News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Investigating immune response of a man who received 217 C... by canadiantim on Monday March 04, 2024 @10:49PM (#39599214)
Curiously, they don't mention why the man has received 217 Covid vaccines, except for "private reasons".
Re:Investigating immune response of a man who received 217 C... by lapcat on Monday March 04, 2024 @11:02PM (#39599284)
Apparently he was selling forged vaccination passports: https://apnews.com/article/covid-health-germany-europe-docum...
Re:Investigating immune response of a man who received 217 C... by kiba on Monday March 04, 2024 @11:05PM (#39599315)
Careful reading suggested he was arrested under suspicion of selling vaccine cards, not that he actually sold vaccine cards.
Re:Investigating immune response of a man who received 217 C... by lapcat on Monday March 04, 2024 @11:11PM (#39599352)
"Police confiscated several blank vaccination cards from him and initiated criminal proceedings."

What are you trying to say?

(1) He wasn't actually trying to selling vaccine cards?

(2) He was trying to selling vaccine cards but hadn't yet succeeded?

Given the evidence — the confiscated cards and the sheer number of shots already administered — both (1) and (2) seem like absurd presuppositions.

We're not a jury, and this is not a trial. We can't send him to jail, but we can say he's clearly guilty as hell.

Re:Investigating immune response of a man who received 217 C... by safety1st on Monday March 04, 2024 @11:30PM (#39599465)
No.

Big mistake and with respect you're uninformed and wrong here.

If he's not convicted then your statement is an accusation of guilt. A false accusation is defamation and it's damaging to the aggrieved party.

False accusations are both harmful to the target and risky for the person making them.

You don't need to be a jury or judge to care about this, for these reasons the AP style guide and practically every journalism outlet takes this matter very seriously.

Now maybe it's 2024, you're a rando from the other side of the world on the Internet and you just do what a billion other social media randos do and you run your mouth. You think your speech doesn't really matter because in practice if you're wrong neither of you is likely to be affected, so you don't need to hold yourself to this standard.

OK fair enough. But if your speech is junk that doesn't matter, why did you open your mouth in the first place? Do us all a favor and if you're going to promote the idea that casual defamation is fine, keep it shut.

Re:Investigating immune response of a man who received 217 C... by pseudo0 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @12:23AM (#39599747)
People commenting online are generally giving their opinions, not making statements of fact. Statements of opinion are not defamatory. My opinion is that given the evidence in the article, this guy was probably was selling fake vaccination passports. I also hold the opinion that OJ Simpson is probably a murderer, despite his criminal acquittal.

News organizations generally try to split their coverage into fact and opinion sections. It would be inappropriate to insert opinion into a factual article, but they can and frequently do weigh in on legal matters in opinion sections. The bar for defamation there is usually actual malice, so in reality it's extremely hard to prevail in suing a news organization for defamation.

Re:Investigating immune response of a man who received 217 C... by lapcat on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @07:06AM (#39602292)
Wow, this reply may be crazier than the 217 vaccinations. Get a grip.
Re:Investigating immune response of a man who received 217 C... by bee_rider on Monday March 04, 2024 @11:54PM (#39599585)
The lancet paper has more details

https://www.thelancet.com/journals/laninf/article/PIIS1473-3...

> Evidence for 130 vaccinations in a 9 month period was collected by the public prosecutor of Magdeburg, Germany, who opened an investigation of this case with the allegation of fraud, but criminal charges were not filed.

Given the amount of information they gathered about him, it seems likely that if he was doing something illegal, they would have worked it out and charged him, I guess? It seems like an odd thing to do for “personal reasons” as they say in the paper. But the pandemic was a weird event for everybody, maybe it induced odd behavior or something like that. It is hard to say.

Re:Investigating immune response of a man who received 217 C... by evandijk70 on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @03:02AM (#39600561)
Purely speculating here, but perhaps omitting the reason was a condition of the hypervaccinated individual to cooperate with the study?
Re:Investigating immune response of a man who received 217 C... by bee_rider on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @12:17PM (#39606400)
Could be! Hard to say, right?

I would tend to assume that the person’s motivation is less interesting to the researchers, and getting into it could distract from the research. Plus, who knows, maybe Germany just has really strict ethical and personal medical laws, so the researchers could just want to avoid that whole minefield.

Re:Investigating immune response of a man who received 217 C... by lern_too_spel on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @12:10AM (#39599661)
It sounds like he just wanted to get a lot of vaccinations and used blank cards to not arouse suspicion from the person administering the vaccine and stamping the card.
Re:Investigating immune response of a man who received 217 C... by InSteady on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @12:37AM (#39599825)
This is such a no brainer. The article states he has official records of 134 vaccinations.

They wont just keep stamping the same card endlessly until it is completely covered. How else is he going to accomplish this absurd undertaking but to have access to a bunch of official vaccination documents?

It's not outside the realm of possibility that he was also selling them, but I feel like Occam and Hanlon both agree that unless there is direct evidence, he's probably not some criminal mastermind getting rich. He's just a random person with either a fetish or something to prove.

Re:Investigating immune response of a man who received 217 C... by lapcat on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @06:29AM (#39602053)
> It's not outside the realm of possibility that he was also selling them

From the AP story: "German police have conducted many raids in connection with forgery of vaccination passports in recent months."

This wasn't just an isolated case or idle speculation. People were selling them, regardless of whether this particular individual did.

> he's probably not some criminal mastermind getting rich

Of course not. He was a dumb petty criminal who got caught, just like countless other dumb petty criminals in the world.

Re:Investigating immune response of a man who received 217 C... by hillz on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @01:00AM (#39599938)
> clearly guilty as hell

I think you underestimate the power of neuroses. Good chance no money was involved.

Re:Investigating immune response of a man who received 217 C... by lapcat on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @06:22AM (#39601996)
> I think you underestimate the power of neuroses.

Neurosis was my initial theory, before I discovered the news articles mentioned in the submission. "They learned of his case via newspaper reports."

Re:Investigating immune response of a man who received 217 C... by mikeyouse on Monday March 04, 2024 @10:58PM (#39599251)
The Lancet link has slightly more detail - sounds like he's a bit crazy and they were investigating him because they thought there was fraud happening but then they realized he was just 'hypervaccinated' and so they didn't file charges and enrolled him in this study;

> Here, we report on a 62-year-old male hypervaccinated individual from Magdeburg, Germany (HIM), who deliberately and for private reasons received 217 vaccinations against SARS-CoV-2 within a period of 29 months (figure A; appendix 1 tab 1). HIM's hypervaccination occurred outside of a clinical study context and against national vaccination recommendations. Evidence for 130 vaccinations in a 9 month period was collected by the public prosecutor of Magdeburg, Germany, who opened an investigation of this case with the allegation of fraud, but criminal charges were not filed. 108 vaccinations are individually recorded and partly overlap with the total of 130 prosecutor-confirmed vaccinations (appendix 2 p 12). To investigate the immunological consequences of hypervaccination in this unique situation, we submitted an analysis proposal to HIM via the public prosecutor. HIM then actively and voluntarily consented to provide medical information and donate blood and saliva. This procedure was approved by the local Ethics Committee of the University Hospital of Erlangen, Germany. Throughout the entire hypervaccination schedule HIM did not report any vaccination-related side effects. From November 2019, to October 2023, 62 routine clinical chemistry parameters showed no abnormalities attributable to hypervaccination (appendix 1 tab 2). Furthermore, HIM had no signs of a past SARS-CoV-2 infection, as indicated by repeatedly negative SARS-CoV-2 antigen tests, PCRs and nucleocapsid serology (figure A; appendix 1 tab 1).

https://www.thelancet.com/journals/laninf/article/PIIS1473-3...

Re:Investigating immune response of a man who received 217 C... by andrewflnr on Monday March 04, 2024 @11:57PM (#39599604)
I don't know, maybe they just gave him a break on the charges in exchange for cooperating with the study. You know the scientists would try to pull something like that to study a unique case if at all possible, and I know I would "actively and voluntarily consent" to that if my alternative was jail.
Re:Investigating immune response of a man who received 217 C... by mikeyouse on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @12:40AM (#39599840)
That'd be super unethical and they point out it passed their IRB so that's unlikely to have been the case. I believe their system is like the US where the docs/pharmacies are reimbursed for each dose given so the prosecutors likely were doing basic fraud detection and saw that 100+ doses were associated with the same person which lead them to investigate -- it's probably not illegal to get hundreds of vaccinations hence the lack of charges and it just so happened to have provided an interesting data point for researchers.
Re:Investigating immune response of a man who received 217 C... by andrewflnr on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @12:56AM (#39599916)
Fair point about the ethics angle. I guess. Personally I think it's morally fine (clearly a win-win for him and society) but it does look like coercion and there's a case for avoiding "even the appearance of evil"...
Re:Investigating immune response of a man who received 217 C... by petesergeant on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @12:52AM (#39599894)
> 62-year-male … for private reasons

Without being crass, I can definitely see a world in which someone showing up to do something they know they’re not meant to do, interacting with a nurse (likely female, likely in a uniform), and getting a small but manageable amount of pain being a fetish thing.

Re:Investigating immune response of a man who received 217 C... by NoGravitas on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @09:05AM (#39603576)
You're getting downvoted for this, but there were people who actually developed a fetish for intranasal stimulation back when covid testing was still common (and presumably many more who joked about it - see "nussy").
Re:Investigating immune response of a man who received 217 C... by schoen on Monday March 04, 2024 @11:06PM (#39599322)
Most explanations I can think of would involve an anxiety, delusional, memory, or cognitive disorder. Or an art project, scientific self-experimentation, or an deliberate effort to experience an adverse reaction in order to qualify for a vaccine injury payment?

[ Edit: Wow, I didn't even think of the fraud possibility mentioned in other comments. :-( :-( In some places maybe people are also directly paid to receive vaccines? ]

I wonder if there's anyone for whom 217 total lifetime vaccine doses (cumulative across various vaccines) would be considered medically indicated. Maybe if you got childhood vaccines on an inefficient schedule, moved around between countries with different recommendations, got a bunch of travel or special occupational hazard or special exposure risk immunizations, eventually got multi-dose old age vaccine series, and also got the annual flu shot every year?

Oh, I guess if you go to both the northern and the southern hemisphere every year, you could have two different annual flu shots indicated (since the hemispheres have different flu shot formulations). I think that could do it when combined with the other stuff.

Re:Investigating immune response of a man who received 217 C... by triceratops on Monday March 04, 2024 @11:16PM (#39599384)
He read Bruce Lee's adage about the man who practices one kick 5000 times. /s