinion is on AI bias/safety given what happened at her old company.

Re:OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other direc... by darkwizard42 on Saturday March 09, 2024 @04:59AM (#39650641)
All fairly high profile with experience in non-profit and profit ventures.

I only have experience with Fidji who used to be head of the Facebook app and was razor sharp.