> Either your domain names are universally accessible, or someone needs to follow specific instructions to use them, in which case why use AlterNIC or OpenNIC, when you could just give instructions that were specific to your chosen domain name?
In theory there is a network effect. If it got popular enough, there is a possibility that major operating systems or browsers or recursive nameservers might start supporting one of the alternatives, which is never going to happen with your bespoke individual domain name.
Regardless of your grievences with ICANN, nearly universal consensus is almost certainly worth the price of using an ICANN delegated top level domain.