News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rogue Editors Started a Competing Wikipedia That's Only A... by bloopernova on Saturday March 02, 2024 @01:47PM (#39574815)
Reminds me of Everything2. It started as a freeform text linking site, where nodes (pages) could be linked just like a wiki these days. It was written by some of the slashdot crew, back around 2000. The site grew and attracted a fun crowd who really liked the freeform wiki-like interface. Unfortunately some of the admins wanted to compete with Wikipedia, so the fun, frivolous stuff was discouraged over purely factual nodes. This meant that some people stopped contributing. I left around that time.

https://everything2.com/

Huh it's still going! It must be 25 years old now, not a bad achievement.

Re:Rogue Editors Started a Competing Wikipedia That's Only A... by thoughtFrame on Saturday March 02, 2024 @02:00PM (#39574928)
That's interesting, because I checked out everything2 last year to see what I had missed out on, and found it a nice place with poetry and personal essays. Maybe at some point their culture changed again?
Re:Rogue Editors Started a Competing Wikipedia That's Only A... by bloopernova on Saturday March 02, 2024 @02:09PM (#39574987)
It's entirely possible! I left sometime in the mid 2000s, so there's certainly a lot of time for cultures to have changed significantly even multiple times.
Re:Rogue Editors Started a Competing Wikipedia That's Only A... by creatonez on Saturday March 02, 2024 @09:41PM (#39577978)
> Maybe at some point their culture changed again?

Supposedly Tumblr has done the same. They crashed and burned so hard that they actually came out of the ordeal with a reverse eternal September effect, where miraculously most people act respectfully towards each other and are not just trying to exploit the platform.

Re:Rogue Editors Started a Competing Wikipedia That's Only A... by unwind on Saturday March 02, 2024 @01:54PM (#39574885)
Founded (as "Everything1") in 1998 according to the other site.
Re:Rogue Editors Started a Competing Wikipedia That's Only A... by bloopernova on Saturday March 02, 2024 @02:08PM (#39574983)
Oh right! Yeah I completely forgot about its initial incarnation being named that.

It was definitely a new frontier where we thought anything was possible. Just being able to easily link between nodes/pages was a very cool feature back then.

Re:Rogue Editors Started a Competing Wikipedia That's Only A... by Espressosaurus on Saturday March 02, 2024 @06:22PM (#39576742)
Hah. I remember joining it to write a bunch of stuff about a game, which immediately got removed.

I of course immediately left.

What is with these "encyclopedias of everything" that don't want frivolous information?

Re:Rogue Editors Started a Competing Wikipedia That's Only A... by contravariant on Saturday March 02, 2024 @06:26PM (#39576767)
Easy, if you want an encyclopedia that contains truly everything you can just use the library of babel.
Re:Rogue Editors Started a Competing Wikipedia That's Only A... by Dylan16807 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @12:43AM (#39578724)
Sure, if you move the goalpost from "information" to "has letters".
Re:Rogue Editors Started a Competing Wikipedia That's Only A... by ethbr1 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @12:38AM (#39578713)
Humankind's inherent love of rules and order?

>> “I don’t have a problem with roads,” Zeleny said. “There are lots of obscure subjects on Wikipedia, but you have to follow the guidelines. People see Wikipedia as a joke. They think it’s not serious. I’ve taken great, great pains to make sure articles are well written, well researched, and well cited.”

Or maybe more precisely, people's desire to believe the thing they're volunteering vast amounts of their personal time to matters and is serious, and because it's serious there should be rules.

Re:Rogue Editors Started a Competing Wikipedia That's Only A... by Cipater on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:36AM (#39579209)
I agree that people contributing to Wikipedia should take it seriously.

I also believe that Wikipedia is important and the work contributers do there matters.

Your comment makes it sound like you disagree.

Re:Rogue Editors Started a Competing Wikipedia That's Only A... by ethbr1 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @08:47AM (#39580805)
I think it's unreasonable to treat people's volunteer efforts lightly. Nobody gives massive amount of personal time to something they don't really care about.

But that also leads to myoptic views of projects in super-volunteers, where the intent of the project to users gets lost in performance of the rules.

I'm not sure this is a solveable problem for volunteer-based projects though. There are only so many people willing to donate time, and you have to keep them happy.

Re:Rogue Editors Started a Competing Wikipedia That's Only A... by err4nt on Sunday March 03, 2024 @11:53AM (#39582032)
My wikipedia editing experience was similar, crazy to think that it was almost 20 years ago. Me and some friends contributed our honest-best to some articles relating to language dialects we spoke, and minerals we liked - the stuff we could nerd out about a tiny bit more than whatever was on Wikipedia at the time, and so we added our paragraphs. In all cases the changes were reverted, and we actually made an enemy with a wikipedia editor who if I recall was an army vet and science teacher, and personally 'babysat' the articles about minerals, and would allow no changes to his articles.

I think it would be cool if there was something that saved all contributions, even deleted ones, and made it easy to explore all of them. I know Wikipedia has a diff history but that's not the right interface to bring all that to the surface.

Looking forward to the next collaborative scrapbook to start up so I can participate in good faith and have some good fun :D