I think it might be interesting to have a knob-like control that responds to the scrolling action of the mouse/touchpad. At least with that, you'd have (somewhat) clearly defined up and down actions. Touchscreens could support this with a two-finger-up/down gesture, and then we'd be very well on our way to Trek-like UIs ;-)
Re:JQuery knobs
by ricardobeat on Wednesday May 09, 2012 @09:12PM
(#3951364)
Some iOS apps already do (can't remember right now).
I'm not sure if it's what Udo meant, but the date/time widgets are in this vein. Actually, a knob that functioned like those widgets would be quite interesting.
All popular software-synthesizer knob controls adjust the value by dragging vertically. Including the really well-designed ones like Ableton Live.
Which is why this piece of UI is rather counter-intuitive, and it's obvious the author hasn't ever really used any other software with knob controls.
But even then, I kinda think knob controls aren't very user-friendly either way. I can sort of understand their usage in software synths as a skeuomorph, but that's about it.
Re:JQuery knobs
by gravitronic on Thursday May 10, 2012 @09:38AM
(#3953374)
For my android app DJPad I originally implemented knob control as linear. Move up or right and the value increases, move down or left and the value decreases.
I realized this was a mistake when I gave my app to friends to test and had to stop myself from saying "no! you're moving the knob wrong!" and went back to the drawing board :)
Which then gets me thinking about direct vs indirect manipulation. Which then distracts me from eating my breakfast.