News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by bayindirh on Thursday February 22, 2024 @01:57PM (#39471427)
Does that mean after Bluesky reaches critical mass, it'll turn the federation off, like Google Chat killing its XMPP federation?

For clarity: I'd love to see this comment and say "I was wrong" 5 or 10 years later.

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by jakebsky on Thursday February 22, 2024 @01:58PM (#39471448)
The network is designed to be "locked open" in a way that prevents this. The architecture is designed to work like the web.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by Repulsion9513 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @05:04PM (#39473950)
> A central directory server collects and validates operations, and maintains a transparent log of operations for each DID.

(https://github.com/did-method-plc/did-method-plc/blob/main/R... linked from https://docs.bsky.app/blog/self-host-federation)

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by yupyup54133 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @02:06PM (#39471544)
Nothing against Bluesky, but I think we are all a little jaded after seeing decades of the "embrace, extend, extinguish" pattern.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by steveklabnik on Thursday February 22, 2024 @02:08PM (#39471575)
Being jaded is understandable, but because this critique is generic, it is applicable to literally anything and everything. I don't see how you can ever get something that's considered good if you always assume it will turn into something bad regardless of its current stance.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by itsanaccount on Thursday February 22, 2024 @02:17PM (#39471686)
Thats easy, you don't have a structure made with a single large actor capable of changing the rules of the game mid flight.

You get something good system by sharing power, not by once again falling for "trust us bro." You get it by understanding power imbalances and avoiding them the same way my dog avoids objects with large amounts of potential energy, because they're predictably dangerous.

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by steveklabnik on Thursday February 22, 2024 @02:31PM (#39471857)
I understand this, yet, when presented with exactly this, the response was "well what about EEE."
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by preciousoo on Thursday February 22, 2024 @03:03PM (#39472332)
The protocol and hosting mechanisms are open source. There’s one actor currently sure, but it seems like bluesky is not holding onto that.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by mcherm on Friday February 23, 2024 @05:49AM (#39479101)
So presumably today's announcement that they are now supporting self-hosted instances is welcome news to you -- it is a huge stride in the direction you are advocating for.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by bayindirh on Thursday February 22, 2024 @02:12PM (#39471631)
Actually it's very hard, and becomes tiring after some point. I personally always keep a hope that I'll be wrong in the long run.

Sometimes I'm spot on, sometimes I stand corrected. The problem is, as time goes, your free time reserve starts to decline. You optimize things, consolidate services, etc., and these kind of migrations start to take tons of time.

Because of this, I gave "big web" up and moved to "small web", and always have plans to evacuate any service in a moment's notice.

It's like being a doomsday-preparer from a point, but at least I have backups and backup plans for everything.

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by lolinder on Thursday February 22, 2024 @02:07PM (#39471564)
This would be more "create, extinguish", because there's no existing AT protocol network to embrace.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by hardcopy on Thursday February 22, 2024 @02:12PM (#39471634)
"embrace" would be the rise of decentralized social media
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by lolinder on Thursday February 22, 2024 @02:15PM (#39471664)
If there can exist an "extinguish" step for the concept of decentralized social media itself then decentralized social media has already failed. The whole point is supposed to be about changing hearts and minds to embrace self-governance, a rug pull should just result in people moving somewhere else.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by secstate on Thursday February 22, 2024 @03:11PM (#39472444)
But that's sort of why Bluesky is not really decentralized, just federated. It's a pretty significant difference. Mastodon is federated and decentralized. Twitter is non-federated and centralized. Bluesky is trying to be the federated, centralized option.

Whether that works, we'll see. I for one just gave up social media about 8 years ago and, while feeling like I'm missing something flares up from time to time, it's nothing like the disaster my online life was before I gave it up. It wasn't a problem of missing federation or not being centralized. It was inherent to the way social media functions against my person.

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by steveklabnik on Thursday February 22, 2024 @03:16PM (#39472521)
How is BlueSky centralized? I could see that argument before this feature shipped, but "BlueSky is trying to be the federated, centralized option" goes counter to what the team has said directly.

I could maybe see an argument not based on technical premises, but instead something like "it will defacto become one because running a relay is too expensive" or such. Is that what you're going for?

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by Balladeer on Thursday February 22, 2024 @03:53PM (#39473066)
I'm not who you replied to, but yes, that's my main concern: Bluesky is still a company building a thing to pay back the money it owes investors.

I worry that Bluesky becomes the de facto central actor and, due to having no stated business plan and a countdown to repay the money they took, pulls a Google, leveraging its dominance to introduce proprietary, breaking changes.

Yes, right now, the tech, team, interviews, etc sound mission-driven, but "revenue is the dominant term"[2] in the equation of a company's life, and there's still a very real chance that Bluesky dominates whatever federated AT Protocol network ends up forming, then uses that leverage to walk back all this promised openness.

I'm cautiously interested in Bluesky, but I'm watching for this kind of de facto dominance and we're probably too early on to see where the AT network is headed.

- [1] https://somehowmanage.com/2020/09/20/revenue-model-not-cultu...

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by secstate on Thursday February 22, 2024 @09:48PM (#39476374)
Yes. In the sense that Mastodon is decentralized because there is no one Mastodon server. One may accumulate more users or be the "default" for the community of users, but there is no Mastodon server (much to the chagrin of many new users).

We don't even need the hypothetical "it will defacto become..." because Bluesky Social was, up till now, the ONLY way to participate in the community. They had 3 million users before federation, and now we can start to hook into what they've built, but the idea from the start was clearly not built around federation and decentralization, otherwise it would have been federated from day one, as Mastodon was. They can HOPE now, that people accept the federation concept, but there's enough gnashing of teeth around the pain of running Mastodon instance that it seems really clear that going from central to decentral is, if we're being intellectually honest, a bridge too far for most to cross.

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by mort96 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @03:22PM (#39472616)
How can it "lock open"? If 90+% of users are on the official bluesky servers, what could possibly technically prevent bluesky from just no longer federating with other hosts?
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by jorams on Thursday February 22, 2024 @03:09PM (#39472416)
In the same way that Google stopped federating by no longer accepting connections from others, as long as most people keep their stuff at Bluesky they can also just close themselves off from others again. I don't necessarily think it is a big risk, but the only reason the web is resilient to this is that no single ISP controls enough of the network to take it "private".

Basically, until atproto is much bigger than bsky.app, the situation is not very different.

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by micromacrofoot on Thursday February 22, 2024 @02:32PM (#39471877)
what binds this? I have no interest in joining if Jack can sell to Elon again and a switch gets flipped
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by steveklabnik on Thursday February 22, 2024 @02:42PM (#39472024)
That specific scenario is impossible, in my understanding, because Jack does not have an ownership stake in the company.

This release, of federation, is in my mind a major answer to the real question you're asking, which is the same but with "the employees" instead of "Jack," as they have the equity stake.

Once things are federated, other folks gain power over the protocol, by virtue of usage. If Bluesky PBLLC starts to do shady things, the other instances can refuse to do so, and talk to each other instead.

This is why the split between AT and BlueSky is important, and why this news matters, as it is meaningfully delivering on the desire to protect against such a thing.

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by micromacrofoot on Thursday February 22, 2024 @02:54PM (#39472194)
Right I didn't mean to get into the business aspect, but essentially "what prevents someone from undoing this for money." Thanks for the detail.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by steveklabnik on Thursday February 22, 2024 @03:04PM (#39472351)
It's all good. The Jack thing is, in my mind, a bit sensitive, because a lot of people criticizing BlueSky talk as though Jack runs the place, owns it, etc, all of which seems factually incorrect. He has a board seat, but seemingly cares about it so little that he deleted his account. From what I hear, nostr is his focus, but I'm not on there so I can't speak to that personally.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by mort96 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @03:25PM (#39472663)
Jack has certainly been successful in building a general perception that bsky is "the Twitter founder's" next social network project, intentionally or otherwise
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by mdasen on Thursday February 22, 2024 @05:28PM (#39474205)
The issue here is that if 99% of people use BlueSky and 1% use non-BlueSky AtProto servers, that leaves BlueSky with all the power to turn off federation. If BlueSky starts to do shady things, other instances can refuse and talk to each other instead - and eliminate 99% of your followers, 99% of the people you're following, etc.

Email is open, but if GMail decides to block all email from you, you're toast. And while GMail is large, their percentage of email inboxes pales in comparison to BlueSky's percentage of AtProto users (which is near 100% at the moment).

Yes, once things are federated, other folks start gaining some power over the protocol by virtue of usage. However, if 99% of people remain with BlueSky, everyone else essentially has no power.

mastodon.social has around 15% of the Fediverse on its server and it means that it has a lot of power. Mastodon (the software) is around 72% of the Fediverse which means that other ActivityPub software essentially has to use Mastodon-flavored ActivityPub with whatever quirks might exist in Mastodon. But that's still way less power than BlueSky has in the AtProto ecosystem.

Open protocols are only good as long as there's enough reason for lots of different parties to keep those lines of communication open. mastodon.social needs to keep supporting ActivityPub because they'd lose 85% of their network if they stopped. Let's say it's 2030 and AtProto has 500M users and 99% of them are using BlueSky. BlueSky could simply turn off all the AtProto endpoints and make their web and mobile apps use proprietary endpoints. I'm not saying they'd do that, but they certainly could. Now, if 2030 comes around and there are 500M AtProto users and 10% of them are on BlueSky, then it wouldn't really be possible for BlueSky to turn off AtProto. They'd lose 90% of their network.

But we don't know if AtProto will catch on outside of BlueSky or if BlueSky will remain the vast majority of the network. If there isn't a lot of use outside of BlueSky, there could come a day when it's very tempting to turn it off - or do something that isn't quite turning it off, but would effectively accomplish it. Maybe they just start making breaking changes to AtProto, rolling it out, and documenting the change a week later and third parties just end up unreliable and people migrate off them. There's lots of options.

Five years from now, how is BlueSky making money? Are they just storing, processing, and serving lots of content without good monetization as third party apps start grabbing users and making money off their servers? I mean, we saw what Reddit and Twitter did. If BlueSky controls 99% of AtProto users, they can turn the firehose off. Even if they aren't trying to be evil or maximize their revenue, at some point they need money for all those engineers and servers. Maybe the official BlueSky app will be popular enough for them to get some ad revenue there and not feel the need to go after third party apps. Maybe a lot of things.

But until BlueSky is a minority of AtProto users/posts/etc., it's still something they have a lot of power over - including the power to pivot BlueSky off AtProto and make BlueSky a proprietary network.

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by steveklabnik on Thursday February 22, 2024 @05:35PM (#39474276)
For sure. One nice thing about AT's design is that, if they do, you can take your posts over to some other host, and it'll all Just Work. True account portability makes that kind of power grab harder. Of course, that would require users to actually move, which is not a given.

Time will tell!

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by stonogo on Thursday February 22, 2024 @09:21PM (#39476160)
So is Signal, and yet here we are
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by torginus on Friday February 23, 2024 @06:38AM (#39479399)
You are not in control of what you see in your feed, it's the algorithm that chooses for you. So while technically all kinds of content can exist, most users will only see what's officially approved.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by steveklabnik on Friday February 23, 2024 @12:25PM (#39483510)
BlueSky literally allows for users to create their own feeds with whatever algorithms they want, and to share them with others. You can follow them as easily as you can follow an account. I'm already following several.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by rsynnott on Thursday February 22, 2024 @02:27PM (#39471808)
That would only work if Bluesky stays the only significant network node. Which is _possible_, but we haven't seen it with, say, Mastodon. Google Chat was arguably a bit of a special case; vast majority of users never used federation at all, whereas any Bluesky user will, pretty much, just by naturally using Bluesky.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by treyd on Thursday February 22, 2024 @04:36PM (#39473616)
It worked with Mastodon because it was diverse and well-distributed from the beginning even when it was young. I'm skeptical that other people are going to run their own BS servers at scale now that it's been normalized to always just use the firstparty one.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by wmf on Thursday February 22, 2024 @04:56PM (#39473857)
If they really want to they can fix this by closing the central server.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by treyd on Thursday February 22, 2024 @06:05PM (#39474584)
They would never do that since BS has VCs to answer to now.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by wmf on Thursday February 22, 2024 @07:59PM (#39475534)
It depends on their business model. Maybe running the server can't make money anyway.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by Eric_WVGG on Thursday February 22, 2024 @02:28PM (#39471813)
… and if not, what the heck is the business model here?
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by steveklabnik on Thursday February 22, 2024 @02:32PM (#39471876)
BlueSky's first revenue generation (in my understanding, I don't work there) has been a partnership with NameCheap that makes it easy for non-technical users to purchase a domain name and use it as their BlueSky username.

They have been a bit vague about other ways to generate revenue, except in one case: they will not be using advertisements to monetize.

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by threeseed on Thursday February 22, 2024 @02:44PM (#39472054)
That business model is laughable. The percentage of users who care about a domain name, are willing to pay a subscription for it and don't have one already has to be in the single digits.

They better have a good answer to this because it's a threat to the ecosystem as a whole if they don't. Because relying on VC money in this environment is not the smartest thing to do.

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by steveklabnik on Thursday February 22, 2024 @02:47PM (#39472083)
I would agree that if that were "the business model" instead of "a thing that generates some revenue," it would be laughable. However, nobody, including BlueSky, believes that this is solely enough to power the business.

I agree that a healthy Bluesky PBLLC is a good thing, and hope they manage to pull it off. Time will tell.

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by threeseed on Thursday February 22, 2024 @02:57PM (#39472225)
Well hopefully they take it more seriously.

Because based on them raising $8m in a seed round middle of last year they aren't going to have much time to decide and implement a strategy before they will need to start thinking about raising a Series A. Or maybe Jack does become a bigger investor.

Either way I think it's insane to prematurely rule out advertising.

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by steveklabnik on Thursday February 22, 2024 @03:03PM (#39472318)
I don't think they're not taking it seriously.

I also don't believe (and again, don't work there, just a huge fan, so maybe this is wrong) I'm not sure that the revenue was the reason for shipping this feature. It's best thought of as an accessibility feature, for folks who do not know what a "DNS record" is and have never hosted a domain. Without this, more technical users get something special that non-technical users do not: a nicer username. The money is just a side effect of the fact that purchasing a domain name already requires money, and so a partnership with a revenue split just makes sense.

> Either way I think it's insane to prematurely rule out advertising.

I hear you in an abstract "that's the way you make money in this space" sense, but I also think it's a smart reaction to the public sentiment around this stuff. People do not like advertising. It is a differentiator. We'll see if it works out for them or not.

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by layer8 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @03:07PM (#39472385)
The whole point of Bluesky is to build a social network that is not incentivized by advertising. They don’t rule it out completely, but it can’t be a major part of their revenue.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by steveklabnik on Thursday February 22, 2024 @03:10PM (#39472432)
> They don’t rule it out completely,

Well,

> Are you thinking about advertisements at all?

>

> There will always be free options, and we can't enshittify the network with ads. This is where federation comes in. The fact that anyone can self-host and anyone can build on the software means that we'll never be able to degrade the user experience in a way where people want to leave.

https://www.wired.com/story/bluesky-ceo-jay-graber-wont-ensh...

This reads as definitive to me personally.

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by layer8 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @03:18PM (#39472560)
In their business-plan post, they stated: “We set out to build a protocol where users can own their data and always have the freedom to leave, and this approach means that advertising couldn’t be our dominant business model.” Which reads like advertising could still be a possibility, but not as a dominant factor.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by steveklabnik on Thursday February 22, 2024 @03:20PM (#39472585)
Fair!
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by Repulsion9513 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @05:07PM (#39473984)
> enshittify with ads

> we'll never be able to degrade the user experience in a way where people want to leave

Neither of those is the same as "no ads". They're just saying that they can't make the ads so bad that most people want to leave, because then people will leave and the ads won't be shown to anyone.

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by jakebsky on Thursday February 22, 2024 @05:21PM (#39474132)
Reddit destroyed Apollo so they could inject ads into the Reddit experience.

Bluesky doesn't have the ability to do this. There's no API key to revoke that could stop someone else from running parallel apps/infrastructure/etc. The network is completely open.

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by Repulsion9513 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @05:22PM (#39474147)
Reddit had ads long before they destroyed Apollo. Thanks for providing additional evidence for my point.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by jakebsky on Thursday February 22, 2024 @05:33PM (#39474258)
Sure, but Apollo made it easy for users that didn't want ads to use Reddit without them. Destroying Apollo removed that ability for most people.

I'm about as anti-ads as it gets but I don't object to other people using apps with ads in them, if that's their choice.

Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by layer8 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @03:00PM (#39472279)
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by 12345hn6789 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @08:43PM (#39475858)
Ads.
Re:Bluesky announces data federation for self hosters by nomdep on Thursday February 22, 2024 @08:56PM (#39475950)
If they can do that, then the whole federation idea is useless and just a theatre. But I don’t think Bluesky will ever reach critical mass anyway.