It's the longest period in our thousand years history that we Poles have not had to fight Germans.
We have lost maybe even 1/3 of population in wars with Sweden, 1/5 of population in war with Germany.
Poland didn't exist or 123 years under Russian, Prussian and Austrian occupation.
Given that as a baseline, I'm really grateful for the EU.
I don't think it is the EU that is keeping the peace; I reakoon it is the Haber process + the US more than anything else. Although if it was it is failing IMO, there is a land war in Europe right now that is at risk of fighting WWIII. And everyone is arming up again because of it.
The EU is what changed in Europe.
US "occupation" in Europe after WW2 was weak compared to the influence of the EU. The EU emanates all regulation in Europe. The US certainly didn't create the single market in the EU.
Also the brutal occupation of Easter Europe by the USSR is exactly an example of what the EU peace project is about solving.
The common market has probably been a net force for peace, but superpowers staking out areas where they were involved can hardly be brushed aside. After the fall of the USSR it hasn't been 30 years and we see land wars in their former sphere of influence.
Economics doesn't stop armies. We saw in WWII that insane politicians are perfectly capable of destroying everything in sight, economic consequences for their own citizens be damned.
[1]: https://www.euronews.com/next/2023/08/21/real-wages-are-down...
It is easy to imagine a war torn Europe without the EU. Then we would definitely be worse off.
Some things I really like:
* I can travel in a wide area with just my ID card (and practically even without it), no visa or passports required
* sending packages by mail is really easy and cheap compared to non-EU countries
* free mobile data roaming. Not such a big deal for me (but very convenient), but I have friends that travel a lot or are at home in more than one country, for them it's huge
* no need to exchange currencies when visiting lots of places (though not all EU countries)
* my health insurance mostly works in the other EU countries as well
* pretty strong consumer protection laws
* We've been living in peace for quite a few decades now, awesome! (And that's not how it used to be in central Europe, historically)
Note that national politicians often take credit for things mandated by EU, and put all the blame on the EU, so that kinda skews the public discords more negative than it should be.
Just one more data point: only one country has left the EU so far, and it seems they've come to regret it, mostly. Lots of countries have joined the EU since its formation, with more in the pipeline. Would that be the case if negatives outweighed the positives?
Community discussions are odd beasts.
Who can't afford to travel 100km?
Maybe for you, international travel means hopping on a plane.
Most Europeans live closer to another country than to most of their own.
And I'm not against either of those things, both are good. But it is funny how one comment is complaining about doing things that are good for business and the wealthy, then the next comment was celebrating the same.
Seems like this holds true more generally.
The manufacturing is happening in China, the decisions are being made in North America, and the regulation in the EU.
Its like direct (US), produce (China), react (EU)
This is another point that I think Americans miss sometimes - "good for the businesses" is seen as the end goal, and it is assumed that people will benefit in some trickle-down way from that.
The goal for all of this is for people to have good lives. Supporting businesses may or may not be the right way of doing that, but we shouldn't lose sight of the end goal.
1: https://www.nytimes.com/2003/01/12/opinion/the-triumph-of-ho...
1% is like 80 million people. That could translate to around 10% of the US. And the names of those 10% change as people earn more or less through their lives.
There is a middle ground between people making $20 an hour and business tycoons. Policies that help big business might not trickle down to people stocking shelves, but they often advantage middle class people.
For example, the US is an excellent place for software engineers. There are far more of them and they make far higher salaries than their European counterparts. Is it unreasonable to believe that American policies that empower big tech companies also benefit a developer making $250k at Google, even though he does not own the company?
What if policies that benefit the top 1% did, in fact, trickle down to the top 30% of Americans, at the expense of the bottom 70%? What if this bloc of people was organized enough to win elections and control politics without relying on people delusionally voting against their own interests?
In many cases, this is true. Tesla, for example, paid their early factory workers with stock in the company. As a result, many of the factory workers who worked on the Model 3 assembly line are now millionaires.
The US's relatively lax taxation/regulation on equity compensation is one of the reasons why tech workers in the US get paid so much more. Since they're actually literally part owners of the company, this might explain why they're usually more productive as well.
Definitely. Americans are very quick to prioritise the needs of businesses over those of people.
In Europe, the people come first.
Europe is sadly not energy independent like the USA is.
It's not economically feasible to operate a large factory in central europe any more, it's barely possible to operate a restaurant (they are closing in droves) -- energy prices are too high.
- energy independence
- lower energy prices (after the short term)
- addresses global warming
With a huge bonus:
- crushes the evil and collusive petro states
But at least some of the decisions that happen in North America are happening because of EU regulation. For example the push to get all phone manufacturers to standardise on USB chargers
So less in big name end user products, a lot in terms of "drive around EU and you can purchase everything to build any kind of factory"
I'd put energy in a similar frame. Energy matters a lot, and for all the optimistic noise around the Energiewende, the solar industry ended up in China. Wind power Europe has managed a company in the top ten, so that is pretty good [0]. Given the growing energy crisis in Europe, this seems to be an area of failure that needs more focus in how the common market is performing.
The EU's successes seem a bit mild. I remain sceptical that harmonizing charging cables is an important enough dot point to appear on these lists, it looks like there is just a lack of success stories out of the EU. The failures are catastrophic; last I heard the farmers had just started rioting too [1] which is a bad omen.
[0] https://www.zippia.com/advice/largest-wind-power-companies/
[1] https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2024/feb/26/farmers-...