News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by 15457345234 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @05:19PM (#39474121)
> Public = consent for the public to see it. That includes the public on Bluesky.

What? No.

If I put stuff on _my_ server you aren't automatically allowed to rehost it on _your_ server. Pretty much automatically a copyright violation in just about every viable jurisdiction.

Basic stuff here

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by rglullis on Thursday February 22, 2024 @06:03PM (#39474567)
No, not "basic" stuff at all. It's not only "allowed", federation works exactly by replicating all the activities from the remote servers and even the images you share. If you don't believe it, just go ahead and see what happens when you repost a message from someone's server. The repost will come from your server, not the original creator. Or try deleting a conversation on your server and notice how the other instances will still keep everything intact.

Also, what would be the problem if you put content on your server and someone downloads it and holds a copy? No one is redistributing your content trying to pass it as their own. Attribution is still preserved. What is the copyright violation here?

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by Repulsion9513 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @06:23PM (#39474764)
> If you don't believe it, just go ahead and see what happens when you repost a message from someone's server

It's not just reposts. The original post itself is served to viewers by their instance, which is redistribution. (To do otherwise would actually be a massive privacy - and security - concern.)

(To be clear, media - but not the post itself - can be requested directly from the original instance, but any reputable instance will be running a proxy so that random strangers can't trivially get your IP address...)

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by Repulsion9513 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @05:24PM (#39474174)
When you share a public post on Mastodon, you are by implication licensing that content for redistribution. Because other Mastodon servers have to redistribute it in order for anyone on another instance to see it. Hope that helps you understand the basic stuff here.

(Either that or every Mastodon server in existence is a massive copyright violation, which is frankly quite possible given how bad copyright law is)

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by Angostura on Thursday February 22, 2024 @07:41PM (#39475407)
> When you share a public post on Mastodon, you are by implication licensing that content for redistribution….

… on Mastodon

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by icehawk on Thursday February 22, 2024 @08:14PM (#39475655)
...on a server that speaks ActivityPub. Mastodon is one such piece of software.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by Angostura on Saturday February 24, 2024 @05:26PM (#39495689)
Yup, thank you for the correction
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by Repulsion9513 on Friday February 23, 2024 @03:43AM (#39478336)
The common term for the network formed by software speaking ActivityPub is "Mastodon", despite that formally being the name of a single piece of that software. Do you also have a problem with Pleroma or Akkoma or whatever? If not then this isn't relevant.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by kstrauser on Thursday February 22, 2024 @06:01PM (#39474550)
I’m a sucker for a particular mix of condescending plus wrong.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by rglullis on Thursday February 22, 2024 @06:12PM (#39474647)
Except they are not wrong. Maybe not in the specifics but in general this is exactly how AP-servers work. If you are on server A and follow someone on server B, then the posts from B will be on your server and there is absolutely no way that the "original owner" of the post on server B to remove the post from A.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by Repulsion9513 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @06:21PM (#39474742)
So am I, that's why I replied to the people who were condescending plus wrong :)
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by TylerE on Thursday February 22, 2024 @08:49PM (#39475901)
This is more like when you send an email to gmail.com, Google is allowed to forward the message to its intended recipient.