News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Institutions try to preserve the problem to which they ar... by WalterBright on Saturday February 24, 2024 @04:05PM (#39495138)
And yet the free Northern economy buried the slave Southern economy. How does that fit into your theory? And how the entire country boomed after slavery was abolished?

Free economies always outperform slave labor, by a large margin.

> Technological development

Oddly enough, happens first in free market countries. Turns out, you can't build a technological economy using slaves.

The Caribbean countries would be prosperous if they'd try free markets instead of socialism and communism.

Re:Institutions try to preserve the problem to which they ar... by lazide on Saturday February 24, 2024 @04:42PM (#39495383)
Huh?

The northern economy was MORE CLOSED than the South. For one, they banned slavery first. They had more import/export controls.

The south was as free and open* as you could imagine - anyone with the Capital could buy a slave, or sell goods, etc.

Trade was minimally restricted.

(* Notably, if you were a "free man". Slaves, Women, Children, and sometimes Indentured Servants all had significant restrictions on rights across the board in both locations that were very similar - both de jure and de facto).

The North were the ones blockading the South, not the other way around.

[https://history.state.gov/milestones/1861-1865/blockade]

The current Caribbean countries are also currently free markets? At least from what I can see.

Plenty of 'international banking' in many of them too.

Haiti finally paid off the restitution the French have been making them pay since the slave revolt back in 1947 [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haiti_Independence_Debt], and seem to be slowly gaining ground again.

The Dominican Republic (on the same island, other side of the fence, different government due to a revolt in the ~1850's) has been doing quite well for a long time, I think partially because they don't have to pay that debt back, being a "different country" and all. And they generally don't have the various travel blacklists that Haiti has had.

I suspect the argument you're trying to make is that mechanization/automation (and it's helpful companion, Capitalism) beats slavery.

Which I definitely agree with. One beneficial advantage being that it frees up people to do more thinking (and less, well, slaving away) and benefits significantly from economies of scale - both for the Capitalists, and everyone else. Which is why inventing is so useful (when it won't get stomped on by monopolies, anyway).

So it's mostly a beneficial cycle, as long as monopolist tendencies get reined in and someone is watching things to ensure it doesn't get too abusive. Unlike Slavery.

Slavery is also despicable in general, so I personally am glad to see it gone.

Free/Open/Closed/Restricted markets are not necessarily good or bad, independent of the circumstances - same as guns, IMO. They do have predictable outcomes, if used in predictable ways though.

The more closed, the more problematic IMO, but I have yet to see a truly open market (aka a black market, perhaps?) without some really nasty abuses of it's own. So YMMV.

Re:Institutions try to preserve the problem to which they ar... by WalterBright on Saturday February 24, 2024 @05:31PM (#39495723)
You keep trying to equate slavery with freedom and prosperity. It doesn't work. Forced labor is not free labor, and slaves are significantly less productive than free labor, for obvious reasons.

The Southerners used slaves for cotton and tobacco farming. It was the only industry that could eke out a profit with them, and even that was failing by the 1850s.

The Northern economy BURIED the Southern one. That's why the South wanted to secede. It wanted to protect itself from the North. The North also won the war because they enormously outproduced the South in arms, uniforms, railroads, food, everything needed to fight.

The reason for the Gettysburg battle was Lee was headed for Harrisburg to loot the shoe factory there, because the Confederate army was barefoot.

Re:Institutions try to preserve the problem to which they ar... by lazide on Saturday February 24, 2024 @05:51PM (#39495874)
Except I’m literally not?

Maybe you should actually read my comment?

They were fundamentally different, that’s the point. Just not in the way you seem to keep trying to say it is.

Industrialization and automation wins over slavery.

Which is a good thing! And literally what I said in my comment.

Re:Institutions try to preserve the problem to which they ar... by WalterBright on Saturday February 24, 2024 @06:48PM (#39496192)
Free markets win over slavery even in a pre-industrial society.

Consider that no country that had slave agriculture has ever been able to feed itself. Even with tractors.

Re:Institutions try to preserve the problem to which they ar... by lazide on Saturday February 24, 2024 @08:57PM (#39496899)
The Roman Empire? [https://www.bartleby.com/essay/The-Roles-Of-Ancient-Roman-Sl.... ]

Spartans and the Helots? [https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helots]

Plus a dozen other examples from antiquity and recent history - including the Confederate states before the blockades and sanctions due to their use of slavery.

What are you even talking about?

Re:Institutions try to preserve the problem to which they ar... by WalterBright on Sunday February 25, 2024 @08:43PM (#39506807)
From your cite:

"An estimate of the slave population in the middle of the second century, when the Republic was at its peak, was over fifteen percent"

The Romans couldn't have produced enough food with only 15% of the population. Not even close.

As for the Spartans and the Helots, isn't it interesting you have to go back 2000 years to a society of which very little is known? Spartans left behind very little writing, what we know of it comes from their enemies.

The Confederacy used slaves for cotton and tobacco, not produce.

Re:Institutions try to preserve the problem to which they ar... by lazide on Monday February 26, 2024 @08:44PM (#39519058)
Lol. From the beginning of my cite

"Slaves increased the economy, fed the entire republic through agriculture, and they also upheld important roles and was the glue that held Ancient Rome together. Slaves played a huge roll in Ancient Rome and was the reason for the great economy and without the slaves Rome would not have been as powerful as it was. "

Total US employment in the food industry (not just farms) is 10% of US employment, and only 5.5% of GDP.

Slavery is terrible. But pretending humans haven't used it (successfully) to run civilizations at scale is just being willfully obtuse.

Goodbye.