News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Entropy Bagels' and Other Complex Structures Emerge from... by vinnyvichy on Thursday February 29, 2024 @04:49PM (#39555647)
The qm article says "A number is totally real if it satisfies a polynomial equation with integer coefficients" etc but I love your spirit and it's totally on quantamags for not stating their inputs up front
Re:'Entropy Bagels' and Other Complex Structures Emerge from... by 9991 on Thursday February 29, 2024 @09:28PM (#39557864)
As always, Quanta Magazine reporting is just garbage. The name for such numbers is ‘algebraic’.
Re:'Entropy Bagels' and Other Complex Structures Emerge from... by throwaway81523 on Thursday February 29, 2024 @11:40PM (#39558582)
No it's narrower than algebraic. If I have this right, the number is totally real if it's a root of a polynomial with integer coefficients, all of whose roots are real. So for example, the (real) cube root of 2 is not totally real, because x^3-2 has one real root and two complex roots. The idea of totally real is that not only is the root real, but all of its images under the polynomial's Galois group are also real.

See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Totally_real_number_field

Added: in fact the Quanta article gets this right. It says "A number is totally real if it satisfies a polynomial equation with integer coefficients that only has real roots." Also, Jordana Cepelowicz is a knowledgeable math writer and I believe she has a PhD in math.

Re:'Entropy Bagels' and Other Complex Structures Emerge from... by bubblyworld on Friday March 01, 2024 @12:33AM (#39558854)
Yeah, you've got it right, the Quanta article covered this accurately.

For instance, 'i' is algebraic but not totally real (it isn't a real number!), since it satisfies 'x^2 + 1'.

Re:'Entropy Bagels' and Other Complex Structures Emerge from... by throwaway81523 on Friday March 01, 2024 @02:46AM (#39559561)
It does seem like a bit of not totally accurate shorthand: totally real isn't a property of a number, but rather of the extension field where it lives. So sqrt(2) is a root of x^2-2 whose roots are +/- sqrt(2), and the splitting field of x^2-2 is Q(sqrt(2)) which is totally real. But sqrt(2) is also a root of x^4-4 whose roots are +/- sqrt(2) and +/- i sqrt(2), so the splitting field doesn't live inside the reals. The wiki article explains it better. I was unfamiliar with this idea before.
Re:'Entropy Bagels' and Other Complex Structures Emerge from... by bubblyworld on Friday March 01, 2024 @04:30AM (#39560148)
That's true but I think it's implicit here we're working with the algebraic extension generated by the number itself (which always contains the Galois conjugates).
Re:'Entropy Bagels' and Other Complex Structures Emerge from... by throwaway81523 on Thursday March 07, 2024 @06:46PM (#39636036)
I'm not sure if I'm using the jargon properly, but if r is the real cube root of 2, then I thought the extension generated by r is Q(r), which contains only reals. So (x^3 - 2) factors into (x-r) and the irreducible quadratic (x^2 + r*x + r^2). You have to do some extra thing to reach the splitting field, amirite?
Re:'Entropy Bagels' and Other Complex Structures Emerge from... by bubblyworld on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @11:48AM (#39692899)
Pardon me, you're completely right! Thanks for reminding me to refresh my basics before I write =)
Re:'Entropy Bagels' and Other Complex Structures Emerge from... by gjm11 on Thursday February 29, 2024 @09:39PM (#39557934)
The quotation from Quanta was incomplete, and the Quanta article doesn't in fact claim that "totally real" means what "algebraic" actually means. Here's what the article actually says (added emphasis mine):

> A number is totally real if it satisfies a polynomial equation with integer coefficients that only has real roots.

Nothing wrong with that.

Re:'Entropy Bagels' and Other Complex Structures Emerge from... by JadeNB on Thursday February 29, 2024 @10:31PM (#39558240)
> As always, Quanta Magazine reporting is just garbage. The name for such numbers is ‘algebraic’.

Any popularization is inevitably going to run into some inaccuracies—or else it's just re-publishing the technical papers—but the opinions of most mathematicians I know are that, far from being garbage, Quanta's reporting is distinctly better than most.

Re:'Entropy Bagels' and Other Complex Structures Emerge from... by bubblyworld on Friday March 01, 2024 @12:37AM (#39558876)
I highly recommend reading the article, you might be pleasantly surprised =)
Re:'Entropy Bagels' and Other Complex Structures Emerge from... by 9991 on Friday March 01, 2024 @04:07AM (#39560028)
I wrote them off a long time ago, but after this comment thread, I’ll give them another shot. Thanks!
Re:'Entropy Bagels' and Other Complex Structures Emerge from... by bubblyworld on Friday March 01, 2024 @12:28AM (#39558828)
Right, but that's not what they're actually plotting - the quanta bagel is algebraic numbers with colour given by the entropy of their corresponding dynamics! Whereas the one I posted is roots of integer polynomials by density.

The fact that they look similar is striking. It means in some sense roots of integer polynomials generate more complex iterative systems, which is surprising (to me).