News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft strikes deal with Mistral in push beyond OpenAI by ben_w on Monday February 26, 2024 @12:54PM (#39514513)
> Make them start over from a clean room with no copyrighted data.

And when such models become popular[0], all the artists now have no job and no way to get compensation for being unable to work through no fault of their own.

I don't think that's really a winning condition. It might make you feel better about the world, but the end result is still all the artists being out of work.

[0] some models are already trained that way, although I assume you're using the word "copyrighted" in the conventional sense of "neither public domain nor an open license", as e.g. all my MIT licensed stuff is still copyrighted but it's fine to use.

Re:Microsoft strikes deal with Mistral in push beyond OpenAI by robrenaud on Monday February 26, 2024 @01:49PM (#39515295)
In my hypothetical future, at least the people who create the content used to train the models can get "training royalties", which they aren't getting now.

There is still also money to be made in producing physical art or performances, even when AI can produce amazing digital works.

Re:Microsoft strikes deal with Mistral in push beyond OpenAI by ben_w on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @02:46AM (#39521280)
"Make them start over from a clean room with no copyrighted data." makes "the people who create the content used to train the models" the empty set.

> There is still also money to be made in producing physical art or performances, even when AI can produce amazing digital works.

Perhaps, but it may be akin to the way there is still money to be made from horse drawn carriages in city centres, even when cars displaced them over a century ago — a rare treat for special occasions, to demonstrate wealth.

Re:Microsoft strikes deal with Mistral in push beyond OpenAI by rusticpenn on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @04:22AM (#39521951)
> It might make you feel better about the world, but the end result is still all the artists being out of work.

Is it not the same with every leap in technology? There were professions like street lamp lighters, alarm services etc that have become redundant now?

Re:Microsoft strikes deal with Mistral in push beyond OpenAI by ben_w on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @12:08PM (#39526521)
Sure, though I suspect "art" is the human version of a peacock tail — the difficulty is the point, it how we signal our worth to others, cheapening it breaks that signal — which would suggest that making all forms of art easy messes with (many of) us at a deep, essentially automatic, level.

More specifically, I was responding to the idea that "compensating creators" would actually solve anything; to use your examples, it would be as if the literal luddites were suggesting passing laws saying that "all textile machines that work like humans need to compensate the humans they displace", and my response would be analogous to saying "there's already machines which don't work like humans, so you're going to be out of work and have no compensation".

The Luddite movement preceded The Communist Manifesto by about 30 years. Everything's sped up since then, so I'd be surprised if we have to wait 30 years for a political shift which is to AI what Communism was to industrialisation.