News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The day I canceled my Spotify subscription by lawgimenez on Monday February 19, 2024 @06:08AM (#39428440)
> The flip-side is that most of those metal bands now make almost no money on people listening to their music compared to what they did when they sold CDs through a lot of indie record companies.

I was a roadie on my friend's metal band around 2000-ish, they were not in any record company and just sold their CDs through DIY, during live shows, word of mouth, etc. My point is not all bands are in a record company, most are just doing it via DIY. Now, these indie, DIY bands, whatever you call it can now upload and share their music worldwide. That's a huge win.

Re:The day I canceled my Spotify subscription by crtasm on Monday February 19, 2024 @09:37AM (#39430167)
A win for availability and potential audience, but if it causes less people to buy your CD/USB stick/whatever at shows - perhaps a significant reduction on income for the majority of gigging bands?

Do any of the streaming platforms let you direct fans to your own website/Bandcamp to make a purchase?

Re:The day I canceled my Spotify subscription by StackRanker3000 on Monday February 19, 2024 @11:31AM (#39431644)
Are more or less acts making a living off their music now or back then? Absolute numbers and percentage-wise?

How do we decide what number is "fair", or what we as a society want? Surely it's not reasonable that every band that's just started out in a garage should be making bank.

I don't think that it's more difficult to be a professional musical artist or musician today than it used to be, although the business model may be different. But even if it is, I think that's a decent compromise for all the benefits the streaming services bring.

Re:The day I canceled my Spotify subscription by crtasm on Monday February 19, 2024 @05:09PM (#39435427)
My understanding is that essentially zero DIY indie bands are making notable amounts from streaming payouts.