Re:Teen Subcultures Are Fading. Pity the Poor Kids
by silverquiet on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @10:42AM
(#39455168)
I don't think I've ever really gotten the whole teenage rebellion thing; don't most people grow up and emulate the religion, politics, and lifestyle (education, career type, marriage preference, etc..) as their parents?
Re:Teen Subcultures Are Fading. Pity the Poor Kids
by jl6 on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @11:01AM
(#39455460)
Rebellion can mean a lot of different things. Mostly it amounts to opposition in a fairly superficial sense. Different clothes, different haircut, different music, maybe some intentional bad choices... But although these things are high-visibility, they're not that fundamental to identity and culture. It's rare for kids to completely cut ties with the fundamentals (i.e. all the things you mention) of their parents, particularly now when kids are still dependent on their parents for longer into adulthood.
Re:Teen Subcultures Are Fading. Pity the Poor Kids
by SauciestGNU on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @11:09AM
(#39455592)
For me it was self-exploration and exploring the fringes of my identity using psychedelics and other drugs that my parents didn't particularly approve of. For some of my friends it was sexual identity (which was much more taboo than today). In general I think "rebellion" is the consequence of becoming a fully aware individual capable of independence from parents. Parents want to exert control over their teens, teens want to have agency over their lives, and the conflict between those two positions is framed as "rebellion".
Re:Teen Subcultures Are Fading. Pity the Poor Kids
by Anotheroneagain on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @11:17AM
(#39455700)
"Teenage rebellion" isn't natural, it first happened to the boomer generation, and is generally unknown and not expected outside the western world.
The associated smell is also not natural.
Re:Teen Subcultures Are Fading. Pity the Poor Kids
by dihydro on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @11:44AM
(#39456100)
Elders have complained about the impetus of youth for longer than the boomers.
"The young people of today think of nothing but themselves. They have no reverence for parents or old age. They are impatient of all restraint ... As for the girls, they are forward, immodest and unladylike in speech, behaviour and dress." - Peter the Hermit, 1274
Re:Teen Subcultures Are Fading. Pity the Poor Kids
by Anotheroneagain on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @02:41PM
(#39458496)
Those quotes are made up, though I didn't mean it couldn't have happened before, but in recent history. It was obviously not expected then and their parents had no idea how to deal with it.
Re:Teen Subcultures Are Fading. Pity the Poor Kids
by pkoird on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @11:51AM
(#39456193)
If you think about it, teenage rebellion makes sense from an evolutionary perspective as it encourages a subgroup (teenagers) to explore outside whatever's the norm (aka adults). I wrote more about it in my blog post:
https://praveshkoirala.com/2023/05/31/teenage-rebellion-is-j...
[dead]
Re:Teen Subcultures Are Fading. Pity the Poor Kids
by whythre on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @10:59AM
(#39455429)
I… what? Lead deficient? I know some people are iron deficient, but I have never heard of iron poisoning or suffering from lead deficiency.
Re:Teen Subcultures Are Fading. Pity the Poor Kids
by Anotheroneagain on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @11:03AM
(#39455472)
Almost nobody is iron deficient, the supposedly healthy levels are made up. You are iron poisoned if you reach them.
Lead, mercury and cadmium toxicity is made up. Copper is accepted as essential, but treated as a toxin in practice. Its deficiency causesAlzheimer's.
Re:Teen Subcultures Are Fading. Pity the Poor Kids
by jvanderbot on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @10:36AM
(#39455077)
Both your interpretations support the premise of the article: subcultures are disappearing and we should pity those kids.
Re:Teen Subcultures Are Fading. Pity the Poor Kids
by Anotheroneagain on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @10:40AM
(#39455127)
They were carefully constructed by the adults around you, only not by your parents.
This is the opposite of my memory of being a teenager. Teenagers, as a rule, are actively seeking to define their identity independent of the adults around them. The subcultures of our teenagehood weren't carefully constructed extracurriculars that our parents prepared for us, they were formed organically by the kids themselves, and they were subcultures intentionally crafted to exclude the adults in our lives. My dad was big into football, so my brother and I went all-in on the nerd culture. My dad didn't get D&D and MTG and fantasy novels any more than this mom gets what her daughter is participating in, and that was part of the point.
Teenagers are kids who have hit the age where the modern, hovering parenting style completely falls apart. They're not living in your world anymore because their hormones are telling them it's time to forge their own path. It's time to begin to let go, not attempt to craft a better subculture scene for them.