News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by threeseed on Sunday March 03, 2024 @07:47PM (#39585942)
KYC/AML is not some made up concept in order to further some conspiracy. There is genuine harm caused by money laundering and the fraudulent use of the financial system by bad actors.

Likewise anonymous use of shared infrastructure is a central part of the scam/spam/malware ecosystem which costs the global economy $10+ trillion a year.

At some point given the impacts to the most vulnerable in society we need to simply ask that people prove who they are.

Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by costco on Sunday March 03, 2024 @08:12PM (#39586083)
This is about KYC for servers. There are plenty of reasons to think that this will be completely ineffective because foreign providers are under no such obligation. It's also incredibly misguided because the providers that generally harbor abuse are overwhelmingly in foreign countries - no one is starting a bulletproof host in the US. And given that providers will likely only implement the minimum required KYC, it is not even going to be as sophisticated as selfie verification. Which means in the event criminals do want to use a US hosting provider, they will use a $5 fake ID Photoshop template like they always have or pay $15 for a premade account. Even if more sophisticated verification like Onfido is used, that will raise the cost of getting an account with a fake ID to about $150 (that's the price of most crypto exchange accounts on fraud forums).

Also, little barriers to entry like this are the kind of things that discourage initiative and make our economy slightly less competitive. When I was a teenager I wrote Linux tutorials on vultr.com for $50 each to be credited to my account, which I used to pay for hosting before I had a debit card. I had no drivers license so if I encountered some dialog asking for an ID I would've just clicked away and been disappointed. There are 17 year olds running hosting businesses on lowendtalk.com - should their $1000 a month in revenue business be expected to consult with a lawyer to write a 40 page customer identification plan?

Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by sroussey on Sunday March 03, 2024 @08:33PM (#39586204)
You need a local business license, but most people doing stuff on the internet don't know or bother.

People in Los Angeles get a shock when they find out the city wants it percent of global sales.

Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by costco on Sunday March 03, 2024 @08:40PM (#39586240)
The penalties for violating that are also not very high at the scale of small internet businesses. Violations of the proposed rule are treated as violations of IEEPA which is far more serious.
Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by saxonww on Sunday March 03, 2024 @08:51PM (#39586304)
> foreign providers are under no such obligation

What happens with foreign financial institutions which don't implement KYC or otherwise play nice? I'm really asking; I remember when I was young that "swiss bank accounts" were famous for shielding account owners, but my understanding is that's no longer the case.

My first thought here was, what happens when the US decides that network providers doing business in the US must blackhole Hetzner or whatever because they aren't implementing KYC.

Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by costco on Sunday March 03, 2024 @09:02PM (#39586363)
I mean, it's conceivable that could happen down the line but it would break most of the current Internet. Also the rule explicitly says its for US providers. However, the government really loves the extraterritorial enforcement angle as of late so I get the feeling they'll eventually try to apply it to foreign subsidiaries of US companies.
Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by justapassenger on Sunday March 03, 2024 @09:19PM (#39586446)
It’s typical native tech thinking that legal issues can be solved by technology.

USA has a lot of experience how they can influence foreign providers by making it increasingly difficult for them to do business with any USA entities. It’s not bulletproof, but nothing is. As long as USA has dominant position in the world, their influence is huge.

Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by AmericanChopper on Sunday March 03, 2024 @07:52PM (#39585973)
KYC and AML do very little to actually address any risks related to money laundering. But they’re very powerful tools that banks use to push their customers around and control how they use their money (somehow usually in ways that benefit the banks of course).
Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by nine_k on Sunday March 03, 2024 @07:55PM (#39585991)
Could you offer a few examples of such limitations which banks impose, and how it benefits them?
Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by brunblanc on Sunday March 03, 2024 @08:55PM (#39586326)
1) Float. Every dollar that is held in limbo 'for checking' is interest income to the bank. 2) Rabid identification requirements lower the risk of new account fraud (which is paid by the bank). 3) Information on who you're sending payments to is usable by the bank for prospecting and risk analysis. 4) If you read anything about regulatory capture, it explains how regulation is used by incumbents to discourage competition. i.e. No new banks have opened in the U.S. since 2009, when new regulations to prevent banks from getting bigger were passed. <- And now, the biggest banks are MUCH larger.
Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by threeseed on Sunday March 03, 2024 @09:22PM (#39586462)
> No new banks have opened in the U.S. since 2009

From 2009 to 2013 only 7 new banks were formed, fewer than 2 per year.

Many industry observers have suggested that the decline is primarily due to regulatory burden, including new FDIC regulations and the 2010 Dodd‐Frank Act. But other influences could have played a role, in particular, the current weak economy.

https://www.federalreserve.gov/econresdata/feds/2014/files/2...

Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by AmericanChopper on Sunday March 03, 2024 @09:09PM (#39586391)
Banks don’t want you to do anything that reduces their deposits, because they directly lose money when that happens. If you had $1 billion in deposits at a bank that was getting 5% returns on investing its deposits, and you wanted to spend that money on buying some securities or something, then that bank would generate approx $1,000,000 in returns for every week that the AML process takes to complete.

Due to how fractional banking works, in reality they would be earning some multiple of that return rate, but that’s a bit more abstract and hard to quantify.

Because AML processes are completely opaque, often made up on the fly and operate without any due process, banks can and routinely do delay transactions worth multiple billions of dollars for many weeks or longer by asking lots of irrelevant questions, requesting new documents or minor changes, and taking their time in getting back to you about anything, ect... In the world of high value transactions these kafkaesque processes and delays are completely routine.

Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by AlbertCory on Sunday March 03, 2024 @08:07PM (#39586056)
> KYC and AML do very little

This reminds me of when people say, "those stories of street crime are exaggerated." It's content-free. And "any risks related to money laundering" is rather dismissive, isn't it?

Are you denying that actual criminals have a problem with moving money around except in $100 bills and other tangible assets?

Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by brunblanc on Sunday March 03, 2024 @08:57PM (#39586339)
I would say that PETTY criminals have difficulty moving money around electronically. Criminals with LOTS of money do not have any difficulty finding an investment bank to handle money movement. i.e. Epstein JPMorgan, WireCard, Lloyds https://www.reuters.com/world/uk/lloyds-says-it-faces-money-...
Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by AmericanChopper on Sunday March 03, 2024 @09:20PM (#39586448)
AML laws are just a compliance cost of actual money launderers. All they do is increase the number of intermediaries involved in a transaction (who each collect their fees).
Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by AlbertCory on Sunday March 03, 2024 @09:34PM (#39586536)
Even if that were to be granted for the sake of argument:

why is it a bad thing to make criminals expend more effort and money?

Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by safety1st on Sunday March 03, 2024 @10:02PM (#39586655)
Embedded within our justice system and the values of our society we have the concept of the protection of the innocent. See William Blackstone's famous quotation: "It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer."

If you want to imprison all the murderers, you can accomplish that goal by imprisoning everyone but we don't do this and most people would recognize that the idea is mad.

So the test here for any regulating authority should be, is your regulation harming the innocent in some way? If so, the imperative is on you to find a better way to go after the guilty, if you don't you have become an enemy of the public good and your moral authority is lost. We can get into specific regulations but I think with modern KYC and AML we are absolutely at the point where they contribute to the suppression of economic growth and individual liberties and need to be dialed back.

Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by naasking on Sunday March 03, 2024 @10:32PM (#39586780)
Very well said. It should also be said that criminals that want to launder money only exist because of government regulation. Sometimes that's totally justified, say with human trafficking, and sometimes not so much, like maybe a marijuana dispensary.

The point being, sometimes undercutting criminal activity can be done be legalizing the activity rather than introducing more types of illegal activities to try and detect the original ones. The cure is sometimes worse than the disease.

Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by fragmede on Sunday March 03, 2024 @10:27PM (#39586763)
That parts fine, it's the collateral damage that's the problem. Laws don't know who're the bad guys and who are the good guys, and sometimes everyone else gets caught up in the dragnet. By all means, stop the bad guys, but unfortunately, they don't easily identify themselves, so we pass laws and apply them to everyone (in theory), but they can end up doing more harm than good.

The $10k rule by the Bank Secrecy Act wasn't indexed to inflation and would be closer to $80k today. So it should be amounts up to $80k that aren't considered worth monitoring, but instead, if you deal with, say, buying and selling cars, you get tripped up by that all the time. It's regulatory red tape overhead that costs a legitimate business extra time money that they could be better spent elsewhere.

Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by justsomehnguy on Monday March 04, 2024 @03:12AM (#39588137)
For the every criminal there are thousands of people getting.. KYC'ed over minutiae.

And even you yourself answer the main question - it doesn't stop criminals. Just makes it more expensive.

Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by AlbertCory on Sunday March 03, 2024 @09:33PM (#39586525)
what is that link supposed to demonstrate? Lloyds is facing an investigation. So?

As for "Criminals with LOTS of money do not have any difficulty finding an investment bank to handle money movement" what is your evidence for that? And what's the line between "petty" and "LOTS of money" ?

Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by brunblanc on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @02:35AM (#39600410)
I have multiple ACAMS certifications (the trade group that certifies all of us Anti-Money Laundering personnel who work at banks). And no, the public can't apply for membership. 1) Search WallStreetOnParade.com and read all of the articles about laundering. 2) Read the Mary Erdoes and Jamie Dimon depositions about Epstein involvement. JPM was putting Epstein's bribes through to the Governor of USVI. JPM was 'forgetting' to file the mandatory SAR notices on the $5MM in cash that Epstein was withdrawing each year for victim payments. 3) The Yakuza (as written in Tokyo Vice - the book) use privacy laws to prevent any of their businesses from being tied to them. 4) Read Butler to the World: How Britain Helps the world's worst people launder money.
Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by threeseed on Sunday March 03, 2024 @08:22PM (#39586144)
Where I live there isn't just one bank.

So customers can very easily move their money and business elsewhere if they feel like they are being somehow controlled. And as someone who has worked at two banks almost all of those restrictions derive from the government.

Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by AmericanChopper on Sunday March 03, 2024 @09:18PM (#39586439)
> So customers can very easily move their money

For retail and SME customers this is true. But for any customer that deals with large sums of money it is not. If you’ve never heard of an MT730, then you probably have good reason to think that moving money around is easy.

Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by threeseed on Sunday March 03, 2024 @09:21PM (#39586453)
You're dealing with large sums of money and you want to remain anonymous.

Sounds like exactly the sort of entities that the government should be investigating.

Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by kelnos on Sunday March 03, 2024 @11:52PM (#39587146)
Ah yes, "if you want to be anonymous while doing X, you're probably a criminal". That's reductive.
Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer... by AmericanChopper on Sunday March 03, 2024 @09:29PM (#39586500)
Where did I say anything about anonymous? I do some work with an AML consultancy, and I’ve never even heard of a customer who wanted to be anonymous.

But your reaction of “must be a criminal, let’s investigate you” to my complaints of banks abusing your power leads me to 100% believe your claim of having worked in banks before.