Re:'Entropy Bagels' and Other Complex Structures Emerge from...
by bubblyworld on Friday March 01, 2024 @12:33AM
(#39558854)
Yeah, you've got it right, the Quanta article covered this accurately.
For instance, 'i' is algebraic but not totally real (it isn't a real number!), since it satisfies 'x^2 + 1'.
Re:'Entropy Bagels' and Other Complex Structures Emerge from...
by throwaway81523 on Friday March 01, 2024 @02:46AM
(#39559561)
It does seem like a bit of not totally accurate shorthand: totally real isn't a property of a number, but rather of the extension field where it lives. So sqrt(2) is a root of x^2-2 whose roots are +/- sqrt(2), and the splitting field of x^2-2 is Q(sqrt(2)) which is totally real. But sqrt(2) is also a root of x^4-4 whose roots are +/- sqrt(2) and +/- i sqrt(2), so the splitting field doesn't live inside the reals. The wiki article explains it better. I was unfamiliar with this idea before.
Re:'Entropy Bagels' and Other Complex Structures Emerge from...
by bubblyworld on Friday March 01, 2024 @04:30AM
(#39560148)
That's true but I think it's implicit here we're working with the algebraic extension generated by the number itself (which always contains the Galois conjugates).
Re:'Entropy Bagels' and Other Complex Structures Emerge from...
by throwaway81523 on Thursday March 07, 2024 @06:46PM
(#39636036)
I'm not sure if I'm using the jargon properly, but if r is the real cube root of 2, then I thought the extension generated by r is Q(r), which contains only reals. So (x^3 - 2) factors into (x-r) and the irreducible quadratic (x^2 + r*x + r^2). You have to do some extra thing to reach the splitting field, amirite?
Re:'Entropy Bagels' and Other Complex Structures Emerge from...
by bubblyworld on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @11:48AM
(#39692899)
Pardon me, you're completely right! Thanks for reminding me to refresh my basics before I write =)
See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Totally_real_number_field
Added: in fact the Quanta article gets this right. It says "A number is totally real if it satisfies a polynomial equation with integer coefficients that only has real roots." Also, Jordana Cepelowicz is a knowledgeable math writer and I believe she has a PhD in math.